4 ms·
In other words: you're proposing to replace a set of possible, if difficult, technological solutions, with an near-impossible social solution. I'd call that mis
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
In other words: you're proposing to replace a set of possible, if difficult, technological solutions, with an near-impossible social solution. I'd call that misguided.
Technological solutions tend to be discussed because they can be implemented. Social solutions may work better, but only in imaginary la-la land where they can actually be put into practice. In the real world, you can't "just" get people to not drive.
- hyperhopper 3y agoIt's not impossible, much of the world operates without 99.9% car usage like the USA. Every major European city metro area can be traversed without a car. Hell I went through 18 countries and 35+ cities in Europe without renting a car and only using a bus or plane maybe 4-5 times. This is an entirely self-made problem. A world not reliant on cars is not la-la land. It's a land where a car isn't treated as more important than a human, which should be the norm and is known to work in many other first world countries.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThe USA is a lot more spread out than Europe. In places where it isn't (NYC, Chicago) you can get around without a car pretty well. Guess what, in small towns in Europe and in rural areas, most people have cars too, and they drive to get their groceries.
- enragedcacti 3y agoThe northeast corridor is practically as dense as western Europe and we have a number of car-dependent cities denser than major transit-rich European cities. > Guess what, in small towns in Europe and in rural areas, most people have cars too, and they drive to get their groceries. That's fine! lets get our intra and intercity transit solved and small town people can keep doing what they've been doing.
- mplewis 3y agoTrains aren’t difficult technical solutions.
- mminer237 3y agoTrains aren't a solution at all in most areas. My subdivision isn't going to build a rail line to the city 15 miles away. That would require a total abandonment of single-family housing at the least.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoWith trains, the hardware isn't the problem. The property rights are - specifically those of people owning land and real estate on, or near, the planned tracks. But it's still a possible (if uber expensive) problem - the government could eminent domain its way through. But expecting people to spontaneously abandon cars and demand trains? That is impossible in practice.
- anlsh 3y agoHah! Cars have been around for just a hundred years or so, and yet serious efforts to reduce our dependency on them are "near impossible." Talk about recency bias.
- baggy_trough 3y agoWould you say something similar about computers?
- anlsh 3y agoNo. But we're talking about cars, not computers, and their novelty is just one among many strong pieces of evidence that a much less car-dependent society is possible, even desirable. Perhaps you can refute the existence billions of people on the planet who live without commuting via car, or the dense networks of public transit which they often rely on?
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Perhaps you can refute the existence billions of people on the planet who live without commuting via car, or the dense networks of public transit which they often rely on? You have to remember that the infrastructure they depend on to have drinkable water, stores with food on shelves, power and other media, itself is built around cars and trucks, and depends on them being available and able to drive everywhere. Cars are intertwined with everything else in modern civilization - you can't just rip them out. Even if everyone other than critical infrastructure operators suddenly got rid of their cars, this still wouldn't let you eliminate roads from the city, as the trucks and construction equipment and ambulances etc. need to be able to go everywhere.
- bedobi 3y agoIt’s funny because you’re actually arguing against yourself. Those of us who want to reduce car dependency think exactly that: the use of cars, trucks and roads should be reserved for the less able, the elderly, delivery and emergency vehicles etc. Everyone else who don’t need to be there shouldn’t be. Imagine how much easier and safer everyone’s life would be if roads weren’t gridlocked by the countless million people making unnecessary trips in single occupant automobiles who don’t need to.
- kmeisthax 3y agoAutomobile dependency is not a technological problem, it is a social problem. Enormous sums of money were spent on lobbying, laws, and infrastructure, all just to make driving tolerable. The cost of this social experiment was that walking was made miserable and dangerous. A century ago people were saying, "in the real world, you can't just get people to not walk". But they did. We coined the term "jaywalking" to refer to walking down a street like a normal person, manufactured consensus against it, and criminalized anything other than crossing streets at 90 degree angles to get from sidewalk to sidewalk. All so that people in cars could drive faster, which prior to this would have been considered, rightfully, reckless. All the technological problems caused by cars are downstream of the social engineering done to force people into buying them. If people did not have to drive everywhere, then we wouldn't need to worry about tire dust, fuel efficiency, emissions, and all the other things downstream of forcing people to drive heavy metal boxes everywhere. If we decided to end this social experiment, we could. Slowly, and in degrees, of course. But generally speaking there's a lot of people who would like to not drive, but have to, and would be willing to deal with the infrastructure changes necessary to make that happen.
