6 ms·
Homes “unaffordable” in 99% of nation for average American
- legitster 3y ago> ATTOM defined "unaffordable" as someone who must devote more than 28% of their income toward paying for a particular home. Factoring in a mortgage payment, homeowners insurance and property taxes, the typical home priced today would require 35% of someone's annual wages, ATTOM said. Uh, not sure where they came up with the 28% number. Given the traditional advice is 1/3 of income, 35% is not that far. Also, they are only looking at single-income purchasers. Given that I don't know many single people buying houses for just themselves, they should really be looking at overall household incomes. I get that home prices suck, but 99% of Americans not being able to afford a home is obviously not a real statistic.
- thefurdrake 3y agoI'm a single person who bought a house for himself. ... definitely a minority situation, though. Did a dig, though: "The latest number is considered unaffordable by common lending standards, which call for a 28 percent debt-to-income ratio." (From the sauce: https://www.attomdata.com/news/market-trends/home-sales-prices/attom-q3-2023-u-s-home-affordability-report/ https://www.attomdata.com/news/market-trends/home-sales-pric...) This is apparently a common metric? First I've ever heard of it, personally.
- agloe_dreams 3y agoYes, common. Additionally, most americans cannot afford a car payment under 10% of their take home monthly income. But most people do not actually follow this advice, which makes the situation worse. The fact of the matter is that the take home pay for someone making $40K is ~2,300. 10% is $230/mo, which you cant even get a lease for anymore...But people need cars, so they are overleveraged.
- nickthegreek 3y agoThis is why 84-month auto loans are now a thing that more and more people are signing up for. Which wasn't too much of a concern with low interest rates... but now?
- sofixa 3y ago> But people need cars, so they are overleveraged. Which is a massive issue in itself too. In many parts of the US and Canada a car is necessary for daily life, so everyone is forced to spend non-insignificant amounts of money on one or multiple cars, which is very wasteful.
- legitster 3y agoWow, the actual report is much different than the CBS headline! > Home Affordability Report showing that median-priced single-family homes and condos are less affordable in the third quarter of 2023 compared to historical averages in 99 percent of counties around the nation with enough data to analyze. The actual report is saying that 99% of counties have worse affordability. Not that 99% are unaffordable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tristor 3y ago> Uh, not sure where they came up with the 28% number. Given the traditional advice is 1/3 of income, 35% is not that far. You're right. They essentially doctored the numbers to get the result they wanted because it makes good news. QED.
- legitster 3y agoKeep in mind this is not an advocacy group putting together this report. This is a real estate analyst calling for reducing interest rates.
- spankalee 3y ago"Traditional advice" when I was growing up and my parents bought a house was 25%.
- fortran77 3y ago> I get that home prices suck, but 99% of Americans not being able to afford a home is obviously not a real statistic. That's not even what they said. In 99% of the Nation (really 500 hand-picked counties), the _average_ person can't afford the home. Obviously, half of the people are above average!
- Atreiden 3y agoThe 28% rule is a well-known metric in financial planning, they did not come up with this. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/mortgages/mortgage-to-income-ratio/ https://www.forbes.com/advisor/mortgages/mortgage-to-income-... https://www.cnbc.com/select/what-is-the-28-36-rule-for-buying-a-home/ https://www.cnbc.com/select/what-is-the-28-36-rule-for-buyin... https://money.com/what-is-the-28-36-rule/ https://money.com/what-is-the-28-36-rule/ https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/twenty-eight-thirty-six-rule.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/twenty-eight-thirty-six... A better study would certainly include multi-income households, but I think it's worth considering that multi-income households present serious opportunity cost. It is not "free" to have both partners work - assuming you have a partner at all. In previous generations, you had the "breadwinner" and "homemaker" - two clearly defined roles that fulfilled real needs. When both partners are working, who is taking care of the kids? Who is cleaning? Who is meal planning, shopping, cooking, and doing laundry? One or both partners need to then take on all of this in addition to their full-time jobs. This is exhausting, and I'm convinced is the mechanism behind the proliferation of managed services in the household. The monetary cost of these, and other necessary services like daycare, are not insignificant. Assuming that people should have dual income to afford a home is an insidious theft of quality of life. If both partners' time needs to be spent working to earn money, there is less time for traditional homemaking and hands-on parenting. What are the consequences of this, not just to the individual but to society?
