3 ms·
I suppose then that Theranos was never really viable based on the technology back then, as this seems to use "next-generation sequencing" tech.
by satvikpendem 3y ago
I suppose then that Theranos was never really viable based on the technology back then, as this seems to use "next-generation sequencing" tech.
- tptacek 3y agoIt looks like Invitae is a full blood draw, done with a phlebotomist, not a microfluidic pin-prick invention.
- inglor_cz 3y agoWhat Theranos did was like promising a ticket to the Moon for 50 dollars one way. No one doubts that you can fly to the Moon for 50 billion dollars. Perhaps, in the future, it will be feasible to fly there for 5 million dollars. But 50 dollars is beyond the realms of possibility.
- TylerE 3y agoI have serious doubts that any individual or company, starting from scratch not having previously built rockets, gets to the moon on $50b, especially with any sort of safety margin built in.
- Centigonal 3y agoEven if they had a "perfect" analyzer, that could tell them all about every atom in the sample, Theranos's test still wouldn't have worked. This is because Theranos's product wasn't just claiming to look at DNA. It claimed to measure things like cholesterol levels and pregnancy hormones, molecules that are circulating in the blood - all with a pinprick of fluid. If you had a "perfect" analyzer, you would need just one cell to get someone's full genetic code. However, something like blood cholesterol is a statistical average - you need to take enough blood to ensure that the percentage of cholesterol in the sample is reasonably close to the percentage in the patient. It's a population sampling problem (same as how you wouldn't be able to predict a senate election by polling 50 people on who they were going to vote for, even if you could ensure they were 100% truthful with you - it's just not enough people). No tech can get around that.
- evandijk70 3y ago'Next-generation sequencing' was arguably invented in 2000, so it would have been available for Theranos. However, AFAIK they never really tried to sequence DNA, so the availability of 'next-generation sequencing' was irrelevant to the accuracy of their test.