3 ms·
Lots of countries outside the west are not having kids, especially the collectivist cultures of Asia which directly contradicts your "western individualism" vie
by satvikpendem 3y ago
Lots of countries outside the west are not having kids, especially the collectivist cultures of Asia which directly contradicts your "western individualism" view.
- pphysch 3y agoIf you look at the actual countries, it is obvious that the young people not having kids are also relatively individualistic.
- satvikpendem 3y agoHow is that obvious? Where are the statistics to show that they are individualistic?
- pphysch 3y agoI'm not going to spend a bunch of time digging up statistics for you, because I think it is obvious for anyone who has spent significant time in urban areas of developed countries. The youth are obviously individualistic, focused on short-term personal fulfillment, and building a family is the opposite of that. There just aren't throngs of young people living "traditionally" (non-individualistically) yet not having kids.
- satvikpendem 3y agoThere's nothing "obvious" about that. If it's so obvious, you should be able to "dig up statistics." Otherwise, you're just using your anecdotes as some statement of fact. I could do the same and you would be unable to refute them, but I don't think that makes for very engaging discussion on this forum, then.
- wesapien 3y agoNo way. Youth actually want to belong to a group and fit in unless they are comfortable being outcasts in school (to to college) and not having a social life. The youth are obsessed with cool things and trendy/hip things. They are the most easy target for marketing and sales.
- tuatoru 3y agoWell, again coming from a "female choice" perspective, young Chinese women are striving to have careers (or at least fun) before starting a family. They are being told to do this, and most people conform to expectations. (Choice doesn't mean fully independent first-principles decision making.) The rhetoric is still about "increasing female labor force participation".[1] For clarity, the thing you do first is your priority. This is known as "revealed preference" in economics. And careers are individual things, not collective. Also for background, fertility declines secularly from mid-teens to mid forties where it goes to zero. Waiting has two costs: you have fewer years in which to have children, and you are less likely to have them in each year. (There is a third one in increased risk of congenital illness in the child too.) Nearly every woman knows these things. 1. https://thechinaproject.com/2022/03/08/women-at-work-in-china-in-2022/ https://thechinaproject.com/2022/03/08/women-at-work-in-chin...
- mensetmanusman 3y agoUm, China destroys the hypothesis.