8 ms·
A new era for Arecibo
- jasonkester 3y agoArecibo is really awkwardly placed for being anything but what it was. It’s at the end of a long windy narrow road up the side of a mountain in the jungle. And when you get there, there’s just about enough room for a little building perched on the side of a pit. They can fit a lot of biology and computer science schools at the base of that road, I bet.
- orev 3y agoIts location in a remote area made it good for what it was, a telescope with relatively little surrounding radio interference, but it really isn’t suited for other uses that bring in more people. It’s unfortunate since there’s a lot of pride about what it used to be on the island, but I feel like this is more of an emotional grasp than something that actually requires that site.
- lacker 3y agoThere has also been more and more radio interference at that site over time. It isn't that remote. Sites that are really out in the middle of nowhere in empty desert, like the VLA in New Mexico and MeerKAT in South Africa, have far less radio interference.
- orev 3y agoIt really wasn’t meant to be in a totally radio silent area, but that just happened to be another advantage. The main point was the bowl-shaped area which is somewhat unique. You don’t need that kind of geology just for an educational center.
- ajford 3y agoYep. Parking for visitors (and staff) was an absolute nightmare the entire time I worked there. I can only imagine how much worse it'll be if the revamp the visitor center. There's almost no space on-site for more parking without tearing up more of the natural environment. Though perhaps without the need to maintain the superstructure any more they could repurpose the Physical Maintenance yards into more parking.
- digging 3y agoAlthough expensive, seems that vertical building (underground and above) should be a priority then.
- deepsun 3y agoWhy didn't they made a shuttle?
- ajford 3y agoWasn't a priority. It was an active scientific facility, so the priority was on producing science. The site was chosen for being remote and shielded from the outside by hills/mountains, so it really is a long winding road to the entrance gate. I can't really think of a suitable site for parking within say 10min of the site, so it'd be a long shuttle ride.
- user3939382 3y agoThis is how we solve it in Manhattan https://i.imgur.com/qLYlbya.png https://i.imgur.com/qLYlbya.png
- jedberg 3y agoGiven that they don't need the antenna anymore, can't they repurpose the entire pit for buildings?
- squarefoot 3y agoSad to see it go away, but for starters they could sell the remaining reflector tiles and make some money for other science related uses.
- chasil 3y ago...and that long, windy road is one-lane, and I don't remember high-quality pavement. Some of that money would have to be spent on the road, right away, if there is any hope of it to be a general attraction.
- an-allen 3y agoHaving made the trek myself, and seeing one, in my opinion, of the great wonders of the modern world… I can certify that i would not drive there to just experience science museum stuff. Driving in puerto rico is terrifying, and up that hill to Aribaco… never again.
- wkat4242 3y agoThat's ideal for a radio telescope, especially considering how reliant modern society is on radio equipment
- world2vec 3y agoVery sad that its next phase is not as a bigger, better observatory. RIP.
- oh_sigh 3y agoDo these massive telescopes have a future, when we could just build smaller ones and use aperture synthesis to pretend like we have a really really big telescope?
- madengr 3y agoIt had a powerful transmitter for radar work, and there are advantages to having a single, giant aperture when it comes to maintaining low sidelobes, power amplifier coherency, etc.
- mandevil 3y agoFor receive only, yes, aperture synthesis (like the VLA and the GVLBI) is capable of resolving more precisely than even Arecibo could. But Arecibo also did a bunch of active radar mapping of things within the solar system, which aperture synthesis cannot replace. You can't solve the coherent beam problem without actually having an antenna that really is that big.
- echelon 3y ago> You can't solve the coherent beam problem without actually having an antenna that really is that big. What's the tl;dr on the math here?
- madengr 3y agoYou know how Nyquist says you must sample at minimum twice your highest "frequency" or your get aliasing in your spectrum? It's the same with antennas except you must sample at least 1/2 your wavelength or you get grating lobes (the equivalent of aliasing) in you far field pattern; it's all the same math. A sample in time is equivalent to an antenna element sampling space. A big reflector is equivalent to sampling everything at once with no gaps; it's bandwidth independent. You can only put array element so close together, limited by the size of the element (itself is limited to a fraction of the lowest wavelength), electronics, and unwanted inter-element coupling (though there are tricks to take advantage of this coupling and make very wideband arrays). If you leave "gaps" in your array elements, that's not a problem receiving strong, periodic signals. You can physically move the elements to fill in the gaps to remove those lobes; the equivalent of an equivalent time oscilloscope or a synthetic aperture radar. The problem is you can't do that when transmitting since you only have one opportunity to send something (non-periodic). There are other disadvantages with phased arrays. Each amplifier has to be matched in amplitude and phase. I've had to bin lots of amplifiers as some have phase compression and some phase expansion over amplitude. That distorts the pattern over the pulse. On the receive side, each receiver has thermal noise un-correlated with the others. So for N antenna elements, you received signal-to-noise scale proportional to sqrt(N) instead of N like you have on transmit, or with a big reflector. This is why arrays suck for very weak signals. Notice NASA keeps building big dishes for their DSN instead of "cheaper" arrays. Then there's the whole timing and phase noise issue with distributing an oscillator. Tough you can only make a reflector with about 100 dB gain.
- tpmx 3y agoThat Arecibo scene from Contact (1997): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfiOT14MyaQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfiOT14MyaQ
- spiritplumber 3y agoLooks like it'll become a museum of itself :(
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- mikhailfranco 3y agoArecibo is d-e-a-d. Passing the baton... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five-hundred-meter_Aperture_Spherical_Telescope https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five-hundred-meter_Aperture_...
