8 ms·
Algebra is incredibly important, because it teaches students to manipulate truths using symbols. It is a tool which improves thought.
by kazinator 3y ago
Algebra is incredibly important, because it teaches students to manipulate truths using symbols. It is a tool which improves thought.
- robot_no_421 3y agoIt's way, way more than just a tool that improves thought. It's a necessary tool to organize your life. How can you even budget or use a credit card responsibly if you don't know algebra? You need algebra to know how long a paycheck can last you. My dad didn't graduate high school and even he knew enough algebra to work out how much money he needed a month for cigarettes (until he eventually quit once he really thought about the numbers).
- kazinator 3y agoThat's a good question. Historic human societies without algebra somehow had working bean counting. Using a credit card isn't very abstract. You only have to use the concrete specific values in your situation, and not solve some generality. Moreover, I don't think I had to ever square anything, let alone, cube, when reckoning over credit card transactions. Or find the roots of a polynomial, or do anything with polynomials. I'm not saying that the intuitions gained from algebra are not relevant, mind you.
- robot_no_421 3y ago> Using a credit card isn't very abstract. To use a credit card responsibly you need to understand the concept of exponential growth, or you might accidentally turn a manageable $500 debt into a burdensome $5000 debt. Same goes for understanding good debt (mortgages) vs bad debt. It might not be solving a polynomial per se, but I don't see how you get to understanding exponential equations without at least understanding algebra.
- taeric 3y agoThere is understanding the concept of exponential growth, and there is being able to manage it. They are two skills. Where management is helped more by having resources than it is by understanding it.
- robot_no_421 3y ago>Where management is helped more by having resources than it is by understanding it. There are many examples of lottery winners, athletes, and celebrities who came across considerable resources yet still went broke because they didn't understand how to manage it or the concept of exponential growth. A fool and his money are easily parted, as the saying goes. People who don't have financial literacy will lose their money over and over again regardless of how much you give them.
- taeric 3y agoThere are, but there are also plenty of examples of lottery winners, athletes, and celebrities that came across considerable resources and then lived quite well on said resources. Probably more of those, but the stories are far less dramatic. You are also picking a category of people that come across enough resources that make them a target to plenty of others. Such that it is almost an adversarial game, at that point.
- robot_no_421 3y ago>Probably more of those, but the stories are far less dramatic. Evidence shows that having an excess of resources actually leads to more financial irresponsibly, not less. Or as the Illustrious Notorious B.I.G. eloquently put it: "mo money, mo problems": "The CFP Board of Standards says nearly one-third of lottery winners eventually declare bankruptcy, and lottery winners are more likely to declare bankruptcy within three to five years than the average American." https://www.ngpf.org/blog/question-of-the-day/question-of-the-day-what-percent-of-lottery-winners-eventually-go-bankrupt/#:~:text=The%20CFP%20Board%20of%20Standards,reckless%20with%20their%20newfound%20wealth https://www.ngpf.org/blog/question-of-the-day/question-of-th....
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoNot entirely true. I have multiple credit cards and use them for everything, yet I've never ran into exponential growth. I don't spend money I don't have. It's really simple math this way.
- robot_no_421 3y agoI'd argue that you're not really using the credit on your credit card as a credit card. You're using it as a charge card. Exponential growth is a fundamental concept of financial literacy. If you want to invest in the stock market or plan your 401k it helps to understand exponential growth. The reason why it's impossible to get rich off a wage is because of the difference between exponential vs linear growth. >I don't spend money I don't have. You've never taken out a mortgage or opened a margin account? Plenty of responsible people make money by spending money they don't have every day.
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoSorry, yes. I do spend money I don't have, just not in the context of credit cards, as they have terrible interest rates. I go to the banker to get a loan.
- recursive 3y agoI don't think you really need abstract representations to do basic budgeting. Adding and subtracting concrete quantities can get you pretty far.
- kazinator 3y agoWhen it comes to spending money on credit, you need an intuition for running sums. This lets you maintain an estimate in your head tracking how much you charged on the card. People without that intuition are surprised at how fast the little charges added up to an unexpectedly large sum. But I only spent a hundred here or there; how did it blow past $4700?
- gsinclair 3y ago> But I only spent a hundred here or there; how did it blow past $4700? This is basic human frailty and completely orthogonal to mathematical ability.
- Loocid 3y agoI'm a big proponent for math education but I don't think budgeting or dealing with credit cards requires anything past basic arithmetic.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bmitc 3y agoAnd at the basic level, it almost isn't even mathematics. It's basically more applied logic. The whole "I'm bad at mathematics" schtick oft repeated at the high school level and below can be translated into "I'm bad at basic logic and reasoning", which makes the gap much more real and apparent. Mathematics is not some magical piece of knowledge that needs all sorts machinations to teach. Like any subject, it should be moved away from rote teaching and into projects and applications rather than mindnumbing exercises.
- kazinator 3y agoIt's only because of the mindnumbing exercises that you can sit down with a pen and paper, and use algebra to solve something, when you're 45 years old. :)
- blacksmith_tb 3y agoYou mean if there's no internet connection for wolframalpha? I half-kid, obviously if you don't understand what you're asking for the best software in the world won't give you the right answer, but I also don't find myself solving equations with a pen very often as an adult...
- singleshot_ 3y agoA running joke in law school was “lawyers are bad at math, so who cares if I am innumerate?” which, in light of your translation is pretty alarming.
- bmitc 3y agoAs someone with a background in mathematics that had to deal with lawyers, regarding something as mundane as buying a house, I would say that they indeed do not operate on logic and reasoning. I mean no personal offense, since you mention you attended law school. It was just very eye opening how much of a constructed language lawyers speak. In dealing with contracts, I found that the contract itself was effectively meaningless. The important part were its interpretations and what could be litigated or not, mainly set by precedent. It was such that no application of logic and reason could be applied to the contract. Not to mention, I had to correct several mistakes in the contract.
- ekm2 3y agoCombinatorics can do that even better,minus the memorization.
- kazinator 3y agoAlgebraic formulas show up in combinatorics. For instance, expressions which count objects in a certain set generated by combinatoric relationships. There is probably no need to delay studying some combinatorics before algebra, but at some point, you need the algebraic background.
- ekm2 3y agoActually,combinatorial thinking is more useful for understanding Algebra and not the other way around.Key word is understanding.No need for a beautiful formula you cannot understand.
- neonsunset 3y agoIt is. Unfortunately, at school the subject of Algebra simply shares the name, being a tool of choice to drill rote repetition into the students.
- rhuru 3y ago"manipulating truths using symbols" you say, they can get $2M media studies degree to do that as well.
- akomtu 3y agoIndeed, that's the second layer of meaning. Yet another meaning is that in eastern philosophy, mastering symbols is how one develops the higher abstract mind, so it can see truths directly, rather than relying on the rational mind that's called "the destroyer of reality" for its ability to bury truths under piles of thought models.
- User23 3y agoDon’t get crazy now. If we go down this route we might start expecting working programmers to achieve basic mastery of the predicate calculus.