- alephnerd 3y agoTo add on to that, the 28% rule is based on the 30% limit from the Wagner-Stegal Act in 1937 during the Great Deal [0] [0] - https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/COMPS-10348 https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/COMPS-10348
- legitster 3y ago> In previous generations, you had the "breadwinner" and "homemaker" - two clearly defined roles that fulfilled real needs. This is a false nostalgia. For most of human history men and women did equal amounts of labor. A non-working wife was a status symbol of urban society. > When both partners are working, who is taking care of the kids? Who is cleaning? Who is meal planning, shopping, cooking, and doing laundry? If we really want to go back to "previous generations" this was almost entirely done by grandparents or extended family. The idea of a nuclear family household is almost an entirely modern invention. Expectations that a single income was to support an entire household was solely belonged to the post-war baby-boom - before that even children were expected to work! I'm not saying there is not merit to a single-income household or some people shouldn't enjoy it. But I object to any framing of it as "traditional". If anything, part of our problem with our current housing market is that in the last 100 years we have mostly obliterated multi-family/multi-generational households from cultural acceptance.
- alephnerd 3y agoThe 28/36 rule was a benchmark based on the Wagner-Stegal Act/National Housing Act of 1937 under the FDR administration. It stated that no more than 30% of income should be devoted to housing expenses. [0] - https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/COMPS-10348 https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/COMPS-10348
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoThe only solution for this is to build less housing.
- Tagbert 3y agoBuild more, not less.
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoThe people that do currently have housing should not have their view ruined just so you don't have to sleep in the street. Particularly if they are in a historic neighborhood, a wealthy neighborhood, a poor neighborhood, a majority white neighborhood, or a majority minority neighborhood. No housing should be built in any of those. Or sprawl, don't do that. Or buildings over 2 stories. Also, all new units need 3 parking spaces, even if they're on top of a subway or train station. This message is brought to you by SF, Boulder, and the State of California.
- fragmede 3y agoHah, pretty good one, you almost had me. I will note though, that SF actually has parking maximums for new construction - you're not allowed to put a ginormous parking garage under that new high rise, basically trying to force people to not have cars.
- Tagbert 3y agoSo people end up parking on the streets. The stick approach doesn't change behavior.
- plussed_reader 3y agoSB-35 would disagree with your notion of aesthetics. Building is definitely happening in Nimbyville, just not anything affordable for the rest of us.
- cryptonector 3y ago
- jjkeddo199 3y agoIn my impossible fantasy dream world, China and America could avert the "2nd cold war" by having dangerously over-leveraged idled Chinese builders (Evergrande, Country Garden, etc.) partner with American construction companies and put their idle/money-burning build capacity to solving America's own real-estate shortages. Each Chinese worker would be required to have an American teammate on the job, bringing a nice profit for everyone involved and building new friendships along the way. One can only dream...
- spacecadet 3y agoIf only.
- nordsieck 3y ago> China and America could avert the "2nd cold war" by having dangerously over-leveraged idled Chinese builders (Evergrande, Country Garden, etc.) partner with American construction companies and put their idle/money-burning build capacity to solving America's own real-estate shortages. I don't think that works. If the Chinese builders are idle, it isn't because they don't have work to complete - the entire crisis is because people basically prepaid for their homes and the builders have yet to complete a lot of them (I think there's a strong implication of embezzlement here). And the Chinese government is desperately trying to find a solution that will get complete homes to the people who have paid for them. In any case, I don't think a lack of construction companies and/or workers is the problem. It's that local governments are making it impossible to build. We're not going to get more homes built to attacking something other than the bottleneck.
- smileysteve 3y agoContext "Even 1.4 billion people can’t fill all of China’s vacant homes, ex-official admits " https://www.cnn.com/2023/09/23/business/china-too-many-homes-for-1-4-billion-people-intl-hnk/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/09/23/business/china-too-many-homes...
