3 ms·
The lego analogy is good, the Punch Buggy is not. Here's the thing: words (as opposed to physical violence) are very curious insofar as they can only hurt you
by angersock 15y ago
The lego analogy is good, the Punch Buggy is not.
Here's the thing: words (as opposed to physical violence) are very curious insofar as they can only hurt you as much as you let them.
I'd suggest that it'd be better to try and cultivate thick skins, and to publicly shame or ignore people who are acting like idiots until they knock it off.
Racism, sexism, genderism (is that even the right word?), and agism are all stupid biases, and by treating them like a valid threat instead of a silly self-limiting arbitrary preference we are doing well by no one.
- DanBC 15y ago> Here's the thing: words (as opposed to physical violence) are very curious insofar as they can only hurt you as much as you let them. What happens when Bob, (who was hospitalised for 6 weeks by a gang who beat him while shouting racist abuse at him[1]) hears someone using that same racist abuse? > Racism, sexism, genderism (is that even the right word?), and agism are all stupid biases, and by treating them like a valid threat instead of a silly self-limiting arbitrary preference we are doing well by no one. I really don't understand the self-limiting argument. It's made very often. Maybe I'm being a bit thick but doesn't history prove it wrong? Women (in the UK) were openly paid less than men until laws were passed. That didn't self-limit. It was common (in the UK; after WW2) for people letting rooms to have signs saying "No Blacks No Irish". That didn't self-limit.
- tomjen3 15y agoHow is the feeling Bob has any different from the same guy getting beaten the same way by a gang in a particular brand of car whenever he sees that car? Do you want to ban that car brand too?
- DanBC 15y agoI don't want to ban anything, not even words. Some words come from hate, and are used by hateful people, and the recipients of those words will perceive that hate, and it's not their problem of having thin-skin. (btw: I am not going to post anymore about this. Kind regards.)
- lmkg 15y agoI find that most people's suggestions on this topic are that someone else modify their behavior to accommodate the suggester. This observation applies to both sides: pro-feminists suggest men stop behaving in ways that offend them, and (non-pro-feminist) men suggest that women stop being offended. I don't think we're going to get very far when both sides put the responsibility[1] for action on the other party. [1] Responsibility is not the same as blame.
- angersock 15y agoYou're welcome to do as you please, of course. Just acknowledge that, if it pleases you to be offended when somebody says something factually incorrect about you, well, by golly, you'll be offended. We cannot do anything by message passing (especially on the internet) that directly and unstoppably changes the mental state of another person--they must read it, and then become offended or not. This is trivially shown to be true. You don't throw a system out on the 'net without hardening it--even well-meaning applications can cause problems if you don't. Similarly, even well-meaning messages can cause people distress if they allow them to; it's better just to have thicker skin and deal with the unrepentant troublemakers by ignoring them or correcting them.
- msbarnett 15y ago> Here's the thing: words (as opposed to physical violence) are very curious insofar as they can only hurt you as much as you let them. Life is not that simple. Psychologists have shown that exposure to 'harmless' sexist humor can lead to an increase in the toleration of hostility towards, and discrimination against, women.[1] 'Growing a thicker skin' might save your feelings for a bit, but the net effect is paradoxically that over time your ability to tolerate 'minor' comments will open you up to increasingly more serious discrimination. Far easier to nip the discrimination in the bud when its still a dumb blonde joke, far harder when it's serious pay discrimination or outright sexual harassment. [1] http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/11/071106083038.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/11/071106083038.ht...
- angersock 15y agoWe can (and should!) address directly and harshly things like pay discrimination and sexual harassment (ill-defined though that may be). The writeup in the news article you cite doesn't really address either the rigor or testing circumstances of things--I'd be hesitant to take it as gospel. (minor note: the article you refer to is available at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18056796 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18056796 but is behind a pay wall)
- MartinCron 15y agoTelling people to grow thicker skins is such a cheap way out. Outrage is an appropriate response to an outrageous situation. words (as opposed to physical violence) are very curious insofar as they can only hurt you as much as you let them It's not about the words themselves. It's about behaving in a way that is aggressive, dismissive, and disrespectful. What's the appropriate reaction to someone treating you in an aggressive, dismissive, or disrespectful way? One might feel aggressed, dismissed, or disrespected (or offended even). Maybe you're so self enlightened and have such an exquisitely sublimated ego that nobody can hurt you through those kinds of behavior. But it's not typical, and isn't a reasonable expectation for your fellow humans.