4 ms·
Free speech is important. People don't get mad at air because it allows people to transmit their thoughts. People don't get mad at pencils because it doesn't ce
by charcircuit 3y ago
Free speech is important. People don't get mad at air because it allows people to transmit their thoughts. People don't get mad at pencils because it doesn't censor what people write. Internet companies transmitting people's ideas is no different and wanting to censor people is against the principles of a free society.
- crabmusket 3y agoThis is juvenile. Facebook is not free speech, nor does it merely "transmit" speech. It is a machine for algorithmically amplifying speech. Facebook is not a pencil. Notice the article does not criticise mobile phone vendors for including keyboards in their phones. Who do you think was pushing to subsidise data usage for Facebook? And to what end? Air doesn't do that. I completely agree that free speech is important. I'm sure the people of Myanmar agree with that too after decades of regime rule. But it's irrelevant to this discussion.
- v3ss0n 3y agoI am on the ground and let me say this. I am Burmese , I am from Myanmar . I born there. Genocide is done by the organized criminal group sponsored by military junta. I totally disagree with freespeech cause the crisis.Junta is the one responsible for mass killing and genocide.Freespeech is helping us to fight junta . I am risking too much my self to say this already. Freespeech is what they afraid a lot. Even with algorithm , Facebook is platform to deliver our words. I wish there are non-algorithmic , un-mainipulatble , non-moderated platform that can be reached out to the world.
- crabmusket 3y agoMy heart goes out to you. I can't imagine what you and your country are going through. I pray that your words will win out over those of hate and ignorance, over force and violence.
- anon84873628 3y agoI've seen all your replies in this thread and appreciate you sharing your viewpoints. I understand your points and there is one thing that needs to be said in response: All of the stories and citations in this article also come from Burmese people and international monitors on the ground in the country. So parallel to your claims that Facebook is irrelevant, there are other people working in this space with equally valid claims that Facebook does bear some responsibility. People who saw the situation developing and tried to warn Facebook, only to have their pleas fall on deaf ears. Thanks again and best of luck to you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lnxg33k1 3y agoLiberty is not an absolute, positive liberty is one thing, negative liberty can't be accepted, we mean for positive liberty the ability to act within the boundaries of the liberty possessed by the rest of society, the ability for libertarian to be idiots affect themselves only, but until their idiocy doesn't become negative liberty, and for negative liberty we mean that set of liberties that go to affect the liberties of the rest of the society, saying that we should fucilate all libertarians is a negative liberty, because it spreads hate and put someone else in the society in danger and so my liberty directly limits the liberty of someone else
- charcircuit 3y ago>and put someone else in the society in danger Words can't put someone in danger. Sharing people's words doesn't limit other's liberty.
- Avshalom 3y ago[flagged]
- lnxg33k1 3y agoIt's the safest thing we can do to let some violent "ideas"/"ideals" spread, and then acting when they're acting on it only no? We've seen it with Nazi on Africans, Gays and Jews (alphabetically ordered), it ended up so well. I'd say, the freedom of speech can't contain concept that put third party in danger, or that could limit the liberties of others, because bad ideas have always become sufference
- charcircuit 3y ago>It's the safest thing I am not arguing about what is the safest thing. A free society should be free to make themselves unsafe if they so wish. >the freedom of speech can't contain concept that put third party in danger, or that could limit the liberties of others If a free society is not capable of relinquishing their freedom, then are they truly free?
- dwrodri 3y agoI respect agree with your belief that freedom of speech is important, but I disagree with your conclusion that "Internet companies transmitting people's ideas" is no different. The key idea here is that freedom of speech is not the same as freedom of reach: Facebook might give everyone the same text box to write posts or upload content, but they need to answer for HOW and WHY they recommend certain content over other types of content. The comparison pencils or air isn't fair because they aren't being boosted by a recommender system, powering the application layer of the content delivery platform for 90% of a country's people. If I write a message on paper containing a call to action which incites violence (e.g. "We should round up all people with six toes on each foot and shoot them") and hand it to one person, the message has reached one person. I would say, the digital equivalent to "pencil and paper" or "talking in a public square" more like "Writing a message in an HTML file and putting that HTML on a web server you own." I think it would be much more difficult for your average user in Myanmar to reach millions, even if they were given a web server and the means to write HTML. Comparing it to "getting mad at air because it allows people to transmit their thoughts" equates Facebook the Internet, when one is an organization of people who provide technology and the other is technology. There are data scientists and engineers who created the models which learned how to optimize for engagement, and there are product managers who help set the KPIs for those engineers (i.e. encouraged them to solve for engagement) and there are execs who benefit from all of the above. While no single person is solely to blame for what happened in Myanmar, it's wrong to claim that we can't at least reason and discuss the products still created, maintained and own by company (made of people). My opinion on this is heavily formed by the training I received when I wanted to DJ for my university's radio station. Even in the US, where freedom of speech is protected in the Amendments to the Consitution, there were very specific things you could and could not say on the air (while being classified as a non-profit radio station). You could receive massive fines for profanity, obscenity, inciting violence, hate speech, with a large general emphasis on calls to action. Generally, I think this training was good and it encouraged everyone who learned to DJ to be more intentional with their language. I really think that if Facebook is gonna enable users to reach millions, there absolutely should be some caveats to that. People should be able to say whatever they want if they are capable of providing the means by which their own speech is amplified--and even then there are clear cases where the megaphone needs to be taken away. Facebook is giving megaphones to people and some people use it to dispense hate speech. While I might've been willing to give Facebook a pass in their early years, it is clear that between Cambridge Analytica and this that governments around the world need to do better when it comes to working with Facebook to better identify content on their platform which incites violence or calls to action which present a clear and present danger to other people if acted upon. Facebook isn't some amorphous inanimate entity that we can't negotiate/regulate/punish. If someone uploads a hateful message which has a 0.00001% of encouraging a hate crime in Burma, Burma can expect around 5 hate crimes as a result of this message. With great power comes great responsibility.
- brg 3y agoWhile air is a passive requirement, I would suggest that writing, the printing press, speakers, radio, television, and the web are all more similar. They are intentionally used to increase engagement of content intentionally created.
- v3ss0n 3y agoI agree 100% , freespeech is very important for us.