4 ms·
It's important to differentiate between the relative inconveniences of obtaining and maintaining a license and the absolute impediment posed by the lack of acce
by takoid 3y ago
It's important to differentiate between the relative inconveniences of obtaining and maintaining a license and the absolute impediment posed by the lack of access to a personal vehicle. Governmental licenses, while a form of regulation, generally do not serve as effective tools to suppress rapid mobilization for protests, uprisings, or other civil unrest. They are largely administrative hurdles that the vast majority of citizens can and do clear, thus retaining their decentralized power of mobility.
On the other hand, a lack of access to personal vehicles entirely changes this dynamic. Without a car, the population's ability to quickly mobilize and organize diminishes substantially, thereby increasing vulnerability to central control. Protests or other forms of collective action often require rapid assembly at specific locations, sometimes far from one's residence. Public transportation routes can be easily shut down or rerouted, and walking may not be feasible over long distances or in emergencies. In this context, personal vehicles are not just a convenience; they serve as a critical enabler for civic engagement and resistance to potential tyranny. Therefore, while the economic and regulatory aspects of car ownership are not trivial, they are outweighed by the benefits of maintaining a system that allows individuals a meaningful degree of autonomous movement.
- manuelabeledo 3y ago> In this context, personal vehicles are not just a convenience; they serve as a critical enabler for civic engagement and resistance to potential tyranny. These "self organizing concerned citizens agains tyranny" are one hundred percent not aligned with the general European sentiment, not even in the UK, first and foremost because urban density in European cities is ~4x vs those in the US. Cuts in public transportation drive as much public outrage as rising gas prices. I think that you are reading too much into this, effectively giving this conspiracy theory some semblance of rationality. You would be hard pressed to find any of the high ranked European proponents able to articulate any of the ideas you just presented. In fact, the article mentions how the conservative government in the UK are the ones pushing against 15-minute cities. Will the loons side with the government to stand against the tyranny of the government?