7 ms·
Google Now Using ReCAPTCHA To Decode Street View Addresses
- pbreit 15y agoI'm really not a fan of captchas in general and Recaptcha in particular. Captchas are user hostile enough, benefiting the service provider at the user's expense. Recaptcha is worse because it is even more of a drag on the user and now also benefits Google. I run across a lot of captchas where I would be very surprised if the site owner actually had a problem being addressed by the captcha.
- schiffern 15y ago> Recaptcha is worse because it... now also benefits Google. I fail to see how this is a down-side. Maybe it's not an up-side, but is it actually a loss for anyone?
- pittsburgh 15y agoAs a developer, I agree that captchas can be a drag on users, and I think we should put serious thought into whether or not their UX-cost is justified. Personally, I try to avoid using them on sites I build. That said, as a user, it's hard to hate ReCaptcha after hearing Luis von Ahn talk about and defend his invention: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ht4qiDRZE8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ht4qiDRZE8 It's a clever way to digitize books (and now street signs) while keeping out spambots, and when I combine that knowledge with my affinity for Luis von Ahn as a person I find myself less annoyed every time I have to prove I'm not a robot.
- a3_nm 15y ago> It's a clever way to digitize books (and now street signs) It used to be a cool idea when it benefited everyone, because it was used to ditigize public domain books that everyone could retrieve. Now, it's only a clever way for Google to use your brain to do stuff for their own purposes.
- quanticle 15y agoYou'd be surprised. With automated posting tools, the cost of probing many different sites and posting massive amounts of spam (in an effort to raise search engine rankings) is very low indeed. I've run several small forums, and without fail, eventually they'd be overrun with spam and I'd have to either 1) install authentication or 2) install a captcha. I agree that captchas are user-hostile. But, when weighed against the alternative - a forum or comments section so filled with spam and nonsense as to be unusable - captchas are by far the lesser of two evils.
- sukuriant 15y agoWow. That's even easier to write a bot to circumvent...
- ericlevine 15y agoAre you suggesting that detecting text from these mediocre-at-best photos is easy or that it's easy to determine which of the two sides is the control photo?
- sukuriant 15y agoI'm suggesting that it's easier to detect text from these "mediocre at best" photos. Classifying objects in a visual space often deal with low quality images. In fact, the algorithms have to deal with the objects they're trying to classify at many different resolutions. While captchas are generally hard to identify even for humans, because they're contorted and confusing, the numbers in these addresses are all standardized numbers in grainy environments. I would even go as far to argue that if these become widely used, we're going to see algorithmic "solvers" for this captcha in a matter of weeks.
- schiffern 15y agoreCAPTCHA has always checked only one side. The new system isn't any less secure.
- sukuriant 15y agoI don't really understand that response. What I'm saying is that if these addresses become one of the actually-checked human-verifiers, it will be easier to circumvent, because those numbers look comparably easier for a virtual classifier to evaluate. The house numbers are easier for a computer to classify than the messy, weird contorted letters.
- schiffern 15y agoThen they'll do what they did for books – introduce distortion. reCAPTCHA has already solved this problem.
- smackfu 15y agoMany of those in the examples at the bottom look like trivial work for OCR.
- ceol 15y agoFrom a privacy standpoint, what effect does this have on us? I kind of cringed at the thought of my house number being spread around the Internet for strangers to solve. Then I realized I don't really have a problem with people solving my address so much as I have a problem with Google having a database of photographs of everyone's house. Are my concerns unfounded?
- notatoad 15y agoIn what way does tying the appearance of your house to its street number have anything to do with your privacy?
- ceol 15y agoIt's more so the photograph of my house than knowing my street number.
- enjo 15y agoWhat about that makes you uncomfortable exactly? I'm genuinely curious, as I've heard that sentiment expressed many times before. It's not like your house is otherwise invisible...
- ceol 15y agoMy house isn't necessarily invisible, but having photographs of my (and every other house) sitting in some company's database makes me uncomfortable. It's kind of like those cars that drive around recording everyone's license plate. Sure, that information is sitting out in the open anyway, but streamlining the collection of that information gives me the creeps.
- __alexs 15y agoGo remove it then? I did it for mine just to see if they would and it was gone within 48 hours.
- 15y ago
- notatoad 15y agoI think everybody might be looking at this backwards. Google already has very precise gps-correlated maps and street view data, it doesn't seem like they would need our help to determine street addresses. Recaptcha pairs a known with an unknown to verify, maybe the addresses are the known factor.
- hbar 15y agoUsually if I input an address into Google maps, it places a marker somewhere near the actual address. If I use street view it seems to point me in a random direction and usually not toward the address I wanted. I think this is aimed at that.
- DavidChouinard 15y agoSlightly related, but if you haven't yet seen Luis von Ahn's TED talk on reCAPTCHA, I recommend it highly: http://www.ted.com/talks/luis_von_ahn_massive_scale_online_collaboration.html http://www.ted.com/talks/luis_von_ahn_massive_scale_online_c...
- Permit 15y agoI'm curious how they're able to identify what parts of images are house numbers. To me, that seems like it would be a harder problem than determining what numbers are present. But I have really little knowledge in this domain so I might be completely wrong.
- majmun 15y agolet me guess , there is another captcha that test users to find house numbers in a picture.