3 ms·
The internet enables people to uncover the worst of society if they so choose. Nobody bats an eye about it, because it grew slowly. Attempts to lock the interne
by echelon 3y ago
The internet enables people to uncover the worst of society if they so choose. Nobody bats an eye about it, because it grew slowly. Attempts to lock the internet behind an ID verification system fail time and time again because the system was conceived and built without one.
The internet had a period of time where only experts and enthusiasts had access, then in the 2000s everyone started to join what was already snowballing in popularity. Not only did the voices of censorship not really have a say in the rise of the technology, the internet was the bastion of free speech when it came into prominence.
LLMs are the same, except that everyone on the planet can now be exposed to them. Lots of folks are clamoring about safety without seeing the parallel to the internet itself. In the previous era, these journalists might have been writing for a newspaper and not fully aware of the capabilities of what was being developed.
If the internet was being built today with the attitudes of the present, I'd be shocked if we wound up with the same freedoms we have now.
LLMs can say bad things and make horrible suggestions, but this is greenfield. The fact that companies are releasing their systems to the public is a good thing and shouldn't be chastised. Safety will be figured out, but it's too early to slam research and engineering that doesn't incorporate it. If we shut down these efforts, we'll wind up with monopolistic corporate control that is overly censored.
Imagine what the internet would look like if we'd been criticizing it the same way.
- thelastparadise 3y ago> Attempts to lock the internet behind an ID verification system fail time and time again. The biggest problem these wanna be censors have is that their position is ultimately untenable with respect to reason, logic, and objective reality. If we look a few moves ahead, they end up censoring bona fide facts and knowledge. This pushes us toward a modern day dark age.
- nvm0n2 3y agoIt'd be nice if that were true but in most of the world you can't get online without ID verification. Even for WiFi you will need a text message, which ties it to your phone number which ties it to your identity
- echelon 3y agoThat's so fucked.