3 ms·
Every year, Apple releases new hardware and software in tandem. How long does it take Android manufacturers and Windows manufacturers to take advantage of the
by scarface_74 3y ago
Every year, Apple releases new hardware and software in tandem. How long does it take Android manufacturers and Windows manufacturers to take advantage of the latest OS features?
How are those Android updates working out compared to iPhones?
- mschuster91 3y ago> How long does it take Android manufacturers Way way too long, but to be fair a huge part of the issue are carriers and their insistence to pack the phones full of bloatware that needs to be tested against each update. > and Windows manufacturers to take advantage of the latest OS features? Windows device manufacturers tend to do what Microsoft demands of them. > How are those Android updates working out compared to iPhones? Samsung is fairly decent, although I'd be happier if they'd ... consolidate their lineup a bit and instead offer longer availability for spare parts.
- scarface_74 3y agoFairly decent? The iPhone 5s from 2013 just got an update and it’s the carriers is a poor excuse. Apple runs on the same carriers. Google’s first party phones don’t have third party bloat ware and still have a piss poor history of updates
- mschuster91 3y agoAnd guess why? Because ~3-ish years used to be what the SoC vendors provided as BSP support timeframe, and there was no mandate that they open up their specifications. Most don't even care about following the legal minimum aka provide the kernel and bootloader source code, especially not all these fly-by-night gongkai "brands".
- scarface_74 3y agoSo it’s what happens when hardware and software is not integrated…
- mschuster91 3y agoNo, it's what happens when there is no competition in the SoC vendor area. Apple and Samsung don't sell to external customers, NVIDIA doesn't do much with Tegra outside of the Switch and automotive, Broadcom doesn't do much in mobile SoCs (and from what the Raspberry Pi community learned hard, their chips are utter dogshit which is how RPi got started after all - they used surplus crap that Broadcom wasn't able to sell), which leaves Qualcomm as a sole supplier for the "high end" and Mediatek/Rockchip for bottom-of-the-barrel crap. There used to be Annapurna Labs as well, QNAP used their SoCs for a while, but I think they stopped selling to externals as well as they were bought up by Amazon and now only do Graviton which are Amazon exclusives.
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd yet Apple uses Qualcomm chips and manages to update 10 year old phones. It couldn’t possibly be your premise is flawed could it?
- mschuster91 3y ago> And yet Apple uses Qualcomm chips and manages to update 10 year old phones. For modems, yes, but only because there's even less competition in that area (which is why they bought Intel's mobile modem business, but failed to produce a viable design in all the years since). They've been running their own SoC designs since the iPhone 4 era in 2010.
- scarface_74 3y agoSo now it’s the severe lack of competition that allows Apple to support phones for a decade but stops Android manufacturers?
- nani8ot 3y agoApple has an interest in keeping their devices alive, since they can make money of the store and services. Android manufactures want you to throw the phone away and buy a new one. Since manufacturers didn't demand long support, Qualcomm didn't provide updates for their SoCs. This meant Fairphone couldn't support their phones even if they wanted to, which is why they used am automotive chip in their new phone — which is nearly the same as a phone chip except the 13 years of updates.
- pjmlp 3y agoLame excuses, Google could do the same as Microsoft with PC standards and OEM legal obligations. They have chosen not to.
- mschuster91 3y agoAgreed. Google has gone down the drains just as well on all fronts... the thing is, once again, there is no viable competition left since Microsoft gave up. The various Linux phone projects are extremely niche stuff, Blackberry and Symbian are long gone, and Google seems to be happy coasting along on mediocrity and billions of dollars in Play Store revenue.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoThat wouldn't change at all. The newly separated software company would get appropriate hardware specs and prototypes during the same timeline they do today (as a vertically integrated branch of Apple).
- scarface_74 3y agoSo instead of working together , the software team would work in isolation and then when they are finished they deliver to the hardware company and keep going back and forth? Yeah that’s going to work out real well. Let’s just look how well it work for Android.
- thomastjeffery 3y ago> the software team would work in isolation Only if the hardware company refuses to share info with them, which - as you clearly laid out - is not in their interest.
- scarface_74 3y agoYou really don’t see how that would slow things down compared to the hardware and software company working together? I bet you also think that a company should set up a DevOps “department” to increase efficiency
- thomastjeffery 3y agoAre you telling me that Apple doesn't have a separate hardware division? I sincerely doubt that.
- scarface_74 3y agoI am saying that Apple has a software and hardware division that work in concert. Chris Lattner, the inventor of the Swift programming language and the open source LLVM was once interviewed on the Accidental Tech Podcast and he was asked whether bytecode could be used to allow Apple to switch architectures without forcing them to require developers to recompile and still have native compilation. He made up some half truth about whether that would be possible. Years later when the S chips in the Apple Watch became 64 bit, he admitted that at the time of the interview, he knew that the 64 bit S chip was on the roadmap internally and he designed the LLVM with that in mind. That’s what happens when you have software and hardware teams working together. The same is true with Nvidia and the their software developers who design Cuda and Intel and the compiler makers. There were also reports that the software team responsible for the JS engine in WebKit worked with the processor team and the processor team did some design work around Apple’s ARM variants to make JS pre compilation faster. This is also the whole idea of VLIW architectures where the processor manufacture depends on a team of compiler makers to ring out efficiencies and they work closely together. Heck even back in the Apple // days, Woz a developer, designed hardware and software together.