9 ms·
Norway wants Facebook behavioral advertising banned across Europe
- ktosobcy 3y agoYes, please... Actually all custom ads should be banned (I'm looking at you Google)!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- croisillon 3y agoyet Norway doesn’t want be part of the trade union that would enforce this ban
- tokai 3y agoAs the article points out Norway is a member of the Court of Justice of the European Union, which is the enforcer.
- the_duke 3y agoWell, Norway is actually part of the trade union (European Economic Area), as well as Schengen , the cour of justice and many other EU institutations/treaties. They are not in the EU proper though.
- pil0u 3y agoGood. Thread was not released in Europe, I doubt we are missing something huge, except for the huge data harvesting that comes with it. I think about ads and the whole industry in general, especially in the digital space, as inherently harmful. Thought experiment: what would the humanity miss if we removed the concept of ads entirely?
- endisneigh 3y ago> Thought experiment: what would the humanity miss if we removed the concept of ads entirely? for one you wouldn't be posting on this site since it's literally a marketing device. without targeting advertising you effectively only allow large companies to advertise. I'd say you lose anything you're not paying for explicitly, which is most of the internet.
- hightrix 3y ago> I'd say you lose anything you're not paying for explicitly, which is most of the internet. The internet existed before ads and would continue to exist after ads. Trillion dollar companies built on ads served to the internet would not exist, but the internet would.
- whimsicalism 3y agoVast majority of the internet did not exist prior to ads and removing ads would make its revenue model very difficult. Putting your fingers in your ears and wishing away the problem is not a solution.
- timeon 3y ago> which is most of the internet Ads and SEO killed lot of community driven internet. I was active in several of those. We can live without ads.
- avgcorrection 3y ago> I'd say you lose anything you're not paying for explicitly, which is most of the internet. Oh no. Anyway.
- fulafel 3y agoI think HN works as a argument in favour of an ad ban: it's a marketing device, but it's not an ad. This clearly seems like a better outcome for the public than ads.
- BoxFour 3y ago
- dylan604 3y ago>Thought experiment: what would the humanity miss if we removed the concept of ads entirely? devil's advocate says that everything you consume online without a subscription or other purchase price.
- moate 3y agoYou're not wrong, but you think too small. Ads existed well before the internet, and are so ingrained in the world at large that as a thought experiment this is up there with "what would we miss if we removed the concept of murder/books/good/etc. entirely". What does "the concept of ads" mean? Is it advertising if I say "I bought a really great hammer from place, you should also get one if you want a great hammer" to a friend? I literally cannot think of a world in which you can only remove ads and not blow up literally every paradigm of how we deal with resources and their distribution.
- dylan604 3y agowhy does one assume that because i'm playing devil's advocate means that's how i think? your premise is greatly flawed.
- mostlylurks 3y agoMany of the freely available things I consume online are funded by voluntary support from dedicated groups of fans, on patreon etc, and which spread mostly by word of mouth. This requires neither a subscription for the content in question nor any purchase of it. Thus, at least one business model exists which can sustain freely available content without relying on ads, and thus, not all free content would disappear if we banned ads.
- danbruc 3y agoDisagree. Watching ads pays for nothing. People buying stuff with some ad budget included in the price is what pays for that content. The entire thing is essentially like a tax collected with everything you buy, then part of the money gets spend to produce ads and run the entire ad industry, the rest is distributed among everyone displaying the ads. Even if I block every ad, I am still paying for them, I am still paying for the content. And if you are getting a subscription to get rid of the ads, then you are actually paying twice - not only directly with your subscription but you are also still paying into all the ad budgets when you buy stuff.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- olalonde 3y agoRemoving ads would disadvantage less affluent people and youth, as many free services like online platforms and social media are funded by advertising. This indirect subsidy from wealthier consumers who buy advertised products would vanish if ads were eliminated. Likely, services would introduce paywalls as an alternative revenue source, making access harder for those unable to pay. Moreover, ads would be replaced by something worse. Without ads, companies would still market their products, but in more covert and potentially deceptive ways. This could lead to less transparency and potentially more manipulative tactics, making it harder for consumers to discern genuine content from promotional material. Journalists would be given free stuff, get invited to parties, there would be product placement everywhere, endorsements, etc.
- danbruc 3y agoCompanies could just not produce and show ads but keep the ad budget in their prices and keep spending it. Yes, this will of course not work, this will screw up all kinds of incentives, but then lets make it a tax and let the state send a cent every time I visit a website. Free internet services for everyone just like we could do free public transportation. Not sure if this could work and even if then it would probably be more complicated, but I have serious doubts that the ad based system we have right now is the only, best or most efficient system.
