3 ms·
To me, this seems like Canute demanding the sea doesn't rise, because he doesn't like wet feet. OK, you want truth, eloquence, and public interest (dry feet)?
by ben_w 3y ago
To me, this seems like Canute demanding the sea doesn't rise, because he doesn't like wet feet.
OK, you want truth, eloquence, and public interest (dry feet)? Great: you need that for which higher ground, or a dyke, is an apt metaphor.
In particular:
> at their best, journalism’s words emerge out of public service, unimpeachable reporting, self-reflexive news judgment, eloquent storytelling, rigorous editing, and timely publication.
"[P]ublic service, unimpeachable reporting, self-reflexive news judgment": these are things many of us already doubt in the media. Rightly or wrongly, and for long before the phrase "fake news" was coined.
"[E]loquent storytelling, rigorous editing, and timely publication": all the things that GenAI is really good at. At least, on the "news article" scale — don't bother trying to use it to make a novel, it's not eloquent on long-form content, at least not yet.
Worse, the first proposed solution:
> First, taking a page from the Writers and Screen Actors Guilds, and aligning with some newsroom unions, journalists could find their collective voice on GenAI. Indeed, we’ve started to see some halting but hopeful efforts at collective action.
To the extent that it's capable of timely publication of eloquent storytelling, it's already an enormous megaphone for any and all propaganda. It doesn't need any trained human journalists who care about the craft. By the volume, it is the ocean and striking unions are Canute (yes, I did have this mental image first and then fit everything else in my comment around it).
WGA has a slightly easier time of this, for now, but only because it's not great at coherent film-length plots. Yet.
The second point is more valid. In particular:
> Hidden beneath GenAI outputs is a vast ocean of data with histories and politics that make GenAI anything but neutral or objective. Who categorized and labeled the dataset, what is overrepresented in or absent from a dataset, how often does the system fail and who suffers most from those mistakes?
This is all 100% true and completely valid.
It's not limited to AI though, rather it sounds like my GCSE history teacher 24 years ago explaining the value and limits of both primary and secondary sources when researching the past, and is even starting to touch upon the fundamental issues of the philosophy of knowledge c.f. the Münchhausen trilemma.