2 ms·
> Having created a polity that broke completely from the European monarchic traditions, I've got to agree with skissane here on this. Do you know who else bro
by defrost 3y ago
> Having created a polity that broke completely from the European monarchic traditions,
I've got to agree with skissane here on this.
Do you know who else broke from European monarchic traditions? Most of Europe, the UK in particular started in 1066 and by WWI (say) had a monarchy that was almost entire symbolic in power and fully deferred to the elected Government to make decisions.
The bulk of the European monarchies were overtaken internally by governments that preserved the ideal of a crowned head of state but didn't allow them to hold any significant reins of power.
The US "breaking away" from the King's taxes was a good example of UK investors protecting their investments and further weakening the ability of UK monarchy from raising taxes for petty family disputes (ie. wars much larger than the American Revolutionary War)
While the US made a radical jump for the time in which it was founded, it didn't really politically evolve much since - as noted in the peer comment "the United States is a monarchy with an elective king", evidenced by all the Presidental moves taking the US to war, etc. without full approval, the apparent inability of the US government to successfully prosecute a President, etc.
Australia, for example, came along to independence later and established a "Washminster" system of Government, one that drew from both the UK Westminister system and the US Washington system.
What you call a "vigorous collection of local democratic entities" much of the G20 would see as a backwards assembly of petty fiefdoms with local sheriffs imagining themselves a little king.
- skissane 3y ago> Most of Europe, the UK in particular started in 1066 and by WWI (say) had a monarchy that was almost entire symbolic in power and fully deferred to the elected Government to make decisions. Even by the time of the American Revolution, the British monarch was largely a figurehead, and Parliament held the majority of the real power The American rebels blamed all the policies they hated on King George III – that made good propaganda, but if they'd directed their anger at Lord North (the PM) instead, it would have been more accurate The historian David Cannadine [0] even argues "the founding fathers gave to the American presidency just those powers they erroneously believed King George III still possessed" – possibly suggesting that it wasn't just propaganda, but rather that on the other side of the Atlantic Ocean they'd failed to understand how the British system actually worked > The US "breaking away" from the King's taxes was a good example of UK investors protecting their investments and further weakening the ability of UK monarchy from raising taxes for petty family disputes (ie. wars much larger than the American Revolutionary War) While the Seven Years War did involve some "petty family disputes", they weren't what it was really all about, any more than the First World War was really about the assassination of Franz Ferdinand. The Seven Years War arguably started in North America, as a war between France and Britain (that sub-theatre is generally known as the "French and Indian War")–a war which the Americans wholeheartedly supported, on the British side–and one of the complaints of the Declaration of Independence was that the British had conceded too much to France in the peace negotiations (e.g. agreeing to allow newly conquered Quebec to keep the French legal system) [0] https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-32741802 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-32741802 – same source as I linked in my other comment
- defrost 3y agoFair points - I confess to gross over simplification as an attempt to jolt a different perspective.