10 ms·
Microsoft Says the Days of Free Windows 7 to 10 or 11 Updates Are Over
- rbanffy 3y agoIt's not like I'd be using Windows 11 on a PC if it weren't a free upgrade. I keep one Windows machine in the house because it's handy for tests for things that need to work in Windows and because lots of my colleagues use Windows and sometimes I need to check something I am not going to try on my corporate-issue Windows laptop. OTOH, Windows usually comes for free on PCs (not all offer discounts for not running Windows).
- djbusby 3y agoYou pay for Windows when you buy a no-OS PC because the manufacturer still had to buy the license from MS.
- elkos 3y agoDid the manufacturer had to pay or did Microsoft had to pay the manufacturer?
- djbusby 3y agoManufacturer pays MS a Windows license fee for every system sold, regardless of OS.
- rbanffy 3y agoIIRC, they could pay a higher fee per system actually sold with Windows, or a lower price for every machine sold, regardless of OS. Remember Microsoft IP infects everything, from SDCards to EFI/UEFI.
- LoganDark 3y agoSome vendors offer a discount if you buy the laptop with Linux instead. See System76.
- djbusby 3y agoThose vendors don't have a license agreement with MS. But Dell, Lenovo, etc do.
- LoganDark 3y agoSo vendors exist that do not have a license agreement with MS. I rest my case.
- djbusby 3y agoI already knew that, we weren't at odds. There is no "case"
- LoganDark 3y agoThe case is that there are indeed computers you can buy that are not, in fact, eating the cost of a Windows license, because OEMs exist that do not have those agreements with MS. "You pay for Windows when you buy a no-OS PC" is not true if said no-OS PC didn't have to eat the cost of a Windows license.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoIt's coming...OS as a subscription.
- booleandilemma 3y agoIt's never too late to switch to linux.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoYeah. That's where I'm headed eventually. I was going to say that in my upthread comment but didn't want to get distracted. I've used MS and Apple in the past, but both are privacy threats at this point. My next hardware update will be a made-for-Linux machine. Shame on me already.
- GuB-42 3y agoOS as a subscription is not a dumb idea. Not that I like it, but with security updates, hardware support, etc... an OS requires constant maintenance. And if you don't update, often thing start to break down as apps drop support. It would be fine offline, but you can't do much offline today. But that's not it. Windows 7 still works, in fact, all Windows versions still work if you still have the hardware (or VM) for it. It is just that upgrades from Windows 7/8 are not free anymore. But that's normal, major upgrades are rarely free. The free Windows 10 to 11 (previously 7/8 to 10) path is the exception here, because Microsoft really want as many people as possible to essentially beta test the latest version of Windows.
- mentalpiracy 3y agoYou’re right, OS subscription isn’t a bad idea. It’s a horrific, intrinsically anti-user idea that should be loudly and aggressively smothered every time it rears its ugly head. There is no version of reality where OS-as-a-service does not become a n irreversible hostage situation, leaving users at the mercy of “line go up” corporate self-enrichment. We’re practically there already. Look at the trajectory of IoT products. Even if you pay extra for a product that is sold as no-subscription - like the PHILIPS Hue line for example - one day you will inevitably discover the hardware that you already paid for is being held hostage until you accept the new Terms of Service and pay a subscription fee. This isn’t hyperbole - it has already happened dozens, even hundreds of times. OS-aaS is a cute idea for a world where the free market is working correctly, bolstered by strong consumer protections and effective enforcement of regulations. There must be a line.
- havnagiggle 3y agoTitle should have been upgrades, not updates.
- ballenf 3y agoI don't know, for me each one has been a downgrade of the things I value most in an OS. Not saying a bunch of stuff wasn't upgraded, it just wasn't stuff I cared about (except security patches, but those just felt like mafia tactics -- "I'd hate it if something happened to your pretty little system.") I'm currently on 10 on my one Windows computer and will be there until they stop patching security, which I guess isn't too far off.
