2 ms·
I still don't understand why these days we don't just post our papers to OpenReview and call it a day. They support community comments (so you get reviews and f
by godelski 3y ago
I still don't understand why these days we don't just post our papers to OpenReview and call it a day. They support community comments (so you get reviews and feedback from other researchers. More specifically/importantly, researchers interested/knowledgeable in your niche), it supports revisions, all the information is public.
I just can't for the life of me figure out how journals improve the system. The only thing I see is they help reach, but these days that's more handled by the researchers themselves and the universities. The universities are just paying _and_ subsidizing these journals (as well as government). They directly pay for access, they donate, they pay in that their workers also work for these journals (without pay), and so on. What do journals __do__?
- neural_thing 3y agoProvide a mark of credibility bureaucrats can understand. They can't evaluate the merits of a paper on, say, dendritic computation, but they know what level of respect a Nature Neuroscience publication generally commands. My solution is to build new centres of research without bureaucrats.
- godelski 3y ago> Provide a mark of credibility bureaucrats can understand. I think they accomplish the second half but have routinely established that they are incapable of doing the first half. 1) I don't think you can honestly validate or invalidate most research, though there is a bias towards being able to invalidate. I mean in science you tend to not prove things, but disprove things. People forget that the distinctions between things aren't "True vs False" but there's a third option "Indeterminate". Whether you want to point to Godel, Turing, or Schrödinger or whoever. This binarization actually harms science. 2) Metrics for metric's sake is highly destructive to our society and science. Goodhart's Law has clearly been taken to the extreme in our modern society. It's the exact reason everyone hates bureaucrats. Because there is a lack of nuance. The world has gotten more complex, removing nuance from our conversations is going in the opposite direction. Increased complexity can't result in increased hand waving. You just make more errors, at a rate proportional to the increasing complexity.