6 ms·
Waste plastic can be recycled into hydrogen fuel and graphene
- senectus1 3y agohttps://archive.li/1BNJt https://archive.li/1BNJt
- stevespang 3y ago[dead]
- userbinator 3y agoThis seems like a bit of a "duh" article? Most widely-used plastics are basically (very) long-chain hydrocarbons. Hydrogen and carbon. It's just like crude oil, except less... crude.
- dottjt 3y agoWould it be viable though if you need to include distribution and sourcing? I wonder at what scale this might work.
- tanvach 3y ago‘Economically’ is probably the keyword that’s missing?
- pstuart 3y agoYes, whilst including full operational costs (e.g., dealing with waste). There was a recent posting here about a company in this space using pyrolysis to break down the inputs but had serious issues in emissions from the plant.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoYes. Basically for this to be economical, it would have to be both low cost and more high in value than alternative ways to recycle plastic. Basically making plastic out of plastic probably takes less energy and results in a more valuable product that can be recycled more than once. Alternatively, burning it and using the resulting heat for energy generation is also very common. And then there is the question of scale and sustainability. Recovering hydrogen from what is essentially a product made from fossil fuels to then burn it is not really that helpful. And there is only so much plastic out there that we can recover. At best we get a second use out of the fossil carbon before it is released back into the atmosphere. But you could argue that a landfill at least captures the carbon more permanently. So, labeling this as green or sustainable would be a bit of a stretch of the definition.
- HPsquared 3y agoThe only way to really tell if something this complex is economical, is to try it out.
- rbanffy 3y agoIndeed. With enough energy we can convert recycled plastic into literally anything. All you need is to fuse the right nuclei together. It might need more energy than you would spend mining it from a distant star system, or release enough heat to melt the factory, the crew, and the planet it's on, but, still, there is no fundamental law of physics preventing you from doing it.
- PaulHoule 3y agoNote "pyrolysis" and "gasification" processes like this are the fast breeder reactor of non-nuclear energy. There are plenty of reports from the 1970s that pyrolysis could be a cheap way to create cheap electricity from "clean coal" or biomass or even create fuels. There are numerous variations such as attempting to convert municipal waste to hydrogen-CO "syngas" with a plasma torch or attempting to cook plastic down to a toxic and carcinogenic mess of aromatic compounds that can be used as diesel fuel but the scenario is usually: (1) environmentalists tried to stop the project because of the toxics produced, (2) environmentalists fail to stop the project, they (3) build the machine, but (4) can't really get the machine to work and shut it down not long after it is put into operation. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_gasification_commercialization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_gasification_commercial... https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/mar/02/clean-coal-america-kemper-power-plant https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/mar/02/clean-co... It would be nice to see something succeed in this space but boy am I skeptical. Boosters make the point that it was a proven technology back in the 1910s, but a big coal gas factory they built in my hometown (Manchester, NH) became a big superfund site that is a huge gash in the area between the downtown and the river that I don't believe is fully remediated to this day. Probably the most successful facility of this sort is https://www.dakotagas.com/ https://www.dakotagas.com/ but that project was really too big to fail and it took them about 25 years to get the bugs out and it get it financially sustainable after it went bankrupt. That project also has a big strip mine across the street that gives it quality feedstock that lets them run the process consistently. Throw in random plastic from municipal waste that will never be the same twice and getting production of any kind of product will be a struggle, never mind production of quality products. The SASOL corporation of South Africa has long been using technology of this sort to make gasoline from coal when they were under embargo, it is proposed that they'll export the technology whenever oil prices spike, but they always seem to forgot what happened last time. SASOL was the worst performing major stock in the world in 2020.
- hedora 3y agoIgnoring the gasification challenges, this trash burning power plant was a disaster: https://www.ohioexploration.com/structures/trashpowerplant/ https://www.ohioexploration.com/structures/trashpowerplant/ Pantyhose and bowling balls in the fuel stream (municipal garbage) routinely took it off line. How does the gasification reactor deal with that (or, these days, laptop batteries) I wonder?
- ars 3y agoWhy do people keep doing these pointless things? Just burn it for energy and quit with all the complicated and unnecessary chemistry. I know I sound a little blunt, but the solution to plastic waste is so incredibly obvious and yet people keep avoiding it.
- s3graham 3y agoI assume the idea would be to avoid the carbon emission from doing so?
- mrjin 3y agoHow? The more steps adding to it, highly likely the more energy consumption and thus more emission. Hopefully there was an exception.
