5 ms·
Misunderstanding Greek and Latin in eighteenth-century Britain
- adastra22 3y ago> She recommends a simple course of learning a thousand sentences in six to nine months, and dismisses the idea that students might try to learn a whole language and its grammar Looks like the sentence-mining method goes all the way back to the 18th century!
- n3storm 3y agoThis language learning methods where created for world war times so introduced soldiers could learn fast enemy or foreign language just to get to certain target and do their action, steal, bomb, etc without being recognised (not for coming back) Spoiler: it did not work, that is why I whole new methodology based upon modern pedagogy and linguistics was created. War method had best selling points like speed (you know nobody has time this days, like we are missing something) thus it still exists in different shapes (such as mobile apps) And also, sometimes at certain points drilling techniques should be used, but not only.
- fullmoon 3y agoWhen exactly are native speakers of a language using grammar drilling methods? Is it part of kindergarten?
- FranzFerdiNaN 3y agoIt’s ridiculous to compare native language acquisition by children with second language acquisition. A child has so many advantages: 100% surrounded by ghe native language, people who constantly talk to the child at levels they understand, teachers who work with the child (and yes native children do get grammar lessons). And children also get constantly corrected when making mistakes. A second language learner lacks most or all of these things.
- masklinn 3y agoReadable text provides immersion and context, which allows implicitly absorbing the most common grammatical constructs and intuiting vocabulary. Anecdotally I can’t recall being anything more than a middling student of English until I reached the end of the translated discworld volumes and figured there was a lot more to read if I but acquired them in the original English. Some contribution can also be credited to getting into computing although mostly because EverQuest required daily interactions with English sites and speakers.
- ido 3y agoNow try to learn another foreign language as an adult and report back on how easy it hard that was :)
- adastra22 3y agoI have, multiple times. I’ve also raised bilingual kids. Adults fare vastly better (an order of magnitude) than kids, when compared on a basis of hours invested. The thing is, kids are exposed to a language learning environment 24/7/365 with few other responsibilities or a mother tongue to fall back on to express themselves. If you were able to put in the same immersion effort as is forced upon a kid, you’d be fluent in less than a year and native-level a few years later, for most languages.
- fullmoon 3y agoIt’s not so ridiculous once you realise that it’s entirely possible for a second language learner to surround himself in the target language and constantly consume level appropiate (and interesting!) input. If someone lacks those things, IMO the method isn’t very good.
- Tor3 3y agoIt's not ridiculous at all. I learned English in exactly that way: Massive input. I learned nothing back in elementary and middle school - they tried to drill grammar, in the form of "I am, you are, he/she/it is, we are, you are, they are". Didn't work. But I got interested in microcomputers in the mid seventies, when I was a teenager, and most of the material available was in English, so I subscribed to Personal Computer World after finding issue 1 in a local shop. Drank it all up, slowly at first, then faster, and later on I just continued - not in order to learn English, I just wanted to read what I wanted to read. And there were of course movies etc. I didn't get past technical English until much much later, when I started to read English books because that was what was available when travelling. I got all my English vocabulary and grammar from that. English is admittedly a bit special in that it's easy to immerse even if you don't live in an English-speaking country. There's no problem finding comprehensible input (a term I hadn't heard until recently, but looking back that's what I was doing). I can manage in more languages, to a survival level, using exactly the same method. And I've worked for many years trying to learn Japanese, by more traditional methods (I couldn't just start reading.. I thought) - and I got almost nowhere. Yes, I can describe basic grammar, but I can't (or couldn't) understand Japanese outside of greetings, and I couldn't speak to save my life. But some months ago I switched to what we're discussing: Acquire the language by comprehensible input. Fortunately there are now people around who prepare material for you, and that's what I'm using. Suddenly I'm finally getting somewhere. It works. The fog is lifting. As to "And children also get constantly corrected when making mistakes" - no, that's not really true. That's a myth. If you look, you'll see that children's mistakes are only corrected if it's serious. For the rest, except for a small amount of corrections, children simply gradually correct themselves. And they don't need teachers to work with them to learn the language. Children are fully fluent when they enter school, what they learn is more vocabulary (something which continues for the rest of their lives, of course), expressions etc. But that's not teachers teaching them said expressions. They simply come across them as part of everything else they do. "people who constantly talk to the child at levels they understand" Again, that's not how children learn the majority of speech. What they do is to constantly (but in a relaxed, passive way) listen to adults and other older people talking between themselves. They're surrounded by input. And that's how they acquire their language. An adult actually has an advantage most children don't have: A great ability to read. If they can read, and understand a lot of interesting topics, adults have access to massive input which is not typically accessible (at least to that level) by children.
