3 ms·
> American Muslims are more affluent and highly educated than the average American Is this not just due to the immigrant effect, ie the only ones who can affor
by satvikpendem 3y ago
> American Muslims are more affluent and highly educated than the average American
Is this not just due to the immigrant effect, ie the only ones who can afford to immigrate (legally, at least) are those who are relatively rich (which correlates with high education levels) in their countries? It takes money to shore up a visa and buy a plane ticket, that most individuals in poorer countries would not be able to afford. American Hindus (including Indians), East Asians etc are also more affluent and highly educated than the average American, for the same reasons.
- catlover76 3y agoIt is not necessarily "rich", but you're on the right track. During the 70s and 80s, US immigration policy basically filtered/let through mostly people who came here for college or higher education. That was the case for India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh at least, I believe. So of course the South Asian population here skews successful and educated. I am not sure what immigration policy was like for Arabs.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI'm saying that those who can even cross the seas are relatively richer than their peers in their home country. It is not just a function of a country opening immigration, the potential immigrant must first be able to afford to do so in the first place.
- catlover76 3y agoMaybe, I'm not sure; the trope of people coming here with pretty much nothing and being able to establish a life is a true one that plays out time and time again. My own grandfather came here from India with very little--literally few dollars to his name, had to live with someone he knew for a bit, ate "ketchup sandwiches" regularly, etc. So I think in his case he had the resource of a network, but not much financial resources. And my dad came to the US for college from Pakistan, also with basically nothing--his family did not have much money. But yes, I suppose there is literally the trip across the ocean that costs money.
- satvikpendem 3y agoHow exactly did they come here? Who paid for their flight or ship voyage? That is the "relatively rich" I'm talking about. My parents (and I) also came here on not much money, but I can realize that having the ability to come to the country in the first place as well as secure a job cannot be understated.
- catlover76 3y agoYes, I take your meaning :)
- selimthegrim 3y agoWell, this is not universal - my great grandfather came from undivided Punjab in the 1920s as a merchant sailor and I think had about seven kids in USA.
- catlover76 3y agoOh that's cool man, what's the story there? Was he among the Sikhs who settled in farming communities in California and intermarried with the Chicano population?
- selimthegrim 3y agoNo, he was an Ahmedi in Kapurthala whose ancestors were sweetsellers from Bareilly. He went to New York, then Detroit and then Pittsburgh.
- catlover76 3y agoAh cool--pretty unique story! How much of his religion and culture survived down to your generation of the family tree?
- 3y ago
- rayiner 3y agoThey may be more affluent than Indians back home, but many start at the bottom of the ladder in America. Asians are actually the highest poverty rate group in NYC. But Asian income mobility from the bottom of the income distribution is about 2.5x the income mobility of white Americans. Also don’t forget that many East Asians came here as laborers and railroad workers in the 1800s and early 20th century, and as refugees in the 1950s-1980s. Third generation California Chinese, or Vietnamese, are also more affluent than white Americans today, for reasons that have nothing to do with immigration of affluent individuals.