3 ms·
> Where consumerism is high, procreation is low, as children and parenthood are antithetical to the ethos of consumption. This ethos infects and corrupts every
by wkat4242 3y ago
> Where consumerism is high, procreation is low, as children and parenthood are antithetical to the ethos of consumption. This ethos infects and corrupts every domain of the culture and conspires against families by creating a mutually enabling thicket of disincentives, consumerizing and commoditizing everything, including sexual intercourse and sexual relations, in general. Contraception and sterile "sex" are paradigmatic of consumerism.
I have to disagree here. Having more money to spend on consumer items is not the only reason to not want kids.
For me it's not about money but about time. I don't want to waste time raising kids that I could have used pursuing interesting opportunities to enrich myself. Which are usually not things that make me financially richer either. And also, I just don't want them. There is no attraction to fatherhood for me.
But I would not call myself consumerist at all. I don't buy that much stuff, don't have a car, only a $100 second-hand TV, buy a new phone once every 4 years or so... But I do have a really interesting life. I learn new things every day, constantly move my horizons. I couldn't do that if I were tied down with a family. Many of my friends do have them but if we want to go on a weekend away we have to plan it months in advance because they have to find a common path between all the birthday parties, judo competitions and dance performances of their offspring. I can just do whatever I want on a whim.
And once people become parents their sex life becomes pretty much null and void too.
There is definitely a correlation between high standards of living and smaller families yes. But I don't think this is because people want to spend more. It's just that they don't really need a big family for "pension" reasons, don't usually care about religious directives anymore (think the big catholic labourer families of old) and want their life to be more than about having kids. Women don't just want to be a baby machine anymore. It takes a toll on their bodies too.
And I think it's good. For environmental reasons our population should be stable, not growing rapidly. 2 children per couple is perfect.
- keiferski 3y agoDon’t think of consumerism as consumer products. Think of it as “consumption”, rather than creation. A focus on consuming and experiencing things in the world, not building them - of which a family with children is a prime example.
- wkat4242 3y agoBut I build a lot. Most of my hobbies involve creativity and making of things like electronics and 3D printing. I don't think having a family would be as valuable even.
- keiferski 3y agoWell I don’t want to be too harsh, but from my point of view, the idea that your hobbies are more important than the creation of life is a very shallow consumeristic one. It’s a very limited, self-focused way of being in the world. That’s not even mentioning the fact that you can share your hobbies with your children.
- wkat4242 3y agoI just don't think creating life is that special :) or necessary. There's already too many humans in this world. And I don't view it as something sacred. In fact if I'd want a child I'd adopt one and give them a better life. I think it's better to lift an orphan out of poverty than to reproduce myself. Also, I have too many mental issues I would not want to bestow upon a child. But I'm just not interested in either. None of my friends who have kids have done this out of a sense of community or purpose though. It was a choice driven by their own desire, just as selfish as my own reasons not to have any.
- anthonypasq 3y ago> There's already too many humans in this world. what does this actually mean? people say this but i dont understand it.
- satvikpendem 3y agoWhy is a hobby shallow but the creation of life deep? Surely that depends on the hobby as well. Having a child can be seen, in one aspect, as a very expensive and time consuming hobby. What is so special about creating life, anyway?
- tomp 3y ago> I learn new things every day, constantly move my horizons. I couldn't do that if I were tied down with a family. Try explaining these concepts to children. Now that’s a challenge! > And once people become parents their sex life becomes pretty much null and void too. I can guarantee that’s not true for everyone. Of course, maybe even some single couples get bored of having sex, and maybe even single men see their libido drop with age! > For environmental reasons our population should be stable, not growing rapidly. That’s a common trope pushed by degrowth activists like Greenpeace, but not actually true. Technology gives us means to so more with less, so we are far from the limits of even what Earth can support, let alone our solar system.
- wkat4242 3y ago> Try explaining these concepts to children. Now that’s a challenge! Could be but I don't want to :) even in work I don't have the patience for training others because it slows me down. > I can guarantee that’s not true for everyone. Of course, maybe even some single couples get bored of having sex, and maybe even single men see their libido drop with age! Of course it's not the case for everyone but on average it is for sure. All my friends say they simply don't have enough time or opportunity. Let alone doing more wild stuff like going to sensuality resorts or swinger clubs. It becomes more of a standard up/down "let's get this over with before the kid wakes up" kinda thing. > Technology gives us means to so more with less, so we are far from the limits of even what Earth can support, let alone our solar system. Well it hasn't actually delivered that. Right now we're doing more with much more. Look at the ocean full of plastic, the ever rising oil use. The climate crisis. If technology can give us those means it should really start doing so pretty soon before we really screw the world beyond repair. And really, exponential growth has to stop somewhere. Eventually it has to. Better to do it before the absolute limits are reached and it becomes another acute crisis like we have now with the climate.
- michaelhoney 3y agoNo, we’re fucking up the planet pretty badly, and our impact is (consumption x population).
- sokoloff 3y ago