7 ms·
This is financial advice [video]
- hikingsimulator 3y agoHalfway in, this reads like yet another home run after his last year's video on NFTs. Just exposing fraud, manipulation, and tragedy -- in three-hour monuments.
- throw0101a 3y ago> […] last year's video on NFTs. * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQ_xWvX1n9g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQ_xWvX1n9g * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_Goes_Up_–_The_Problem_With_NFTs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_Goes_Up_–_The_Problem_Wit... See also the 2020 video that starts out on Flat Earth, a belief that is waining… because people are going to Qanon: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JTfhYyTuT44 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JTfhYyTuT44
- dleeftink 3y agoIt's a long watch, but I'm impressed at Dan's dedication to digitally 'live amongst' the subjects in question for each of his videos. Maybe even moreso by the enormous script that must have gone into this, without any of the talking head shots feeling rehearsed. Also incredible work by all the voice talents bringing these semi-anonymous comments to life!
- gilleain 3y agoFascinating intersections between people wanting to change the world and grifters and conspiracy theorists. How we so easily 'worldbuild' our way into a different reality in which up is down and literally accidentally tweeting a single letter is some kind of hidden mesage. Well worth the watch.
- ProllyInfamous 3y ago>Fascinating intersections between people wanting to change the world and grifters Echoes of hospital administrators 2000% growth since 1990... src: med school drop-out
- gilleain 3y agoSure, not an obvious connection but I see it :) In general, it seems like there are many people who see a problem - like with the financial system - but come up with a solution that will never work. Crypto, for example seemed very promising for many up to the point it was clearly bad (for now?). For meme stocks, there remain a core of people who are convinced (according to Olsen, and I believe him) that they have to hodl forever to change the world or get their reward. The problem (a self-serving, potentially corrupt financial system) may be real, but the solution (short-selling stock in a failing company) is definitely not.
- Raed667 3y agoThis is a brilliant video, I didn't know how deep the "game stop" saga goes
- usrme 3y agoSame. I had a vague notion that there were people HODL-ing still, but nothing on the level shown by Folding Ideas, yet again.
- 0x008 3y agoGreat production value
- bongobingo1 3y agoI'm at 2 hours in and my head is truly starting to spin. These people are unhinged and once again, everyone at the top is making off like bandits.
- FormerBandmate 3y agoIt's unironically a cargo cult. GameStop was insanely oversold by short sellers and had an astronomical short squeeze because of it, but then it got limited by the big guys (because it literally had the potential to bankrupt Robinhood) and now it's probably the purest example of an anti-establishment cult, taking legitimate grievances about Wall Street and making them stupid
- asfdgionion 3y agoGameStop's price didn't skyrocket because of a short squeeze. That was the story that kicked off the bubble, but there's little evidence it was true. https://www.sec.gov/files/staff-report-equity-options-market-struction-conditions-early-2021.pdf https://www.sec.gov/files/staff-report-equity-options-market... >Figure 6 shows that the run-up in GME stock price coincided with buying by those with> short positions. However, it also shows that such buying was a small fraction of overall buy volume, and that GME share prices continued to be high after the direct effects of covering short positions would have waned. The underlying motivation of such buy volume cannot be determined; perhaps it was motivated by the desire to maintain a short squeeze. Whether driven by a desire to squeeze short sellers and thus to profit from the resultant rise in price, or by belief in the fundamentals of GameStop, it was the positive sentiment, not the buying-to-cover, that sustained the weeks-long price appreciation of GameStop stock. What really happened is that some people on Reddit bought up a bunch of GameStop stock and went around convincing other people to buy it by telling them an appealing but false story. If done deliberately, that's called a pump-and-dump. Dumb money attracts smart money, so there were definitely some wolves among the sheep.
