4 ms·
“Can we predict what restaurants you’ll like when you’re in a new city? It may not be that you search for pizza, but we know you tend to like pizza places, or y
by fauigerzigerk 15y ago
“Can we predict what restaurants you’ll like when you’re in a new city? It may not be that you search for pizza, but we know you tend to like pizza places, or you tend to like more casual, loungey bars, so we can suggest things.”
Thanks Google for helping me stay the same forever. Just what I needed a search engine for.
“I actually think most people don’t want Google to answer their questions. They want Google to tell them what they should be doing next,” Schmidt said
And you would be totally wrong to think that. Searching for things doesn't work nearly well enough for Google to move on to useless suggestions that extrapolate my current behavior in a completely uncreative way.
They are simply on the wrong track.
- msabalau 15y agoSearching isn't perfected today, so no one at Google should have or articulate a vision for 20 years in the future? That attitude must make one a real buzz kill around 13 year olds. "You haven't mastered your classes for this semester yet, how dare you spend any time dreaming about what you might be when you grow up." Thanks for encouraging Google to stay the same forever.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoI'm not saying they shouldn't have a vision or shouldn't change. I'm saying I don't like this particular vision. (I didn't downvote you by the way. I never downvote)
- ddw 15y agoAnd yet this is a natural progression for Google. I'm really interested to see how/when the public begins to resent the algorithms that control their lives. Perhaps privacy will be a feature then.
- reader5000 15y agoThey are on the most logical track given their assets, i.e. access to the real-time behavior of BILLIONS of human beings, something no entity has had access to in the history of the human race. Maybe you find their recommendation systems currently poor (personally I never leave the first page) but their potential to add value is ENORMOUS. They just need to forget facebook and go back to being google. If google is not mankind's first omniscient benevolent AI accessible through a simple http query within 20 years then google will have failed.
- jrockway 15y agoThanks Google for helping me stay the same forever. Just what I needed a search engine for. So you'd rather be pushed in the direction of becoming the "average consumer"?
- talmand 15y agoI would say that helping him stay the same forever would make him be an "average consumer".
- jrockway 15y agoNot really true. If he's a vegetarian and most people aren't, he's not becoming more average by seeing vegetarian restaurants ranked above steakhouses. He's just getting results that he's more likely to find useful. (Try asking your vegan friends if they want a steak for dinner tonight. Do that every day. See if they get annoyed at all.) Same goes for programming language. If you're programming Java and are googling for the Iterables library, you probably don't want to see the C# version. And if you always click Java results in preference to C# results, it makes sense to not clutter the top couple of results with C# information. You never use them, after all. (Imagine the kind of advice you'd get from friends if they didn't know you. It wouldn't be very useful; you might as well ask a random stranger.) Google is just a computer program whose config file you edit by using the Internet. Not all that scary.
- talmand 15y agoWhat you say is true, in that context. I guess it depends on what the group is we're talking about when we're talking what "average" is. He could become an "average" consumer in the context of a vegetarian; always eating what every other vegetarian is eating because he's never offered an alternative. As for your example with the programming languages, I would find it annoying if it only always displayed results for what it "thinks" I'm looking for. I'd rather define what language I need the information for. Otherwise, if I get accustomed to the system then it would impede me from researching a new language because I'll have to go on a crusade to convince it that I do indeed want information about a new subject. Then it learns my new subject but what if I want to go back to getting information about the old subject? Now I have to convince it that, yes, I do want the information I wanted before that I didn't want later that I want again now. At least give us the option to turn it off. I don't know where you got scary from though.
- chrisbroadfoot 15y agoThey are simply on the wrong track. So, what do you want?
- CastIronSkillet 15y agoI certainly do not want a few days of searching to be extrapolated into a complex determination of my future desires. I obviously have no idea what sort of algorithm they use, and I can only assume it will be very intelligent, but if search suggestions of today are any indicator of the future, I foresee issues with people who may use Google so seldom such that it is unable to develop an accurate prediction and serves only to frustrate the end user.
- Spearchucker 15y agoLol I thought much the same. The basic example she gives is a problem for me. I know where the restaurants I like are. I've been going to them for years. The type of place I would search for is when I need somewhere, maybe more upmarket, to take a client to. The last thing I need is for a search engine to point me at the same-old. It's trying to turn out of ruts. You turn the steering wheel like a madman, but the tyres don't bite and you just keep going where you don't want to go.