5 ms·
DOJ vs. Google evidence release that judge calls embarrassing exhibit [pdf]
- talkingtab 3y agoThis is a frank discussion about "search advertising", probably from someone at google. If it was not already clear to anyone, this explains it clearly: "... we could mostly ignore the demand side of the equation (users and queries) ..." In other words the people who use google search and what they want to know can mostly be ignored. Instead the focus is on "advertisers" where advertiser is a euphemism for anyone who wants to target people for any purpose. This purpose can and does include disrupting our social order, promoting extremist causes, selling products that are unfit for use or products that are prohibitively expensive. In case you have not been paying attention, welcome to clickbaitnet.
- jcranmer 3y agohttps://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/09/google-exec-said-users-get-hooked-on-search-engine-like-cigarettes-or-drugs/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/09/google-exec-said... has more discussion of the context. > probably from someone at google. Specifically, it's "meeting notes that Google’s vice president for finance, Michael Roszak, created for a course on communications."
- jppittma 3y agoSeems to me like there are two disjointed teams worrying about two different things. Search org is worried about daily active users and user experience, and ads is worried about monetizing search. The reason finance doesn't have to worry about demand is because search org is worrying about it.
- eastbound 3y agoDid that person work on the Youtube search? You can search for any topic and videos from your feed keep appearing in the search results, no matter how unrelated. Google’s lawyers should make the case that they can’t be trialled for monopoly on the search, because it’s one aspect that they don’t even do anymore.
- notacoward 3y agoWhat's missing is that they've exhibited monopolistic behavior toward their "supply" side (advertisers) as well. "Tear the economics textbook in half" is a weird way to say "follow exactly what the book says regarding monopolies".
- sonotathrowaway 3y agoMonopsonistic*
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 3y agoYou say potato, I say pedant.
- astrange 3y agoThey're literally opposite concepts with opposite effects. Which is why it doesn't make much sense to call a middleman either one, when they're both.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 3y ago"They're opposite" is the most incorrect statement in this thread. Yes, there is a difference, but the effects can be similar. Either way, market participants are denied a fair price because of their counterparty's dominance. This very case demonstrates it, as does Amazon's. That's why our laws treat them similarly, even using the word "monopoly" to mean both ... as do professional economists when both are under discussion. This "I know a word you don't know" game is tiresome, especially when people do know the words (and apparently better than you).
- voisin 3y agoThere’s nothing surprising here. We’ve known for two decades that Google and others treat users as the product being sold to their actual customers - the advertisers. We need to stop being shocked that the companies themselves, addicted to ad revenue, did some truly despicable things and most of the people at them (yes, many on this forum) actively enabled these behaviours and acted as apologists for them. Seriously, fuck Google and fuck Meta and if your company is ad driven then it’s on you too.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoAd blocking is a moral imperative. We should all do what we can to drive these advertiser profits to as close to zero as humanly possible. This will fix the web.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoOr boycott them entirely
- avidiax 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20230930132321/https://www.justice.gov/d9/2023-09/416692.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20230930132321/https://www.justi...
- bitshiftfaced 3y agoI spent too much time trying to parse the meaning of this headline. I wish HN would train a regressor for the difficulty in understanding a headline's meaning, and then automatically restrict them past some threshold.
- dylan604 3y agorelease ^that judge Is it really that difficult?
- mandmandam 3y agoIt is, yeah.
- londonReed 3y agoNo, not really.
- jcranmer 3y agoIt is a noun phrase (which means there's no main predicate verb) where 4 words in the middle could be read as verbs. So yes, it can actually take a few tries to parse the headline correctly.
- kens 3y agoWhat is the correct parsing of the headline? At first I figured it was a regular garden-path sentence [1] but after multiple readings I still can't figure it out. [1] A garden-path sentence is one where you find at the end that the expected parsing is wrong. e.g. "The old man the boat" or "The horse raced past the barn fell". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garden-path_sentence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garden-path_sentence
- branweb 3y agoNew evidence was released in the DOJ vs Google case. The judge for the case called this evidence "embarrassing" to Google. It's a bad headline. There's no a complete sentence here. "DOJ vs. Google evidence release" is a noun phrase ("release" here is used as a noun), modified by the clause "that judge calls embarrassing exhibit". In that clause, "judge" is the subject, "calls" is the verb, "that" is the direct object, and "embarrassing exhibit" is an object compliment, which refers to the same thing as "that". So basically we just have a big noun phrase.
