6 ms·
Prosper.com, P2P Lending Startup, Shut Down by SEC [pdf]
- nickb 18y agoKiva, Zopa next? What exactly do the other two differently so they stay on the legal side (or maybe they're all illegal)? Anyone know?
- cabalamat 18y agoKiva are legal because they don't pay interest.
- aneesh 18y agoYep, the profit motive was mentioned over and over again in the SEC document, and it seems that was the key. Because of the profit motives, loans on Prosper qualified as securities, and hence the SEC regulations applied. With Kiva, there's no way for the lender to profit, so the same SEC regulations don't apply to Kiva.
- icky 18y agoI wonder if there's a way around this: instead of an explicit interest or profit, make it a trade-based market: I'll give you X dollars-today, in exchange for 1.1X dollars-N-months-from-now. Or I'll give you X dollars-in-a-month in exchange for Y Euros-today. Does the SEC regulate currency trading markets? And, if not, why can't dollars-today and dollars-6-months-from-now be traded as separate currencies [taking into account expected inflation/deflation, as well as the time-value of money]?
- aneesh 18y ago"I'll give you X dollars-today, in exchange for 1.1X dollars-N-months-from-now." Isn't that the very definition of interest?
- icky 18y agoNo, interest usually compounds. This is more like a one-off currency trade of now-dollars versus future-dollars.
- aneesh 18y agoStill, you are giving some amount of today's dollars in return for a larger amount of tomorrow's dollars. That implies some effective interest rate over that time period. Also, while most financial institutions use compound interest, the concept of simple interest also exists. Am I missing something?
- dangoldin 18y agoThis thread reminds me of Islamic laws dealing with interest. Since you can't charge interest, the solution is to go into a trade like transaction. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_banking#Modern_Islamic_banking http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_banking#Modern_Islamic_... So even if charging interest is forbidden in one way, there are ways to circumvent that.
- fugue88 18y agoThat's called simple interest, as opposed to compounding interest.
- ig1 18y agoThey can and are. They're called "FX forwards", and what's more the technique you described is exactly the one the Medici family used to make their fortune (avoiding the usuary laws of the time). However it doesn't work if you can't guarantee a fixed rate of interest (as in this case).
- bokonist 18y agoYou'd think that by 2008 we wouldn't still be banning usury, but I guess not.
- nickb 18y agoBanking is a racket and they can practice usury all they want. They just hate competition, that's all. Credit cards have 21% limit in some states and no limit in others. How's that for usury?!
- jhancock 18y agoIf you are a bank or some other org that paid lobbyists to create the loopholes for you, usary laws hardly effect you anymore. However, I think usary protections should exist and we need to repeal all these loopholes.
- cabalamat 18y agoThe problem with this type of ruling is that it prevents new and innovative financial services from springing up which (if allowed to exist) might supercede the present financial system. It's not as if the present system is perfect. Having said that, there are sensible reasons for regulating companies in the financial industry, for example preventing unsophisticated customers from losing lots of money.
- nickb 18y ago... might supercede the present financial system And that's precisely why they will be always shut down. Government hates competition. Gov also shut down Liberty Dollar which was a commodity-backed currency. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_Dollar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_Dollar http://www.flickr.com/photos/71392301@N00/1404773871/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/71392301@N00/1404773871/
- jhancock 18y agofrom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_Dollar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_Dollar -> "Community currencies may present problems for users because there is little to stop the issuer from producing more currency." ahh...brutal irony in a wikipedia article ;)
- gills 18y agoThat's a good argument for repealing the Federal Reserve Act. Did anyone else listen to NPR yesterday morning and hear the open admission that they were printing to fund their new failout package?
- drewcrawford 18y agoWith our current economic institutions failing, we can't afford to have innovative and successful financial institutions. That would just make everyone look bad.
- cabalamat 18y agoYeah, heaven forbid that the banks should actually have to face competition like, er, the rest of the economy. If the computer industry was regulated like this, the Internet would look like Compuserve circa 1990. And your PC would still only have 640K of RAM.
- patio11 18y agoI am as Republican as the day is long, I invested on Prosper and made a profit, I believed then and believe now that innovation in the financial markets would lower prices and raise returns, and I default to the assumption that government meddling in the free market is almost always to the detriment of the participants. That said? If you knew about the particulars of this situation, which I covered a wee bit about in a post above, you would say Prosper is about as close as you can get as a poster child for Why The Market Should Be Regulated without being founded by Ponzi himself.
- mattmaroon 18y agoPreventing innocent people from getting ripped off by scammers asking for investments is necessary for a healthy market.