- garba_dlm 3y agononetheless astronomy is doing fine https://english.news.cn/20230928/5929e14fe40b4c939c1f8194e0b953e8/c.html https://english.news.cn/20230928/5929e14fe40b4c939c1f8194e0b...
- elil17 3y agoWhen I visited Arecibo (which I highly recommend but the way - one of the coolest things I’ve ever seen), the intern giving me a tour told me that Arecibo was essentially the main way we had to detect asteroids that might hit earth. Without it, we may not have enough time to launch an asteroid redirect mission. If that’s accurate, it seems penny wise and pound foolish to have spent ~$300 million on the DART test but then not spend the extra ~$50 million needed to actually detect an asteroid coming towards us.
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoMost of the large (more than a few hundred meters) potentially hazardous asteroids are thought to have been found. However, there are some locations (relative to Earth's orbit) that are difficult to view from the ground, because you can only observe them at twilight. The best way to find those last remaining potentially hazardous asteroids would be to launch a space telescope to the Earth-Sun Lagrange Point 1. In the grand scheme of things, this type of mission wouldn't cost that much, but so far, nobody has made the decision that making sure Earth doesn't get hit by an asteroid is worth an investment of a few hundred million dollars.
- elil17 3y ago> nobody has made the decision that making sure Earth doesn't get hit by an asteroid is worth an investment of a few hundred million dollars. This is not true. NASA spent over $300 million to test DART, an anti-astroid planetary defense system.
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoAnd yet, a straightforward mission that would identify all remaining potentially hazardous asteroids hasn't gone forward. DART is great, but it's useless if you don't see the asteroid coming long in advance.
- dotancohen 3y agoIt seems that Starship well greatly upend these calculations and considerations. When launching 100 tons of payload costs $10 million, we should start seeing a lot more science being launched.
- markhahn 3y agowhat would it cost to really begin it's next phase (rebuilding, not what amounts to a mausoleum that runs some classes)?
- srean 3y agoIts such a strange coincidence that a few hours earlier I was re-reading this beautiful short by Ted Chiang https://nautil.us/the-great-silence-237510/ https://nautil.us/the-great-silence-237510/
- geocrasher 3y agoOh goodness... I didn't expect to shed a tear at the end of that. What a gorgeous bit of writing. I can only aspire to be such a powerful storyteller as Mr. Chiang. Thanks for sharing.
- srean 3y agoAm happy you liked it.
- jameshart 3y agoStruck by this part about the island’s sense of loss of the telescope: > Arecibo’s prowess at astronomy was a source of pride in Puerto Rico, and many have been disappointed with the NSF’s decisions. Such a contrasting view compared to the long fight in Hawaii over the Thirty Meter Telescope project [1], where locals have continually fought and protested. It’s tied up in the Hawaiian sovereignty movement, and a lot of cultural connotations, but I can’t help feeling like the Arecibo case should be a lesson for the TMT movement: you’d miss the telescopes if they went away. [1] https://www.npr.org/2022/07/31/1114314076/hawaii-mauna-kea-telescope-space-observatory https://www.npr.org/2022/07/31/1114314076/hawaii-mauna-kea-t...
- runako 3y agoThis isn't confusing. It's totally rational to not want limited, unspoiled land to stay that way on the one hand, and then on the other hand having lost that battle it's fair to prefer a working telescope over the wreck that's at Arecibo now. It's not an obvious conclusion from those two perspectives that one would therefore prefer to have a pristine environment spoiled with concrete.
- jameshart 3y agoThere are 13 telescopes on Mauna Kea already - and some are already due to be decommissioned. It’s not unspoiled and pristine. If they don’t continue to develop the site, the telescopes there will fall into obsolescence, and ultimately disuse. Pushing back against continued development on the site is, ultimately, pushing for it to go the way of Arecibo.
- petsfed 3y agoOr they could perform an explicit reclamation project, to try to restore the land as best they could to the way it was prior to 1893. There are more options than just "build more telescopes" or "let the existing telescopes rot". Of course, just letting them rot would be playing to the standard colonial practice of extracting value, then leaving consequences of that extractive effort to the remaining indigenous people.
- aidenn0 3y agoHow does a large single dish antenna compare to an array of smaller dish antennas? Like e.g. the VLA in New Mexico.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoGreat news, but I'm still sad due to the lack of interest in funding a replacement. To put it in perspective, the cost of just one football (Premier League or NFL) stadium would pay for an entire radio array.
- 0x5345414e 3y agoEducation centre seems like a strange choice given that it’s in the middle of nowhere…
- guender 3y ago[dead]
- dudeinjapan 3y agoFor England, James?
- HocusLocus 3y agoI am reminded of a 1973 story by Frederick Pohl called "In The Problem Pit" ( https://www.rulit.me/books/in-the-problem-pit-read-682068-1.html https://www.rulit.me/books/in-the-problem-pit-read-682068-1.... ). In the story the Arecibo telescope itself had been abandoned and it took place in a network of natural caves underneath it, a silo of sorts where people gathered in a 'think tank'. "And then, when all radio telescopy was driven to the far side of the Moon by a thousand too many radio-dispatched taxicabs and a million too many radar ovens, the observatory no longer served a function and was abandoned." The events in the tale take place in ~2048 and Pohl imagined that even at that future date the rusted cables were still holding the catwalk aloft. He did not live to see the facility's collapse.