4 ms·
>Thought experiment: what would the humanity miss if we removed the concept of ads entirely? devil's advocate says that everything you consume online without a
by dylan604 3y ago
>Thought experiment: what would the humanity miss if we removed the concept of ads entirely?
devil's advocate says that everything you consume online without a subscription or other purchase price.
- moate 3y agoYou're not wrong, but you think too small. Ads existed well before the internet, and are so ingrained in the world at large that as a thought experiment this is up there with "what would we miss if we removed the concept of murder/books/good/etc. entirely". What does "the concept of ads" mean? Is it advertising if I say "I bought a really great hammer from place, you should also get one if you want a great hammer" to a friend? I literally cannot think of a world in which you can only remove ads and not blow up literally every paradigm of how we deal with resources and their distribution.
- dylan604 3y agowhy does one assume that because i'm playing devil's advocate means that's how i think? your premise is greatly flawed.
- mostlylurks 3y agoMany of the freely available things I consume online are funded by voluntary support from dedicated groups of fans, on patreon etc, and which spread mostly by word of mouth. This requires neither a subscription for the content in question nor any purchase of it. Thus, at least one business model exists which can sustain freely available content without relying on ads, and thus, not all free content would disappear if we banned ads.
- danbruc 3y agoDisagree. Watching ads pays for nothing. People buying stuff with some ad budget included in the price is what pays for that content. The entire thing is essentially like a tax collected with everything you buy, then part of the money gets spend to produce ads and run the entire ad industry, the rest is distributed among everyone displaying the ads. Even if I block every ad, I am still paying for them, I am still paying for the content. And if you are getting a subscription to get rid of the ads, then you are actually paying twice - not only directly with your subscription but you are also still paying into all the ad budgets when you buy stuff.
- dylan604 3y agoYou watching the ad is not what gets money to transfer. The person wanting to show an ad pays for someone to show the ad. In theory, the larger number of eyes available to view the ad can demand a higher price for the privilege of showing the ad. The per-click concept of paying for ads is very disingenuous. You provide a monthly budget, and the ad provider will show you charts of how you got exactly that many clicks, regardless of budget.
- danbruc 3y agoI already gave them my money, just distribute it among the websites I visit and do not bother me with your ads.
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago> just distribute it among the websites I visit and do not bother me with your ads Are you a champion of privacy if you advocate for this? How will you implement this without a centralized tracking? Hilarious.
- danbruc 3y agoWhy would you have to track all the things? The entire idea of the ad based system is that you still get access to the content even if you are not paying for it. There is nothing to be tracked all the way through the system. If I see an ad for product X, then because someone wants me to buy X, but the money for that ad comes from someone else who already bought X. You might never know who that other person was because they bought their X in some store with cash and that other person might also not know about the website on which I saw the ad and have no interest in financing that websites. That everything is pooled together and not individually tracked is a feature. If you could track everything, why would you pay for content consumed by people contributing little or nothing to the ad budgets? All the tracking for targeted ads is an attempt to move into that direction, only spend money for ads on people who are likely to pay it back in the future. If you have no money, then there will be no ads for you and it turn no money for the websites you visit.
- justinclift 3y agoThere'd likely still be a lot of OSS available online. ;)
- hokumguru 3y agoAnd no one willing to host it
- justinclift 3y agoNot even slightly true. We (sqlitebrowser.org) host all of our own infrastructure, with a mirror on GitHub for downloads and our source living there due to the Community being there. I'd very happily move us off GitHub to our own git hosting if the rest of our devs would let me. ;)
- whimsicalism 3y agoYeah let’s just impose higher startup costs on all new projects
- justinclift 3y agoSure, because that's how it would work out. :p