4 ms·
One of a hundred ways buses tend to be the better choice for public transit. No specialized tracks, flexible routes, flexible capacity, etc.
by xnx 3y ago
One of a hundred ways buses tend to be the better choice for public transit. No specialized tracks, flexible routes, flexible capacity, etc.
- unethical_ban 3y agoFlexible routes = unpredictable. Flexible capacity = attempts at over optimization = not trusting that capacity will be there = unpredictable. Shared infrastructure with roads and following road laws = all the inconvenience of traffic jams. Flexible routes may be nice on a multi-year timetable but still runs into the jam issues above. So if we are going to build dedicated lanes with special signal crossings and high capacity to encourage a large population to use it, let's make it as efficient as possible - a rail track is much more efficient than tires, and electricity is better than directly burning fuel, and delivering electricity through rail is better than battery.
- Robotbeat 3y agoBus rapid transit exists, is much cheaper than rail, solves nearly all these problems while making the infrastructure far cheaper (due to ability to climb grade, etc). They’re often lighter than trains, they can be much more granular (so you don’t need an entire train at low rider volumes), so the efficiency can be closer to a wash than people would like. Especially with trolley buses or battery electric buses (or BEST, the combination ones).
- dwallin 3y agoIt’s not an either/or situation. You have a bunch of tools with pros and cons and you have to use the proper tool where each one is most appropriate. The best transportation systems are a blend of transportation types. Use rail where the benefits are worth the cost and buses where they are not. There also many incremental options in between.
- Robotbeat 3y agoNarrow buses (or long transit vans) in sewer tunnels. Get ‘er done.
- kredd 3y agoThere’s a huge difference between good and bad metro lines. Just like how there’s a difference between good and bad bus systems. Frequent and reliable metro with good coverage will beat bus system because of predictability. Also, capacity wise it’s much more effective, faster and etc. Unfortunately, most of North America’s systems are not of this type.
- supertrope 3y agoBuses are usually the cheaper inferior option. While bus service doesn't inherently suck, the type of decision making that chooses buses to minimize cost will usually cost optimize every portion of a bus network until the experience suffers. Dedicated lanes are not provided so buses get stuck in traffic. Bus stops without rain shelters or even a bench (versus full stations). Operating budgets get cut and then the interval between buses goes to 30 min. Service after 10 p.m. gets cut. The bus networks that don't suck are usually called "shuttles" and are underwritten by tourism districts, airports, and theme park operators.
- bpye 3y agoBuses can only hope to match the reliability and headway of metro services if they have dedicated right of way and signal priority for the complete route. This eliminates several of your supposed benefits.