- timeon 3y ago> replaced by something worse Not if it is regulated. Maybe there would be less online platforms but there would be some community driven as they were before. This mindset that ads are necessary sounds like Stockholm syndrome at best, gaslighting at worst.
- olalonde 3y agoIt has more to do about humility than "Stockholhm syndrome" or "gas lighting". Who are we to take away the ad-supported platforms from the people who want them or need them, because they can't afford to pay? Community driven platforms exist today. We don't even need to ban the ad-supported platforms to have them. By the way, I think you may be looking at the past with rosy glass or perhaps didn't live through it. Because advertising on the web used to be a lot more distracting and distasteful. There were popups all over the place, full page animated banner ads, etc.
- ljlolel 3y agoI understand the privacy motivations, but behavioral targeting is good for small businesses. This is focusing more power on a handful of mega corps that do brand advertising.
- JohnFen 3y agoMaybe so, but I don't find that argument remotely compelling. Saying that spying should be allowed because it hurts small businesses if it isn't makes no sense to me. We shouldn't allow companies to do bad things regardless of who benefits more from those bad things.
- dspillett 3y ago> but behavioral targeting is good for small businesses Call me selfish, but my concern is not for businesses of any size. I don't want to be followed around the Internet any more than I want to be followed around in my “real” daily life. I'm fine with adverts based on what I am currently looking at and/or where I am (the latter at a granular level: country/region/city, not more precise). Anything more than that involves tracking and storing data that I consider an intrusion. Some might disagree with the granular location even, though without that you can't simulate something like posters in local shop windows advertising local events (which to me feels valid). If I'm looking at technical things¹, by all means advertise technical things¹ at me. Heck, feel free to blanket advertise your technical things¹ more widely. But I don't want targetted advertising for technical things to stalk me when I'm booking a holiday or doing my weekly shop online, any more than I'd want someone following me into the travel agent or supermarket, tapping me on the shoulder and saying “I hear you've been looking at laptops, could I interest you in …”. Small or not, I don't want a business following me around. -- [1] replace “technical things” with anything else I might have looked at or been shopping for: running shoes, martial arts equipment, groceries, recipes, scifi books, books in general, TV listings, etc.
- diffeomorphism 3y agoCould you make this quantitative? Say a "surveillance ad" costs X and a "basic ad" (no tracking, just common sense placement) costs Y. How much more is X worth to you than Y? There does not seem to be much data on this, but last I looked the value of surveillance ranged from worthless for all the effort (3Y at most) to utterly worthless (like 1.1Y).
- dhwixb 3y agoI went to buy my grandmom a phone last week. Just wanted a basic one. I am not tech person, nor do I follow whats going on in phone land. So the sales guy lays out a bunch of the "low end" phones price wise. This one has 4 cameras, but this is better for low light conditions, and this one is better for video stabilization etc etc. I must have seen 10 phones and each one, he is talking about features grandma doesn't need. So I am standing there wondering what am I even paying for? Does no one who builds phones have grandmoms? I start asking him that. His boss shows up and 2 other sales guys join the debate. And everyone agrees the marketers and advertisors love to Target that part of the population who is willing to shell out the most. And when all of the marketers, target the most lucrative group and forget the rest, this is where we end up. Something is really wrong about that. I dont understand how we get to a place where resources are allocated to build things that people dont actually need?
- HWR_14 3y agoJitterbug tried to have that market, but that was years ago. Looking at them now they seem insanely overpriced (almost $80 for a flipphone!) Amazon has unlocked bar/flip phones for just over $20.
- paularmstrong 3y agoIt's capitalism and greed.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> It's capitalism and greed Actually, this is a market failure. Greed would mean building a phone for grandma. Instead we have complacent mediocrity.
- asabil 3y agoYou might want to check out the Swedish Doro phones: https://www.doro.com/en-us https://www.doro.com/en-us
- kalupa 3y agoAll the money and effort is spent on convincing people they _need_ it, rather than figuring out what people actually _do_ need.
- _virtu 3y agoI wish the headline read "Norway wants advertising banned across Europe". I wish society would revolt against the idea that advertising is something that should be allowed. It's an affront on attention and we now have alternative ways of discovering products and services that we want that weren't possible when advertising first started.
- cm2012 3y agoBanning advertising en masse is basically banning capitalism
- jjgreen 3y agoYour point being?
- mongol 3y agoWhat is the point of this question?