- patio11 18y agoSubmitter here. Glad you liked the story. Incidentally, I am a Prosper lender to the tune of $300. The dirt on this story could fill a small book, or a large forum (http://www.prospers.org http://www.prospers.org) The long and short of it: Prosper really wanted to be a technology play like Paypal which disintermediated banks and then got to take a small slice off each transaction. However, their model required that they, in effect, take on a lot of banklike aspects -- including investigating borrowers and collecting on deadbeats. They were woefully unprepared for both of them, thinking at the beginning that the lending peers would crowdsource it, before they realized that this would be very, very illegal. (Privacy/harassment laws + telling 50 pissed people the identity of a single mom late on her payments + Google + lawyer = you tell me how this story ends.) Anyhow, Prosper expected that despite the complete lack underwriting and neigh-total lack of fraud checking they would get default rates roughly similar to that of banks. Then, BEFORE the financial crisis started, reality set in and lenders started losing lots of money. This made Prosper's claimed rates of return ("Hey, if you loan money at 20% and only 5% default that means you make 15% APR!"[1]) extraordinarily rosy. Rather than accepting the data and revising the claimed rates of return downward, they instead started slicing it in smaller and smaller pieces (creating, for example, a Prosper Select Index filled with their best quality borrowers -- are we hearing the word "tranches" yet?) to claim that the rate was still exceptionally positive. Representative ad: [Edit: Thank you to commenter who pointed out my URL was borked. I'll TinyURL it: http://tinyurl.com/63em2c http://tinyurl.com/63em2c ] Funny, "Earn 8.00% to 12.00% rates of return" looks like a security, it sounds like a security, it feels like a security... except if it were an actual security, well, the accountant who approved those numbers would be locked up. (Seriously. I liked the company, but the math is THAT bad. The average rate of return lenders of size were actually achieving was, at the time, closer to 3%. About 25% were losing money. Only about 10% every achieved the rates that were claimed in 36 pt font. And for what its worth, although my $300 doesn't make me a large lender by any stretch of the imagination, up until my first late payment a few weeks ago I was earning close to 18%.) [1] Despite two years of trying to educate them about how math works via their forum and their email, we lenders were unable to penetrate their ignorance about high school math. Seriously. Three years after opening they still thought 25% interest and 20% defaults meant a 5% return. Even if the defaults were almost instantaneous, as most defaults on the platform are.
- pjharrin 18y agoHow has techcrunch not picked up this story yet?
- listic 18y agoTechcrunch promotes capitalism, mind you
- alexandros 18y agojust did. http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/11/26/sec-outlines-its-reasoning-for-shutting-down-p2p-lender-prosper/ http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/11/26/sec-outlines-its-reason...
- pjharrin 18y agoI really liked Prosper, I thought they were doing a very good job of executing their idea. It will be very interesting to see where this goes
- rms 18y agoI loaned $1000 to rather risky people with an average interest rate of 21.2%. I lost $200 dollars with a 39% default rate.
- dpapathanasiou 18y agoSo you experienced the sub-prime crisis in microcosm ;)
- rms 18y agoI really did... my tactic was to loan to high risk people that were homeowners. I was making money until the whole subprime troubles started bubbling up. Though I wasn't using 35:1 leverage.
- globalrev 18y agoNot to be a know-it-all and I-told-you-so but how could they not see the problem with this model?
- crystalarchives 18y agoThanks for submitting! This was really important news for me. I'm actually a huge fan of Prosper - I'm a lender with $500 invested, and I've actually gotten a 20% return because I spent a lot of time screening my borrowers, who have still yet to make a late payment, much less default. I only accepted B and above credit ratings and generally just used common sense when selecting a borrower; very well written, well thought out profiles got priority, limited (1 or 2) late payments in the past were required. I always checked how much of their credit they were using versus how much they made, I never funded a loan near the $25k borrowing limit to avoid a hit-and-run default, I only funded good causes that suggested the borrower spends wisely, etc. Prosper gave a lot of financial information about these people, so I felt that I could make a pretty educated decision. I hope Prosper registers with SEC so they can continue doing business. The platform is pretty amazing, and I think they really added value to the world. I was totally looking forward to scaling up my selection system by automating it, and Prosper was working on an API that would actually let me do that. I never bought into their math, and didn't even really think about it. My plan was always to pick loans very carefully so that very few if any would default. In retrospect, I'm glad I didn't do any subprime lending. :) That said, I probably jinxed myself now and everyone in my portfolio will default...
- epall 18y agoThere's always Lending Club! They seem to have made it through the whole SEC process and out the other side recently. They do have some lender requirements that I don't meet, unfortunately.
- DEinspanjer 18y agoI am a lender to the tune of a few thousand dollars. I actually recently pulled all my cash out of it in a transaction that completed on the 24th. Still have a lot of outstanding loans though. I was doing pretty well, I got hit by one big default early on in my experimentation with the site and only recently came into the green again from that. If I discount that one poor investment, I was actually making a pretty decent return of about 13%.
- ig1 18y agoThe SEC regulation are their to prevent companies taking advantage of naive investors. From what I've read Prosper mis-represented the risks of these loans, which is precisely the kind of thing which SEC regulated companies are not allowed to do. Regulations exist for a reason. As long as your willing to follow the regulations (which exist to prevent mis-selling, market abuse, insider trading, and other such things) getting SEC approval isn't that hard. The other alternative is to partner with a regulated firm and use their approval, this it the route Zopa has taken. But again you need to make sure your company follows SEC guidelines.
- NotAtAllHapy 18y agoPut several thou into this puppy - mostly A & AA - loans started going belly up about 8-10 months out. Have basically written off this as a worthless investment - will be happy to get back ANYthing at this point. And NOW...prosper is "off the air"...fascinating.