- Capricorn2481 3y ago> Automobile dependency is not a technological problem, it is a social problem. This is what the commenter said.
- fnordpiglet 3y ago“We” is not nearly as many as you may believe. I would say most people don’t want to give up their car. That’s why people spend so much time maintaining their cars, polishing them, buying nicer ones, etc. Some people want to give up their cars, but you need everyone to want this, and they don’t. A technical solution is more likely to work than a mass social upheaval.
- seadan83 3y agoThe "we" clearly refers to society at large. (I suspect you read what you wanted to read) > Some people want to give up their cars, but you need everyone to want this, and they don’t This is moving the goal posts, nobody said everyone would want to make s transition and a requirement for this is a novel requirement only now introduced by your response. The example is akin to: 30 people are currently driving to s grocery store 0.5 miles away. If the sidewalk to that store didn't end after 250 feet but actually went all the way, then 5 people would walk. If there were a bike lane, then 3 people would bike, if there were a decent bus, mird would ride, and finally if it were closer.. The line of logic given is basically, "because 100% of trips are done by car, nobody wants any alternative infrastructure, and suggesting that some people would use any alternative infrastructure is a war on cars."
- H12 3y agoWriting off a shift towards walkability as a "near-impossible social solution" I think is misrepresenting the nature of the problem. Shifting car-centric suburbs and exurbs to a walking-friendly lifestyle is a massive challenge, but that only covers 20% of the population. The remaining 80% of the population already live in urban areas that, in many cases, are already very livable car-free, and are a few small policy changes away from taking a massive step forward. Even a couple large municipalities legalizing accessory dwellings, abolishing parking minimums, and rezoning to allow business conversations of existing residential properties could have a sizable impact. Additionally, many of the most expensive areas in the country are ones that are designed specifically to support walkability, which is a strong indicator of unmet demand for such areas.
- xyst 3y agoThe 1950s suburban experiment through cheap money (new suburbs brought in short term influx of cash for cities/counties), massive subsidies of highway infrastructure, subsidies for automobile industries, redlining housing policies, and “white flight” pushed people towards driving. It can be reversed. Believe it out not, prior to the Industrial Revolution people got around just fine. Somehow the auto industry convinced people their dangerous machines in the hands of commoners was a good idea.
- Uehreka 3y agoThe “social solutions” are just policy solutions, and people on HN don’t like the idea of regulation, so they act like “social solutions are impossible”, when the truth is just that “social solutions are impossible without policies I find distasteful”.
- libraryatnight 3y agoSure you can. Teach your kids cars are stupid and bad and stop driving so much yourself. Trickle-down culture is real, economics not so much. Also your lauded tech solutions rarely do shit but create more problems and the businesses we hire to implement them lie about the problems until we've all got cancer, no air, and no water. Minimizing driving and making it a cultural value that it's a tool to be used sparingly seems reasonable and about the only solution I can actually trust when you have a culture of selfish assholes and a society with nothing underneath it but a pit of spikes.
- bedobi 3y ago> only in imaginary la-la land sorry but this is laughable, you don't need to imagine lala-land or some alternate reality, large parts of the world do not have anywhere near the car dependency that north america does and they're fine. (in fact, they're more than fine, they're great, they're better off) visit tokyo and see for yourself - a huge, sprawling city of 40 million, including many single family home areas, where much, much fewer people drive
- danny_codes 3y agoOf course we can. This is just a function of public policy. Once our cities are re-built around walk/bike/transit, nobody is going to drive because it will be slower and less convenient. Just like it is in many cities around the world.