- gadflyinyoureye 3y agoWhy is banning capitalism bad? There is a growing by view today that capitalism is an evil thing. It needs to go. The poster is asking why would of it be bad to get rid of capitalism?
- mongol 3y agoExactly how would you get rid of it? Socialize all private property? Government owns everything? No capital in private hands?
- gadflyinyoureye 3y agoPretty much, yeah.
- bigbillheck 3y agoSounds like a good start to me.
- robador 3y agoI've been thinking about this recently, and I don't think I would actually mind personalised ads. However I don't trust the companies with my private data at all. If there was a way to guarantee anonymity, I might get rid of my adblocker.
- whimsicalism 3y agoEvery website is going to track your interactions on this website. An ad blocker won’t stop that and if you don’t like that your activities online are logged, you should stop using the internet. Tracking between websites is a different question altogether.
- _8j50 3y agoEuropeans are missing out. Now that corporations have eradicated all my privacy, I feel naked before the world with nothing to hide. I feel seen by companies now, like they truly know me at intimate level. I don't even need to vote anymore, they know what I want and will lobby for me. I swear I am not a slave and corporations are not my masters, that would be illegal. (I am being entirely sarcastic, in case it isn't obvious)
- cm2012 3y agoIt's amusing to me how much it seems like the EU has a monkeys paw when it comes to tech regulation. There will be regret in 10 years as the US economy continues to grow and the EU shrinks.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>There will be regret in 10 years as the US economy continues to grow and the EU shrinks How would we regret not letting US tech giants misuse our private data? How would letting them do that improve our economy? Innovations and technology means a lot more than targeted ad-based spy-ware where the US is king and the EU is not even competing. We should be competing who gets to provide a better standard of living for it's citizens not who's country's corporations Fe to exploit everyone to enrich a select few. Also, let me get back from my year long paid parental leave, to tell you why having the strongest economy is not the most important thing in life. https://imgflip.com/i/80vik0 https://imgflip.com/i/80vik0
- cm2012 3y agoAll of these regulations impact smaller tech companies more than the big players. I've worked with literally 100 plus start-ups from seed stage all the way to post IPO. About 15 of those were EU companies. From my experience, the experience of the US and EU companies is dramatically different. EU companies are at a dramatic disadvantage when it comes to promoting their products. It's much harder to track what's working and what's not, and more than that, there's a huge state of uncertainty. Dev teams don't know, for instance, whether this pixel or that server to server integration might get them in trouble for sure, so it just delays everything. So EU tech start-ups tend to languish in obscurity to a far greater degree, which means less of a feedback loop to improve the product, which overall means less tech wins in europe. Start-ups follow a power law where most fail, but 5% succeed. This means you need a lot of shots on goal. When every shot on goal takes 3x the effort and cost... It's not just tech privacy regulations by any means, but all of this together means that the gap between the US and EU continues to accelerate. See: https://www.reddit.com/r/europe/comments/bbotjc/eu_vs_us_gdp_per_capita_adjusted_for_ppp/ https://www.reddit.com/r/europe/comments/bbotjc/eu_vs_us_gdp... And no, I think the "privacy" gains are basically meaningless and not worth the trade-off. And I would bet $100 any time that by 2030 that gap will continue to grow at the same rate.
- nojvek 3y agoI’m glad EU exists and gives shit to US Big Tech companies. There’s a range of good and bad but we should celebrate the push and pull forces. I like Apple now has USB-C, or Tech companies now have to have download portals of all user data, and delete the data after deactivation. Because EU makes the laws for EU, those benefits spread elsewhere. And same with California’s CCPA laws. Good regulation is when there are multiple players competing to provide the highest quality services and goods at the lowest prices, while maintaining a minimum bar of transparency, safety and long term sustainability. Corporations want to make maximum profit. Capture the highest demand at highest prices while spending the least. So govt regulation and corporations are wonderful push and pull forces if well balanced. When prices go down, quality goes up, and total human comfort increases, that’s a wonderful future.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whimsicalism 3y agoIf the big tech companies were in the EU, the dynamic would be completely reversed. It’s simply rebranded protectionism.
- mc32 3y agoI hope this takes hold in the EU and then spreads across the globe. No targeted advertising based on data scooped up by browsers, ISPs, etc. Only if the user opts in and specifically says I want to be advertised on the following categories from which they can opt out or modify at whim.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dang 3y agoThis falls into the class of "proposed bill" (or regulation. etc.) - these are super common and mostly just lead to generic threads. For interesting-thread-purposes, it's better to wait until something actually happens and discuss it then. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20bills%20propos&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22no%20harm%20in%20waiting%22%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...