- cmcaleer 3y ago> What really happened is that some people on Reddit bought up a bunch of GameStop stock and went around convincing other people to buy it by telling them an appealing but false story. If done deliberately, that's called a pump-and-dump. Disclaimer: only read around figure 6 and the part you quoted I'm willing to buy this as part of the explanation, but reading through the methodology for Figure 6 seems flawed. It doesn't appear to account for positions being managed through derivatives (possible reporting requirements are different here?) as firms might have delta-hedged through these means rather than simply buying spot. Really weird that ctrl+F hedges gets so few results, and the Consolidated Audit Trail sample only beginning on December 24, 2020 seems like a major flaw. Like, really, there's a once-in-a-generation market event and the SEC only bother to get CAT data from a month (and many holiday+half days) before regarding the major event for a listed security that had been brewing for months? For me the most interesting (and imo alarming) part of the whole saga was the coordinated action by Robinhood, Trading212, IBKR and others to turn Gamestop into a sell-only asset. Increasing margin requirements? This seems obviously responsible in the circumstances. But effectively pausing a stock while there is no official trading halt was insane and seemed on the face of it to be coordinated. It's obvious that a retail-heavy stock would tank from such action being taken. If you did it to TSLA or MSFT there would be panic and dumping too. (After watching the video where he addresses this I'm still not super convinced there weren't alternative ways to do this without having outsized impact on specific stocks. He definitely plays down the fact that the 28th close was like -50% relative to 27th close as a direct consequence of the volatility caused by the pause, and doesn't mention that those with cleared funds still couldn't buy the stock with these brokers) Also interesting is how hedge funds have learned to exploit this kind of frenzy. I really hope that it will be possible to do research on BBBY to find out how much of that was astroturfed. Whipping up irrational actors through astroturfing seems like a pretty smart thing to do if you're in in Hudson Bay Capital's position with the agreement they had with BBBY. I'm not accusing Hudson Bay Capital of anything, I'm simply pointing out that the incentives were there. I've not watched the entire video yet, but I really hope it delves into that. The BBBY subreddit was kind of a morbid curiosity for me.
- tikkun 3y ago[flagged]
- jdthedisciple 3y agoYou know, I'm one of the few people who - as much as I'd love to honor the effort that went into it - I truly barely ever have the time to watch 2+ hour long videos anymore. So I appreciate it.
- prakhar897 3y agoYoutube never recommends me something and instead prefers to keep repeating old videos. Probably because people re-watch a lot. Is there any way as a consumer to discover new content (matching my taste) on Youtube. Seems like newer channels struggle a lot with this problem.
- ebiester 3y agoLike and subscribe to active channels that connect to what you want.
- hyperhopper 3y agoI'm not subscribed to this user and have never seen one of their videos, this was #1 on my YouTube home page last night. YouTube home page despite popular opinion is my best way to find new deep interesting content.
- throw0101a 3y agoStay logged out of Google account(s), clear your cookies, and go to the channels you already like to (re)build your 'preference profile' associated with the new cookie that Google sends you. Perhaps use browser profiles to separate your logged-in and logged-out 'personas'. If you want to watch a video, but don't want it to contaminate your current preferences, watch it in a private browser window.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 2143 3y agoI have always felt this is where recommendation engines go wrong. If I watch a cat video, it'll think all I like are cats. I may like content about Foo — something entirely unrelated to cats — if I watch it. But since I have never watched anything about Foo before (perhaps because I didn't know about its existence), it won't recommend me Foo. Therefore I wouldn't know it exists. Hence I never see it, even though if I had seen it I may (or may not) have liked it. Meanwhile, after a point I get tired of all the cat videos, and stop using the service. I want recommendation engines to occasionally recommend totally fresh content unrelated to anything I ever watched.
- rjbwork 3y agoI've been following this community since the january 2021. I'm 50 minutes in and this seems like a pretty accurate take thus far. It has absolutely morphed into a syncretic conspiracy theory, and even cargo cult as some other commenters have pointed out. I personally made a pretty penny on the run up just with some stop loss orders. I have been wheeling it for about 1.5 years as well and currently have 200 shares for free. I don't believe in any of the conspiracy theories, but these people keep pumping money in and maintaining a pretty stable trading channel, so I will keep selling theta.
- Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL 3y agoGoing a bit on side venture here with this comment, but I'd so much prefer this to be well written up instead of a two and half hour video. And it's so ubiquitous, watching videos over people reading, and I can't help but think it's extremely hurtful on a cultural/societal level. And the fact that it's creeping in more and more, even on HN, just shows that I must be more and more of an outlier,... is this what it feels to get old? Writing > Video, because: a) I have control over pace. Not just how fast I read, but how long I look at a graphic, or a slide, or I might reread a significant sentence, skip a paragraph where the author dwells on something for too long, stop reading to research something,... this also allows me to skim something to see if I'm interested... this is very hard to do with a 2 1/2 hour video... to the point of where I'm not looking into it for that very fact alone, I'm sad to say. I don't want my attention grabbed by 20 minutes of video watching to find out if it's worth watching... b) Text automatically engages your critical thinking completely differently. In text form it's far easier to see argumentative structure, and you are far more critically engaged in a subject matter. This applies to the reader, who can far more accurately scrutinize the arguments and logic applied, but also to the author while writing, who therefore produces by average far more valuable content. If you don't believe me transcribe audio to text (whether most speeches, podcasts, or other), and read it critically as if it was a book and find how (in most cases) horrendously it performs as text. This is by the way something we completely lost. Politicians long gone spoke modeled after written text. Speeches transcribed from Abraham Lincoln and fellow politicians of the era read like formally written up arguments... barely anyone can talk like this anymore (we've lost so much in that department). c) Writing is in some ways more and in some ways less effort than a video. And I'd argue it benefits the content itself. All that energy going into video production, editing, having a nice background and good sunlight for talking to the camera, would be so much better spent on properly writing, researching, citing sources... I'm in no way saying none of it is done, but priorities are completely different when "producing a video essay" versus "I'll write something proper that can stand scrutiny". And I'd argue the latter produces higher quality content. d) Text is far more easily accessible. I need a static HTML page to host text, it doesn't need any bandwidth to speak of, I can easily host it on my own site, on a blog hosting service, move hosting services, you could even use a pastebin and tweet the link. It's searchable, it can be fully indexed by search engines, it can be accessed via screen readers, easily auto-translated via any tools of ones choosing, easily copy-pasted into your own notes, can be easily cited, extended, worked on... God I wish people would write more, read more, and in turn produce less videos, and watch less videos... but I might just be a walking dinosaur, or (since I am not even middle aged) just have grown up differently, so... I don't know...
- nayuki 3y agoI refuse to watch this 2.5-hour video because I don't trust his words. I watched the entirety of one of his previous videos on a friend's recommendation - "Line Goes Up – The Problem With NFTs" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQ_xWvX1n9g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQ_xWvX1n9g . While I agree with the main premise that NFTs and cryptocurrencies are very problematic from many angles (financial, hype, scams, etc.), he made so many factual errors that I found it very hard to take it seriously. I have worked with Bitcoin software and can point out things he said that are an outright misrepresentation of the technology and mechanisms. (See also: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_Amnesia_effect https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_Amnesia_effect )
- malephex 3y agoPlease give some examples.
- jekrb 3y agoOne I didn't see the other's mention is that in Line Goes Up, Dan calls secure-scuttlebutt (SSB), a p2p messaging protocol, a blockchain. IIRC Dan was relying on a sentence from an outdated, archived documentation site made by an open source contributor many years ago. The core SSB devs then had to try to convince people that Dan was wrong about their project. Dan refused to admit he was wrong, despite a lack of blockchain in the open source code, and just pasted a screenshot of the old docs.
- nayuki 3y agoTo avoid the cost of sitting down for 3~4 hours to rewatch the full video while critiquing it and writing notes, I opted to skim the entire narration transcript and pick out some points. This is not a complete critique, but I'm bounded by how much time I can afford to spend on it. [0h01m15s] He talks about the 2008 Great Recession and frames it in terms of greedy banks offloading risky mortgages. But he fails to mention that the government entities FMAC and FMAE insured those subprime mortgages in order to encourage home ownership, which is what enabled this risk-taking in the first place. If the banks had their own money at risk rather than the government's money, they wouldn't have done it. [0h02m15s] > the biggest returns on a bond come from when it first hits the market, a new bond that creates new securities sales is worth more than an old bond that is slowly appreciating, but not seeing