3 ms·
In my experience it isn't that people lack motivation (the others are spot on), but that they have no idea what a lot is. I had one friend brag to me that afte
by bluGill 3y ago
In my experience it isn't that people lack motivation (the others are spot on), but that they have no idea what a lot is. I had one friend brag to me that after 2 years of contributing to his 401k he had $13k - which sounds like a lot of money, but realistically he should have had more like 300k to be on track for a good retirement.
There is for most people little reason to keep much money in a savings account. They don't earn much interest.
- iosono88 3y ago[dead]
- stouset 3y agoSorry, I should have included "understanding" in that list.
- epiccoleman 3y agoBut... there's no way you could possible have 300k after 2 years of contributions to a 401k. If you were maxing it you'd have about 40. Unless you've made a typo and you mean 20 years? (in which case, now 300k is below maxing out, but slightly closer (although with returns it should be a good bit more))
- mikestew 3y agoBut... there's no way you could possible have 300k after 2 years of contributions to a 401k. You’re right…but that’s not what was said. After 2 years, all they had was $13K. But if they’d been contributing for 20 years like they should have been doing (because they’re 40, not fresh out of college), they’d have $300K. IOW, $13K is nothing to brag about if you’re 35 and working software jobs your whole career. At least that’s how I read it.
- suoduandao3 3y agoI'm guessing the friend started late.
- bluGill 3y agoHe was self employed for a while, and worked for small companies that didn't even offer a 401k before that. So yes he started late which was/is unfortunate for him. That he didn't really have good chances to get on track is understandable, but he is still way behind. He again is working for a small company without 401k options, so I suppose he will retire at 68 with $50k in the 401k and then be surprised there isn't enough money there to last a few months. At least he should get SS like many.
- stouset 3y ago> But... there's no way you could possible have 300k after 2 years of contributions to a 401k. If you were maxing it you'd have about 40. This is a bit of an aside, but… this isn't quite correct. Your (combined) individual contribution limit to a Traditional 401(k) and Roth 401(k) is $22,500 for this year. That doesn't include employer contributions. It also doesn't include after-tax contributions. The total combined limit for all contributions from all sources is $66,000 this year. So you could max out your Traditional 401(k), have your employer contribute $4,000, and then contribute an additional $39,500 to the after-tax portion. The after-tax portion has no advantageous tax treatment whatsoever. It's identical to putting that same amount into a brokerage account… except for one detail. If you employer has a plan which allows for in-service distributions, you can immediately roll over after-tax contributions into the Roth portion of your account. This enables individuals working for companies with very good benefits packages to save an incredible $66,000/yr into tax-advantaged retirement accounts. So assuming no growth, you can actually legally put $132,000 into a 401(k) in two years. It is thoroughly fucked up that the majority of Americans who don't work for giant companies with gold-plated benefits packages only have access to $6,500 in tax-advantaged savings through IRAs.
- sgerenser 3y agoYeah, I have no idea why the government doesn't just completely scrap all IRA and 401k limits, and just combine them into one total "tax-advantaged account contribution cap" of X dollars (maybe $30K or so, indexed to wage inflation).
- earthling8118 3y agoOK. So let's say I put all that money in each year. When does it benefit me after I've become homeless and hungry? After rent, food, insurance, medical bills, student loans, and taxes there's nowhere near that kind of money left. Let alone if you're the kind of person that enjoys recreational activities.
- cableshaft 3y agoThere's no way to have $300k in a 401k in 2 years. There's an annual limit much lower than that. I'm assuming you have a typo somewhere.
- sokoloff 3y agoThat's the point. If someone who is a high-earner started saving at age 38 and by age 40 has $13K in their 401(k), it is still true that they "should have" had $300-400K in their account by that point.
- bluGill 3y agoHe was not a high earner, so the $300k is more reasonable for him. For a high earning turning 40 today $500k is probably about right to have saved up. If you are a high earner turning 25 today, you will probably need in the range of $800k by 40 - but I have no idea what inflation will do so that is just a guess to get attention and not a real number.