- salawat 3y agoNote: Not having to worry about the demand side of the equation == no interest in gaining the consent of the advertised to. The advertising industry has a problem with consent. Q.E.D. I will not accept anyone who fundamentally tries to use platitudes to go "but it's just ads". No damnit. It's not "just ads". My answer is no, not only do you not ask, but when you go and do it anyway, you get pissy when I start blocking everything to do with you. Anything that can be destroyed by the truth deserves to be destroyed by the truth. To hell with Google, and to hell with web advertising. Let it all burn.
- gorjusborg 3y agoAmen.
- RandomLensman 3y agoAs not everyone shares your hatred for ads, maybe we need two webs in the end: one with ads, one without?
- salawat 3y agoI've actually already had that solution architected for years. Web partitioning. One is an indexed information retrieval system, purely intended to be a non-commercial/mercantile address space. One is designed as essentially a business registry. You must be a business (in the legal fiction sense) to be a part. You can advertise to your heart's content in the mercantile web. In the non-mercantile, all toxic/polluting forms of SEO will be pruned with extreme prejudice. The problem? There's no way in hell that there will not be low-key infiltration efforts by the mercantile side of things into the non-mercantile, simply because that'd be leaving money on the table. Further, the non-mercantile one will probably be so absurdly resource constrained as to eventually be subsumed by the mercantile Net in one way or another. There's also still the problem of administrative authorities being pressured into intentional distortions of search indexes.
- RandomLensman 3y agoWhy the need to restrict the second one to business only? Not sure I see a need for that. The first one kind of exists in various commercial forms but they are really expensive. Would your version be a kind of public utility?
- remram 3y agoI can't parse this title. Which is the verb?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 3y agoCalls
- exegete 3y agoA judge calls this evidence from DOJ vs. Google an embarrassing exhibit?
- ImPostingOnHN 3y ago(a judge) calls (this evidence from DOJ), ('an embarrassing exhibit') an exhibit, in this context, is a piece of evidence this one was embarrassing for google
- kaz-inc 3y agoyou guys remember the archaic "which" article that was on hackernews a few days ago? "DOJ vs Google evidence releases, which evidence judge calls embarrassing" found it!: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37629780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37629780
- hotnfresh 3y agoI loot authors I read for grammar, and I picked this and “nb” up from David Foster Wallace, who used both all the time. This usage of “which” is really handy for achieving clarity in certain situations.
- wyldfire 3y agoIt's a sentence fragment without a verb. "DOJ v Google evidence release" is a noun phrase. If you wanted to rewrite it as a sentence and weren't constrained by conventions used in headlines, you could rewrite it as, "Evidence released in DOJ v Google case includes an exhibit that the Judge called embarrassing [for Google]"
- dgreensp 3y agoWell it’s true, they don’t have to worry about amount of demand because everyone needs search and Google dominates that market, with no one challenging their >90% market share or the use of that kind of search to find things on the Web. I don’t think ads are really the “supply,” though. This seems like one person writing down their personal observations, which are not super deep.
- dylan604 3y agoWhat is your definition of challenging? There are multiple other search engines that make up your admitted <10% share. That sounds like challenging to me. Your definition must be closer to neck-to-neck competing which is unrealistic expectations
- ohdannyboy 3y agoAt a feature level Bing is super competitive, if not outright superior with their AI search features. It hasn't proven effective yet in becoming people's idea of the defacto search, but it is competing (see Googles humiliating AI launch).
- throwaway67743 3y agoI mean, it should be a pretty easy case, Google search is objectively terrible and their other practices are extremely shady as shown repeatedly. Obviously law isn't that simple but at least the judge appears to be seeing through their behavior!
- kevinventullo 3y agoOk then switch to Bing, or Yahoo, or DDG, or Yandex, or…
- throwaway67743 3y agoExcept their results are still sub par, which is the whole point of the case - Google has abused it's position to make competition difficult to impossible.
- xen0 3y agoHow exactly does Google make Bing sub-par?
- recursive 3y agoWhat does "objectively" mean here?
- throwaway67743 3y agoDemonstrably terrible results for the simplest of queries, returning drive by malware as preferred results etc, there is nothing subjective about that.
- verteu 3y agoWould you mind providing an example or two? I hear this often on HN, but it never happens to me (perhaps because I use Adblock?)