4 ms·
> The majority of the population does not have the background to consider the implications of say, banning E2EE, they do have the background to understand that
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> The majority of the population does not have the background to consider the implications of say, banning E2EE, they do have the background to understand that CSAM is bad.
This is all still just framing and you're only falling into the trap.
One of the many strong arguments against this kind of government surveillance is it's the sort of thing authoritarian governments use to commit atrocities. People can certainly understand that Nazis are bad and technologies that protect people from Nazis are good. Now all you need is to point to the proponents of the scanning and ask why they want to help Nazis.
It's the same tactic they're using. And then they use counter-tactics, like weaponizing Godwin's Law even in cases when you actually are discussing authoritarian government policy.
It has nothing to do with the nature of the issue and everything to do with the fact that the proponents of these measures are professionally trained propagandists who know exactly what they're doing.
Maybe we need a corollary to Godwin's Law. Let's call it Lovejoy's Law:
As the length of a policy debate increases, the probability that someone implores you to Think Of The Children approaches 1, and the person to do this loses the argument.
- ethbr1 3y agoI've heard Nazis used encryption. Ergo, encryption helped Nazis.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThis is exactly what I mean about framing. The Nazis used infamously broken encryption. We have to make sure our codes can't be broken, unlike the foolish evildoers. The Germans were never able to defeat the Navajo code talkers, and then we won the war.