I merely defend the comment that claimed a perfectly scientifically valid (if far-fetched) possibility. With a sarcastic comment likening that idea (B) to creat

I merely defend the comment that claimed a perfectly scientifically valid (if far-fetched) possibility. With a sarcastic comment likening that idea (B) to creationism, you implicitly adopt A, and let me tell you—it is closer to actual creationism (C) than you might like.