4 ms·
[stub for offtopicness]
by dang 3y ago
[stub for offtopicness]
- aga98mtl 3y agoI do not agree with their usage of the word "Authentic".
- emodendroket 3y agoPerhaps verisimilar then.
- crazygringo 3y agoThe point is that it's not based on hallucination -- it's generated out of the authentic details provided from other images. There's definitely a middle ground here that we perhaps don't have a good word for. E.g. what do we call a painting made by an artist who sat in front of the scene they depicted, vs. a painting made by an artist from their imagination? There's certainly some sense in which the first one was an "authentic" scene.
- CobrastanJorji 3y agoYeah, except it's still absolutely vulnerable to hallucination. Look at the last set of images on "Limitations" page. The algorithm knows that there's a sign with text there, and it uses the original image to get the right letters in there, but it randomly reorders the letters rather than using the source image. "Real" and "authentic" is extremely misleading here. That said, props to them for calling out the limitations so clearly. I really appreciate it when people are up front with the problems like that.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoHere are some better words of the top of my head: Intentional Contextual Everything about this project goes against the meaning of authenticity.
- bhaney 3y agoCool tech, but plastering "authentic" all over this kind of generated photography is really disingenuous and just rubs me the wrong way. I get that it's informed by real details from other photos, but that's not what authentic means. If I buy an "authentic Rolex" and receive a Chinese Rolex clone that's built similarly based on observations of a real Rolex, I'm going to feel scammed and very upset. And I'm much more protective of my memories than I would be of a watch.
- dang 3y agoOk, we've taken authenticity out of the title above.
- cmdli 3y agoI would argue that authentic is a relative term, and actually helped me understand the product more easily. IMO, it is “authentic” because, compared to other image fills, it tries to fill in the data using real data from other photos.
- tremon 3y agoHow do they know the data from the other photos is real?
- endisneigh 3y agoIDK, when I think authentic, I think "genuine", and no image generation is genuine by definition. this is not a bad thing necessarily, but it's important to frame these things correctly. ultimately we oughta think about what we are referring to. if we are talking about a photograph taken by someone, the authenticity is ultimately coming from the combination of the photograph and camera used. so when you think of a genuine photo in this scenario you expect it to be fundamentally taken by the user by a particular camera to create a particular photograph. you can use devices to take a photo without pressing the button, such as a timer, but the photograph and camera are both fundamental to the authenticity of the image. if the camera is no longer entirely involved in the generation of the photograph I would say that it is no longer genuine. Reference driven as described in the article is more appropriate, but alas it is verbose. normally such pedantry bores me, but in this case it's pretty tantamount to what it is being presented in this case.