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago
- ethanwillis 3y agoThe title here on hackernews is wrong. Given their definition of unaffordable these homes are "unaffordable" for the "average" American in 99% of 575 counties. But! there are over 3000 counties in the US. This is not even close to the meaning of "unaffordable in 99% of the nation..." People might not like hearing it, but homes are in fact affordable if you don't choose to live in an overpopulated metro. And even then homes are affordable if you're not buying one that's being flipped with a few panels of drywall that you could've installed yourself. And before you say, but you need to make good money still so the average American still can't do this! There are good starter homes on my street that sell for 5-10,000 dollars. That is within reach of a vast majority of americans.
- jjkeddo199 3y agoWhere do you live? How bad is the gun violence? Is it safe for little kids? How far to nearest city of 100k+?
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoInteresting. Can you post the street so that I can buy them all right now and flip them? /s
- jandrese 3y agoJust in case people didn't catch the sarcasm. The first three rules of real estate are location, location, location. It's easy to find cheap homes in areas where there are no jobs and no services.
- carabiner 3y agoAt least we can talk about it! We're not like North Korea and we have our freedom to be homeless.
- throwawa14223 3y agoThe declining birth rate will sort this out as demand falls, as long as we do not import more people than is sustainable.
- ok123456 3y agoThat's the plan...
- zjp 3y agoIt was a huge mistake to let "we overbuilt" become the dominant narrative about the subprime mortgage crisis, so named because it was a crisis of giving unlendable people mortgages.
- muzz 3y agoIt wasn't the narrative. It wasn't the "overbuilding crisis", it was always the "subprime crisis"
- japhib 3y agoAbolish zoning https://islandpress.org/books/arbitrary-lines https://islandpress.org/books/arbitrary-lines
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoSure there is a problem, but the article is literal bs. Obviously most people are not homeless, so they found some place they managed to afford. One clue is that they are looking at "median home prices". Nobody buys a median home, they buy one that matches their needs and budget. If nobody is able to bid on a home for a few months, seller usually lowers the asking price rather than changing their mind about selling. We can talk of unaffordable as buying a home leaving the buyer with little extra cash to spend on other priorities or unexpected hardships. Or discuss specific drivers of high housing prices, such as NIMBYism, regulation or labor shortage. But it helps to have conversation on non-stupid terms.
- BeetleB 3y ago> Nobody buys a median home, they buy one that matches their needs and budget. The point of the median is that if the median price is higher than most people can afford, then less houses will be bought. If you live in SF and can only afford a $200K house, one isn't going to pop up for you to buy.
- commandlinefan 3y agoI live in a house that I could just barely manage to afford the payments on when I bought it 15 years ago that's more than doubled in value since. When I drive home from work I drive by hundreds of houses that are two-three times the size of my house that I _know_ I couldn't afford the payments on if I had to buy it for what it's being appraised at right now (based on actual sales of comparable houses in my neighborhood). I'm doing well, too, and I can't help but wonder... who the hell is buying these houses and where the hell is the money for them coming from?
- fuzzfactor 3y ago>>Homes “unaffordable” in 99% of nation for average American >where the hell is the money for them coming from? No problem, the 1% can afford to pick up the slack better than ever.
- notacoward 3y ago> who the hell is buying these houses Sometimes people who make even more than you, or who inherited a significant amount. Most often, though, it's people who already bought and sold at least one other house. And often these categories overlap. A not-uncommon scenario is that the parents bought the house for absolute peanuts back in the 50s, then passed it on to their kids who sold it for a million or two so they could buy the houses you see. But whether the inheritance was dollars or a house, they'll never talk about it. "A little bit of a bump" is the most they'll admit.
- Eido95 3y ago> who the hell is buying these houses REIT > where the hell is the money for them coming from? From thousands of investors
- muzz 3y agoMore like "from low-interest borrowing" Institutional buying peaked in 2022 and has fallen off a cliff as interest rates have gone up
- muzz 3y agoRising mortgage rates is literally mentioned as a cause in the title of the linked source from ATTOM, and seems to be completely ignored by all commenters.