much trade. What? I'm pretty sure that's not how the bond market works. Bonds are priced fairly. Bonds being traded are sold at neither a premium nor discount to their fair market value. Also, the trading value of bonds doesn't appreciate or depreciate unless the interest rate changes. [0h14m15s] > How it works in Bitcoin, simply put, is that when a block of transactions are ready to be recorded to the ledger all of the mining nodes in the network compete with one another to solve a cryptographic math problem that’s based on the data inside the block. Effectively they’re competing to figure out the equation that yields a specific result Wording nitpick, but they the equation is easily known, but the values to solve that equation are what are hard to find. [0h14m42s] > Once the math problem has been solved the rest of the validation network can easily double-check the work, since the contents of the block can be fed into the proposed solution and it either spits out the valid answer or fails. If the equation works and the consensus of validators signs off on it the block is added to the bottom of the ledger and the miner who solved the problem first is rewarded with newly generated Bitcoin. Another wording nitpick. The verifier doesn't spit out the valid answer; it takes a proposed answer and spits out "valid" or "invalid". Secondly, the notion of the block being added to the bottom of the ledger glosses over the critical detail that every validator does so. Any validator can choose to reject the block, but it is not in their interest to do so because they would be going against consensus. [0h17m57s] > Because electrical consumption, electrical waste, is the value that underpins Bitcoin. Miners spend X dollars in electricity to mine a Bitcoin, they expect to be able to sell that coin for at least X plus profit. Wrong again, this alludes to the labor theory of value. It's the other way around: Because people are willing to put a value on Bitcoin for their transaction utility, miners are willing to spend electricity to prop up the system. [0h30m58s] > It’s an ecosystem that absolutely demolishes consumer protections and makes the re-implementation of them extremely difficult. He presumes that consumer protection is the only worthy goal. What about merchant protection? Search on Google for horror stories of eBay merchants getting scammed on PayPal by customers who lie about not receiving the product. Look at Louis Rossmann's rants about payment processors forcing merchants to eat the transaction fee even if a dispute is resolved in favor of the merchant. > the transaction fees on popular chains are so prohibitive that it’s pointless to use them on any transaction that isn’t hundreds, if not thousands of dollars The transaction fee on the Bitcoin network is definitely not hundreds or thousands of dollars. Look up any fee estimator and the exchange rate. https://ycharts.com/indicators/bitcoin_average_transaction_fee https://ycharts.com/indicators/bitcoin_average_transaction_f... [1h52m06s] > A deflationary economy punishes buying things, as anything that you buy today will inevitably be cheaper to buy in the future. This is factually true, and I'm pointing to the whole context without quoting several paragraphs. He shows the standard government economics bias that deflation is bad and inflation is good. Yet, he ignores the evidence. For example, the tech industry is massively deflationary. If you have $1000 today, you can buy a better laptop/iPhone/GPU next year if held onto this money for a bit longer. Yet, people still buy electronics. What gives? Well, there is a certain benefit to consuming in the present. It doesn't matter if you get x% more in the future, because someday you'll be dead. The point of saving money is to spend it someday, preferably before you're dead, unless you are generous about giving it to your kids. [1h53m29s] > We used to have a web where anyone could learn to write a webpage in HTML in an afternoon. You can still do that. Nothing obliges you to use 10 frameworks. We at HN can appreciate the basics, and there are tons of threads on this topic. Aside from the specific quotes, he alludes to capital and capitalism 10+ times. I know he has an anti-capitalist, probably socialist bent.
- internet101010 3y agoThe early days of WSB were much different compared to what it is today. It used to have some really smart people doing quality research and putting their money where their mouth was with large bets. As it grew and more new traders came in, the new traders started pumping out half-baked ideas to make a name for themselves and the other new traders followed and lost their life savings. Honestly I think that the focus on memes is partially to blame. All of the people that were originally in WSB left and went to a couple of smaller subreddits and/or a collection of small discord servers.
- twiceaday 3y ago“Any community that gets its laughs by pretending to be idiots will eventually be flooded by actual idiots who mistakenly believe that they're in good company.” - Earnest Hemingway
- PoignardAzur 3y agoEarliest source I've found for this quote is a 2009 HN discussion. (And indeed, it seems like a very internet-ish kind of quote.) But yeah, sounds about right.
- l33t7332273 3y agoIt really is an internetish quote. How many communities got their laughs by pretending to be idiots in the days of Hemingway?
- satvikpendem 3y agoIt's simply a variation on Poe's Law, which origin is from 2005.
- wlonkly 3y agoI thought that quote was from the Buddha. (Well, he said "Any sangha..." but still.)