- lencastre 3y agoso my Win11Pro OEM will no longer freely upgrade to Win12Pro?
- timbit42 3y agoFTFA: "However, Windows 10 keys will continue to be valid for Windows 11 installs."
- isomorphic- 3y agoAs someone who is keeping Windows 10 and skipping over Windows 11, I'm wondering if my Windows 10 key will be usable to freely upgrade to Windows 12. Assuming Windows 12 is worth installing...
- daveoc64 3y agoThis isn't possible to answer - as we don't know if Windows 12 will ever be released, what it will cost, or any of the upgrade terms.
- lionkor 3y agoWindows 11 is in almost every way (except for the Scarlett Johansson voice) the exact same as Samantha from the 2013 movie "Her". There is simply no better way for me to express exactly what I mean. It gaslights, assumes, auto-updates, blames the user, and really eventually leaves you in an abused state where you think you need it, just because youre so used to its complications and way of doing things that everything else seems backwards. See people switching to Linux from Windows who go "I tried installing this program by downloading and running it from AwesomeSoft.co.uk.com.to and it complains libraries are missing! This OS sucks, why isnt there just an installer?". So, I hope people learn to see that the OS is designed to be abusive, unless you have the entreprise-y versions, and stop praising it. Is there really anyone who is upset that its now no longer nagging you and using bad UX to trick you to upgrade to Windows 11?
- phone8675309 3y agoThe push to upgrade to Windows 11 is so aggressive that I turned off the fTPM on my machine in the firmware so that Windows 10 won’t try to upgrade to Windows 11 because "my computer does not meet the minimum requirements". Sad that’s the only way to tell Microsoft to fuck off.
- placesalt 3y agoI tried the above method, but I didn't see any change in Windows update. What seemed to work for me was a group policy (requires local admin, and probably the non-'home' version of win10): gpedit > Computer Configuration > Administrative Templates > Windows Components > Windows Update > Windows Update for Business > Select the target Feature Update version Then, set "product version" to 'Windows 10', and "Target Version" to '22H2' (or whatever you want). Seems to work; after that, the Windows Update pane will say "Some of these settings are managed by your organization", and (for me, so far, at least) there isn't any more browbeating for Win11 installation.
- MollyRealized 3y agoAgreeing with placesalt here. I did the same thing and haven't been bothered for a Win11 upgrade once.
- jprete 3y agoI misread the title. In case you did as well: MS had a program to allow Windows 7/8 keys to be used for Windows 10/11. That program officially ended seven years ago, but the servers kept working, so you could keep using Windows 7/8 keys for the newer versions. MS is turning that off. While I don’t at all like what they’ve done with Windows, it’s not related to the article.
- swader999 3y agoThis would have been a very desirable move if we were collectively at Windows 7 still. You want me to pay to go to windows 8 or beyond? And you promise not to download the 9 GB installer in the "background" on my slow rural correction if I don't pay? Ha ha ha ha ha ha, hard no!
- Dudester230602 3y agoIf only there was some affordable subscription to keep Windows 10 updated forever and turn off Windows 11 notification.
- LoganDark 3y agoIt's called "buying an enterprise key for five dollars"
- anonymoushn 3y agomaybe the revenue can support the development of usable huge pages
- ok123456 3y agoIn related news, it's safe to install windows 7 again.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoHonestly I only use windows because of games. But now valve is doing enough with proton and Linux that I think it will be a thing of the past. And then I can uninstall this absolute crapware of an OS from my PC. It is genuinely user hostile.
- meristohm 3y agoHowever, updates from Windows 7 to Linux Mint Debian Edition 6 are still free. https://www.linuxmint.com/download_lmde.php https://www.linuxmint.com/download_lmde.php
- simonblack 3y agoIn my opinion, Windows 7 is 'Peak Windows'. If you have the best Windows already, why on Earth would you downgrade to Win 10 or Win 11?