3 ms·
Look at all of the small companies that Apple has bought over the years to integrate their technologies into the iPhone. None of those companies could have ha
by scarface_74 3y ago
Look at all of the small companies that Apple has bought over the years to integrate their technologies into the iPhone. None of those companies could have had the scale or the no how to create a useful product by themselves.
Even if you look at chip design, there are only a few companies that I can actually manufacture chips. But plenty of companies that can design processors.
Your law would only help big companies.
- CamperBob2 3y agoIt's easy to imagine a modification to the proposed law that would be beneficial: only the original inventor is allowed to assert patent rights as a nonpracticing entity. That way, the small-time inventor can sell their patent to Apple, or (yes) they could act as a patent troll. But they can't sell it to Intellectual Ventures or another professional patent troll that produces nothing but lawsuits.
- mook 3y agoWho's name is on the patent lawsuit doesn't need to be related to who's funding the patent lawsuit. Being able to pay for somebody else's lawsuit and get a share of the profits is occasionally (but not always) useful; that's basically lawsuits on contingency, and is important for smaller players to sue bigger players.
- davidhyde 3y agoI like this idea. The inventor should also have to use the jurisdiction in which their company was registered or they lived. Also, I think software patents should be not be granted, period. But if they are they should be for no longer than 10 years. This 20 year catch-all is nonsense.
- eek2121 3y agoI am going to have to disagree there. Anyone can file a patent. Costs are cheap (except the lawyer, but if you have a decent patent, lawyers are also cheap) It seems like a whole lot of folks are worried that this will upset something, and can seemingly be unable to name/describe what that thing is except to claim that crap is incredibly cost expensive/difficult to theorize/design/develop...then some guy does it in his basement and gets sued for a bajillion dollars. I actually do support patents, but really, money is not effort, and if effort is zero, you should not be allowed to patent said effort. Using your brain is also not effort. I can think of a million different ways to patent a device that "bends you over and shoves a large stick like device in your anus", should I be granted said patent? I suspect a proper solution would be to make patent licensing completely illegal, and make patents have a 3 year expiration instead of 10 years unless you try to develop/market your patent on your own. Even in those cases, you should not be allowed to license your patent. That is just me, however.
- scarface_74 3y agoSo if you make patent licenses illegal, how are the small companies that build a better widget for a larger device - cars, computers, phones ever suppose to make money? How is the chip designer going to make money if they can’t license their designs to companies that actually make products? 3 years is barely enough time to get hardware to market. It took Panic 10 years to get the Playdate to market.
- raverbashing 3y agoA lot of these are covered by copyright, trademarks or simply by contracts > that build a better widget for a larger device - cars, computers, phones ever suppose to make money? The same they do today? By selling actual products?
- scarface_74 3y agoNone of my examples are covered by copyrights or trademarks. If they were covered by copyright, that would be worse. Copyright lasts 75 years, patents last 20. Why would you sign a contract with someone for their inventions if you didn’t have to? > The same they do today? By selling actual products? Do you realize how hard it is to do hardware at scale? One of my examples was chip design. Are you saying that ARMs business model of coming up with chip designs and then licensing them shouldn’t be legal?
- raverbashing 3y ago> Why would you sign a contract with someone for their inventions if you didn’t have to? Because you're buying the blueprints for the actual project instead of wasting time reverse-engineering it or developing it yourself There are plenty of ASIC/VHDL IP libraries not backed by patents, for example, and people still buy them
- scarface_74 3y agoSo ARM is just going to sell the blueprints once to Apple and Apple is going to turn around and use those blueprints to make literally billions of dollars? How is that going to work? Does Apple pay the same price as some no name Android manufacturer?