- mettamage 3y ago
- latchkey 3y agoA long time ago, I worked for a company called MarinSoftware (MRIN). When I left, I bought whatever shares I had vested (it wasn't that much) thinking maybe some day it'll pay off. The CEO [0] is this short little guy with a Napoleon complex and I figured if anyone could extract value from this business, he could. Eventually, the company went public and the stock performed as expected... it went to shit. This could be due to the company never actually realizing a profit, but who knows. Having worked on the inside, I knew that the technology stack was shit and the engineers working on the system were subpar. For example, the CTO hired his cousin. Since the stock was under water, I held onto it for a a number of years (10?). My internal reasoning was that I wanted to wait until it got as close to zero as possible before selling so that I could maximize my tax loss. Yea, right. Suddenly, in the middle of covid, the reddit "investors" decided to randomly start to pump the stock [1]. It really came out of nowhere and I was kind of lucky to have checked the stock price. Jokingly, I set my limit order for 25 and left it there. A day or two later, I got notified that all of my shares had sold. Thanks WSB! [0] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/marin-software-inc-ceo-christopher-210845243.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/marin-software-inc-ceo-christ... [1] https://investorplace.com/2021/07/mrin-stock-why-reddit-investors-are-sending-marin-software-higher-today/ https://investorplace.com/2021/07/mrin-stock-why-reddit-inve...
- reducesuffering 3y ago> I wanted to wait until it got as close to zero as possible before selling so that I could maximize my tax loss That is... not how finance works.
- latchkey 3y ago> Yea, right. You're saying that to the person who literally sold the very top.
- keithalewis 3y agoLook into "tax loss harvesting".
- 3y ago
- cowthulhu 3y agoThe superstonk crowd were my first real interaction with people fully in on a conspiracy theory. It was a huge learning experience for me - I'd always sort-of believed that if I was ever face to face with, like, a flat earther or whatever, I'd be able to talk them out of their beliefs. Super naive, I know! Interacting on that subreddit though really hammered home that people in a conspiracy theory don't really _read_ your post, so much as flag it as non-conforming then dunk on it. It was pretty eye-opening for me, and I'm really glad noone in my life has drank the kool-aid on any conspiracies because I'm not really sure there's anything you can do.
- izzydata 3y agoI know some people that lost a ton of money on this. It was definitely one of the weirdest things I've seen someone get absolutely convinced of. Any evidence that was contrary to what they already believed was more proof in their eyes to what they believed. Because it was just the "bad guy" trying to beat them. These are seemingly intelligent people that would recognize this same problem in other peoples conspiracy theories and willingly ignorant beliefs. At this point what is there to possibly do? It doesn't seem like a good idea to bring it up at this point and be like "I told you so" and just get them mad. I hope they have recognized their mistake by now on their own.
- netsharc 3y agoOne of the video's conclusion from 2:14:27[1] - 2:18:03 is chilling, "the illusion must be defended at all costs, because the illusion is all that is.". He does call it outward-facing performance, but I'm not so sure if it's not also inward-facing, I think there are many "unhinged" out there who'd rather live in (and defend) the fantasy world rather than accept reality. Accepting reality would mean admitting they've been conned (or even, fooled themselves), that they're not as smart as they thought they were (because in their view: what smart people get conned?), and many of them have too fragile of egos to admit that, and would rather emotionally lash out rather than go down that "shameful" path of self-evalution when challenged. Throughout the whole video I'm reminded of the Game Designer’s Analysis Of QAnon[2], where people are thrilled about connecting dots and finding hints where there are none intended. To delve into politics, there are also many unhinged who put their hope of a better life, some of them probably did so first into Obama (Obama himself has said in his post-presidency book, he found it worrying when running in 2008 that people were putting their dreams and hopes into him), and some of them, when they found their lives hadn't gotten better in 2016, probably thought "Well, Hillary will be more of the similar, and Trump promises greatness (again), what the hell do I have to gain for voting 'similar', and what the hell do I have to lose for voting 'greatness (again)'?". In some sense Bernie also offered that radical change, but if you want to blame brown, gays, etc, people for your suffering, Trump was the easier choice. And rather than admit that they've been conned, they'd rather invent a million scenarios why Trump was (and is) the correct choice, there's just some deep state conspiracy ensuring the continued enslavement of the poor (Note: I don't share this viewpoint, just summarizing it!). [1] https://youtu.be/5pYeoZaoWrA?t=8067 https://youtu.be/5pYeoZaoWrA?t=8067 [2] https://medium.com/curiouserinstitute/a-game-designers-analysis-of-qanon-580972548be5 https://medium.com/curiouserinstitute/a-game-designers-analy...