- usrusr 3y agoI'm not a chemist, so this is a very low knowledge post, but the carbon/hydrogen link in carbohydrates seems to be a rather weak one, we reconfigure it all the time on the long and winding process paths from crude to the many, many things we create from it (these days, pretty much everything that isn't metal or concrete). The majority of the energy we use from burning carbohydrates comes not from oxidating carbon but from oxidating hydrogen: oxidating carbon does release slightly more energy per atom than oxidating hydrogen, but the hydrogen atoms outnumber the carbon ones by far. On the atom level, our society already is mostly hydrogen powered, but unfortunately limited to hydrogen packaged in carbon and we can't burn them separately. With this technology, if it scales (big if, no question about that!), we can burn the oxygen for energy while retaining the carbon as stable, even somewhat useful (perhaps not in the amounts post-scaling...) solids that are relatively easy to keep out of the atmospheric cycle. If that really works, it will be a great improvement over what we do and certainly worth spending some of the net energy we'd get from the hydrogen on. And even if the net energy would be zero it could still be worth it, run the plant only at times of intermittent sources surplus. At zero energy balance it would be a 100$ efficiency storage solution (that would solve some of our plastic waste problems on the side)
- littlestymaar 3y agoStop trying to make disposable plastic cool again…
- jhallenworld 3y agoThe plastic of the Roman Empire was perhaps ivory... maybe something like this can be made artificially now? Just what is ivory anyway? It's teeth in some kind of plywood like structure: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1742706118300862?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S17427... Some plastic things can be directly replaced with it: http://www.antiquegamblingchips.com/distinguish_iv_bon_cel.htm http://www.antiquegamblingchips.com/distinguish_iv_bon_cel.h...
- TylerE 3y agoArtificial bone has been around for years and years.
- wkat4242 3y agoInteresting. Recycling for actual plastic re-use is very difficult due to the different plastics used and additives, colouring etc. This would really make sense for the plastic that will not be able to be recycled (which is in fact 99% of it).
- chaostheory 3y agoUntil this works on a mass scale without even worse side effects, I read this piece as more submarine PR from the plastics industry.
- foven 3y agowaste plastic can be recycled into waste graphene
- mjan22640 3y agoLooking forward to a widespread graphene polution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graphene#Toxicity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graphene#Toxicity
- pfdietz 3y agoUsing plastic for energy is quite practical -- for example, burning it to power cement kilns. All that "recycling" you're doing, carefully separating out plastics 1, 2, maybe 5, washing them, putting them in the bin... most of that doesn't get recycled into new plastic, but it would be fine for burning.
- gpt5 3y agoPerhaps a naive question, but why is using plastic for energy good? When we produce plastic we essentially convert oil into a highly stable form instead of burning it into the air. Essentially, we sequester the CO2 that would've been burnt if that oil was used as fuel. That's a huge benefit of using plastics that we are eliminating.
- sandworm101 3y agoAnd burying that plastic returns some of the carbon to the ground from whence it came. Bury it deep enough and in a few million years it may be cooked, recycled, back into liquid hydrocarbons.
- pfdietz 3y agoThere are two issues here: where does plastic come from, and what is done to it. Plastic could be made from non-fossil carbon sources. If it is, then burning it is just fine, since it's putting no net carbon into the atmosphere. Most plastic is made from natural gas btw, not from oil.
- keep_reading 3y agoAnd natural gas is a ~free byproduct of our oil extraction. Plastic would be unpopular if we had to spend considerable amounts of capital to produce it. Have you ever heard of a speculative plastic market? The plastics industry putting pressure on oil & gas prices? Nope
- pfdietz 3y ago
- nubinetwork 3y agoSomeone's been playing too much factorio...
- infecto 3y agoAnyone have good insight into the US and why we do not have more incinerators like Japan? I realize you need to scrub the smoke stacks and I believe the push I Japan now is to capture the co2 is it or something like that? But why no real effort to do something similar in America? Recycled plastic is a joke. Seems that it would potentially be better to burn it than bury it?
- hannob 3y agoWhether countries use mostly landfills or incinerators depends pretty much on one variable: Population density. The US has plenty of space for landfills. Japan has very little space. But ultimately, landfills and incinerators are both bad solutions. CO2 capturing for incinerators would be somewhat sensible, but there is currently no plant doing that. There were plans for one in Oslo, but that just got put on hold due to increasing costs.