6 ms·
This line-item is basically a smokescreen for cutting all sorts of other important things (like the research tax credit, SR&ED; various social programs; the bud
by mmastrac 15y ago
This line-item is basically a smokescreen for cutting all sorts of other important things (like the research tax credit, SR&ED; various social programs; the budget for our national broadcaster, the CBC; and the salary of the Chief Electoral Officer):
http://www.reddit.com/r/canada/comments/rjrfn/the_budget_5_billion_in_cuts_over_3_years_and/ http://www.reddit.com/r/canada/comments/rjrfn/the_budget_5_b...
Amusingly this particular cut was actually a private member proposal from the NDP (the left-most mainstream party).
- dfc 15y agoI'm not very familiar with canadian politics. Why is it amusing that the NDP proposed this?
- mhyee 15y agoThe party that implemented this is the Conservative party, the right-most mainstream party. The two parties generally don't see eye to eye, to put it lightly.
- dhughes 15y agoThe Conservative party was decimated years ago and was nearly eliminated then eventually the Reform Party which became the Canadian Alliance merged into the Conservative party (both parties were dead anyway). Reformers were certainly farther right compared to the members of the old Conservative party. Now there is a Conservative party it's the same skin on the outside but fundamentally different, it couldn't be more different, it's pretty much the Reform Party 2.0 yet people see "Conservative Party" and vote for it. That's my take on it anyway.
- redthrowaway 15y agoThis isn't the Canadian Budget; it's the budget proposed by the ruling Conservatives. This item will likely generate the most buzz and goodwill for the budget, and it was proposed by the current Opposition NDP, who are socialists. So, the greatest PR windfall for the Conservatives will have come from their biggest ideological and political opponents. It's mildly entertaining. That said, as the Conservatives have a majority (>50% of seats in the House of Commons), there's no chance that the budget would fail, triggering a vote of non-confidence and a general election. So it wasn't a vote that had any real importance politically, but it will serve to generate public goodwill, which they could use. The Conservatives currently only have a majority because of the ineptitude of the Liberals and Quebecers' fatigue with the Bloc Quebecois. Most Canadians are to the left of the Conservatives, have only warily entrusted them with power, and only then because the center-left liberals couldn't get their shit together at election time.
- dhughes 15y agoIt's difficult finding a comparison since the US only has a two-party system. Maybe an example something like Ralph Nader suggesting something and Nixon doing it. Or more modern George W Bush following the advice of Jon Stewart. Anyway (the far?) right agreeing with the left is odd.
- gyardley 15y agoNot particularly far to the right. Setting aside the Quebec-only Bloc, the three main parties in Canada are center-right, centrist, and center-left. They all like to claim the others are extremists, but all of them have perfectly mainstream views.
- s3graham 15y agoThere's another party! And yeah, she's pretty centrist too.
- run4yourlives 15y agoExcept for that whole "wifi is going to irradiate us" stance.
- huggyface 15y agoSay that it's a "smoke screen" is needlessly partisan. It is, indeed, a line item. It deals with something that has come up for consideration since the 80s. If it gets attention, it gets attention. But do you think no one notices the other changes because they're ditching the penny? That is preposterous.
- yay_cloud 15y agoIt might be construed as a partisan comment, but that is exactly how politics works. After working on a few campaigns (and leaving in disgust), a politician or party will gladly pocket an easy but visible decision like this in order to "steal eyes" away from other -- less positive -- changes or events.
- maratd 15y ago> "steal eyes" away from other -- less positive -- changes or events. How is cutting waste less positive? They're conservatives. They get bonus points for cutting things. Now, if they passed tax increases, then you've got a point.
- true_religion 15y agoThere's cutting fat, then there's cutting muscle. The two aren't too similar, but I wouldn't want anyone cutting into me who wasn't a surgeon. Now with politics, we often have people who claim to cut waste, but are perceived as cutting necessary programs.
- redthrowaway 15y agoCutting spending is positive among their base, which is about a third of Canadians. The rest typically wouldn't vote Conservative. They and the NDP simply split the Liberal and Bloc vote in the last election. You may view the CBC and Healthcare as waste; the vast majority of Canadians do not. Harper wants more than anything to convince Canadians that the Conservatives are trustworthy. The last thing he wants is for Canadians to be sick of them by the time the next election rolls around, especially if the Liberals manage to find a halfway competent leader. That's why Harper's been as centrist as he has, and that's why cuts to popular programs are being delivered alongside this news. He'll stay true to conservative values, but only insofar as they don't hurt his re-election chances.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- dstein 15y agofrom reddit: SR&ED is [reorganized.] Whew, so it's not completely axed. If anything Canada needs significantly more investment and tax programs like this. Brain drain has always been a problem for Canada because of the lack of investment from the government and the lack of tech-oriented VC.
- mcantelon 15y agoFrom skimming the news it seems like it's cut significantly. >The changes include a cut in 2014 to 15 per cent from 20 per in the tax credit rate and a restriction on which expenditures count toward the credit. For example, capital expenditures – buildings, equipment and product prototypes – will no longer be eligible. The amount of eligible overhead expenses and subcontracted R&D will also be reduced. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/growth/tories-target-lagging-innovation-with-funding-overhaul/article2386039/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/gr... Bad news for Canada's tech innovators.
- cperciva 15y agoI was hoping for SR&ED to be completely axed. It's a huge monstrosity of paperwork, to the point that small businesses pay 30% of their tax credits to consultants who fill out the forms for them and large businesses hire teams of people for the sole purpose of tracking and classifying SR&ED expenses so that the tax credits can be claimed. I suspect that Tarsnap is eligible for some SR&ED credits, but it's simply not worth the time and headaches it would cost me to claim them. If Canada wants to encourage innovation, they should set up a system which rewards people for doing new and innovative things, not a system which rewards people for being good at filling out forms.
- erohead 15y agoTalk to Ernst & Young. They will help startups file for SR&ED for a flat fee of $1-3k. Takes a few hours to draft the document with their help. It is not as hard as it sounds.
- chrisdinn 15y agoI've successfully written SR&ED applications myself for businesses certainly less deserving than Tarsnap. We decided the consultants were too expensive and gave it a shot ourselves. One solid week of work for one guy at a company of 10 people netted $30,000, definitely worth the time. All you need is a decent record of work done (I used both github commit log and a bug tracker.) Unfortunately I expect you'll never get money from a bureaucrat without a little paperwork. Still, you're missing out if you don't even try.
- aoprisan 15y agohow is this even remotely a smokescreen? it will save money and lower costs for businesses in the long term.
- Natsu 15y agoI believe he's arguing that this is a good change that will get a lot of press. With that creating an opportunity to make a lot of bad changes while everyone is focused on this. Not being up on Canadian politics, I won't take a position on whether or not that is correct, except that the US is in the same boat and I would like it if they would get rid of our penny. I know there are people who say it's traditional and whatnot, but I don't see anyone clamoring to bring back two or three cent pieces.