6 ms·
Language was born in the hands (2022)
- hadlock 3y agoWas this written by someone without kids? In early childhood development pointing at items is referred to as "shared thinking". If a lion is charging at you in the jungle and you point at it the shared thought is "danger! He's coming to eat us!" or general concept. Alternatively if you're playing with your 8 month old nephew and point at the red ball, he'll grab it and give it to you. If you wait four more months and say "ball" he'll do the same thing. Both approaches work but pointing with your hands comes much, much earlier in the development process.
- thfuran 3y agoSo should we expect that human ancestors had fragile, unfused skulls and no ability to move themselves around?
- drekipus 3y agoProbably, when they were very little
- garba_dlm 3y agoanother perspective to the shared thinking is that if a lion is charging at you in the jungle, there very first thing isn't conceptual; it's just fear which will immediately coordinate any mammals in the group to run or prepare to fight. I say this because I know some dogs are able to learn the ball thing too, oh and the fear thing is part of how i communicate with my dog.
- 28304283409234 3y ago“Clan of the Cavebear”? This is not a new theory.
- fmajid 3y agoSo how does this explain how whales, dolphins or parrots have language despite no hands?
- empath-nirvana 3y agoIt's stretch to call what any of them have a "language".
- tlavoie 3y agoI think that your statement is more of a stretch, than the idea that quite intelligent, social creatures aren't using a language that we simply don't understand. I'd love to know what the local ravens are saying to each other; there is quite the variety of calls, and quite situational.
- fmajid 3y agoCorvids are able to recognize individual humans who were helpful to them (or harmful) and share that with others, it's hard to see how that can happen without language ("watch out for the weird standing monkey with the yellow feathers on top, he's likely to throw a stone at you").
- underlipton 3y agoThe crows that live nearby are wary of me, probably because of two incidents (they saw me standing next to a crow's body, which I'd come across during a walk; and, on another walk, a branch had suddenly broken out from under another crow as I passed the tree it was in). I hear a particular call whenever I pass by them now, though I basically never see them anymore.
- tlavoie 3y agoMy ravens are still wary of me, but they always have been. Somewhat less so in the last while, since I've been putting peanuts out for them; they'll still move away when I get close, but not far, and not until I've gotten fairly close. I really want to know what one's got against my little security cameras though... I've got video of one taking one off the railing I put the peanuts on, and (I assume) the same guy has been working to knock another off the driveway gate post. https://youtu.be/y3C-Tf8FeVA https://youtu.be/y3C-Tf8FeVA My son and his girlfriend had a great encounter with one, driving down the Dempster Highway in Yukon. It surfed the wind on the hood of their Jeep for something like 45 minutes, and hopped close enough to grab cat treats when they stopped for a bit. That's on YouTube as well.
- Borrible 3y agoThere was a time when "grasping" something was a literal thing. Strangely enough, however, I only became aware of this when I studied Hegel and some even more obscure texts from Friedrich Engels about Darwin and the importance of the hand for human evolution.Probably his 'Dialectics of Nature'.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- keepamovin 3y agoYes, and the word "comprehend" has the root "prehendere" which means "grasp". You can even see the word "hend" in there I think! :)
- fsckboy 3y agoand apprehend in French comprendre is "to understand", and prendre is "to take"
- drekipus 3y agoInteresting anacdote, my wife is into teaching our 1 year old sign language. Many words and phrases come through much faster than they do verbally. Words for "finished" "more" "water" etc. Really help in figuring out what she wants. And she squeals with delight when she feels understood.
- keepamovin 3y agoHeh, adorable.
- andrei_says_ 3y agoWhat’s a good resource on how to teach a 1-year old sign language?
- Reefersleep 3y agoIn my language, there are decent books on the subject and informative and inspiring accounts on Instagram. Look for "baby signing", must be loads of English materials. We created our own extended vocabulary using English baby signing, lots of good words here: https://babysignlanguage.com/dictionary/table/ https://babysignlanguage.com/dictionary/table/ Like the GP said, helped us loads in communicating with our kid before he could talk, much to our shared delight, and, I believe, relieved a _bunch_ of potential frustration.
- maxent 3y agoWe used Baby Signing Time after we discovered our child was deaf at 10 months old: https://www.signingtime.com/baby-signingtime/ https://www.signingtime.com/baby-signingtime/ You can find their videos on YouTube too, but we love supporting the organization. When we started signing, everything was unlocked - not just communication, but also creativity, personality, and delayed fine and gross motor skills.
- jonahbenton 3y agoReminds me of the most interesting (to me) of the Huberman Lab episodes I listened to, the one with Dr Erich Jarvis, at Rockefeller, about speech, language and movement eg dance. The description doesn't do the content justice. Fully mind blowing.