3 ms·
> Another alternative is forcing these devices to be designed in such a way that installing unauthorized crypto tools isn't possible. On the plus side, this do
by ben_w 3y ago
> Another alternative is forcing these devices to be designed in such a way that installing unauthorized crypto tools isn't possible.
On the plus side, this does mean no more JavaScript and no more Excel spreadsheets. Unfortunately we'd have to ban nice things too, as those are only two of the things you'd have to ban to make this happen.
Don't get me wrong, the government behaviour you describe is plausible — turning those screws to make it harder is highly likely IMO — I'm just saying such limited things will never actually allow them to achieve their goals, and that unless they want to outlaw possession of computers at least as advanced as the Z1 from 87 years ago[0], they need to do their surveillance in a different way that doesn't break crypto.
(And that everyone else being able to do that surveillance necessitates substantial social change, but that's a different topic).
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z1_(computer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z1_(computer)
- miki123211 3y ago> On the plus side, this does mean no more JavaScript and no more Excel spreadsheets Probably true about Excel (or at least non-cloud Excel), but not JS. You can apply the App Store model but for websites. Require ID to get a TLS certificate, block anything which doesn't do TLS, allow certified websites to execute arbitrary code with a few technical restrictions. If somebody violates the law and is discovered, through either manual or automated means, they can be blocked via TLS revocation lists.