- Exoristos 3y agoThey start in the womb, and are still being corrected at times in elementary school. So if you're willing to take that kind of time under that level of immersion, then you don't have to drill, either.
- adastra22 3y agoI don’t know what your comment has to do with what I, or the article was talking about. I don’t know what method was used to train soldiers in foreign languages during the world wars, but I sincerely doubt it was the modern meme of flash card-based spaced repetition of 10,000 sentences method that the internet has made popular under the term “sentence mining.”
- n3storm 3y agoIt is, you just don't as you say, it amazes me you say you doubt it. I studied for Second Language Teaching English especialization. They used to sell vinyl records with just repetition after repetition in the 50-60s-80s long before meme was used only for internet stuff. https://www.ebay.com/itm/333145399151 https://www.ebay.com/itm/333145399151
- adastra22 3y agoLinguaphone isn’t sentence mining.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> ordinarily Boys learn a Leaf or two of the Pueriles, twenty Pages of Corderius, a part of Esop’s Fables, a piece of Tullie I wonder when and why we started calling him Cicero instead. (We might also ask why Julius Caesar wasn't called "Julie", but the historical significance of the name "Caesar" is pretty apparent.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deckeraa 3y ago> To commit the very Accidence and Grammar to memory, requires three or four years, sometimes more, (as many can witness by woful experience) and when all is done, besides declining Nouns, and forming Verbs, and getting a few words, there is very little advantage to the Child. [I know the article is about understanding the cultural level of Latin and Greek understanding in 18 century Britain, but as a Latin teacher I feel obligated to comment about Latin teaching methodologies] This is a common complaint and is encountered many times in modern contexts. I contend that this is due to the method of teaching; namely in language courses that lack sufficient amounts of comprehensible input (i.e. simple text that one can read quickly without needing to pause to consult a glossary). Using a Comprehensible Input method, one can acquire a language much better and faster. For example I was able to read books in the Vulgate comfortably after only 200-300 hours of language learning. There are also people who have learned to speak Latin fluently, for example SaturaLanx or ScorpioMartianus on Youtube.
- popularonion 3y agoSo what was your source of comprehensible input?
- deckeraa 3y agoPrimarily Familia Romana by Hans Oerburg, and then a lot of public-domain Latin readers. There's a guy named Justin Armstrong who maintains a pretty good list here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TugURNkc0461IQoToKIlE4hnnbRykRYYxvrfl2X90No/ https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TugURNkc0461IQoToKIl...
- coyotespike 3y agoI love this comment a lot. I am not fluent in Latin, but have also experienced amazingly fast progress using CI methods (relying on the resources you mention below). Currently I'm brushing up on Spanish in the same way and absorbing (for instance) the subjunctive painlessly. I think most people still underestimate how easily an adult can learn a language. "Paul Nation in a 2014 article estimates that to acquire a vocabulary of about 5000 words a student needs read about 2 million words." If you absorb about 3000 words a day, after less than a year you'll have read 1 million words. With a vocabulary of 2500 words you can do quite a lot. For me, in Latin, that's about 40 minutes of reading (I read faster in Spanish, slower in Ukrainian). Read/listen/watch 3000 words a day, understanding the majority of the words so you understand the whole passage, and after a year or so you'll be mostly fluent. These figures line up with your 200-300 hours to read the Vulgate, as well.
- bazoom42 3y agoLatin and Greek generelly weren’t part of womens education, even well educated women. The quip about “the absurdity to speak Latin in a Ladies presence” shows how Latin was understood as a “male only” club.
- defrost 3y agoIn 18th Century Britain Latin and Greek generally were not part of a man's education either, of course. Indeed: There was no national system of education before the 19th century, and only a small section of the child population received any schooling. Opportunities for a formal education were restricted mainly to town grammar schools, charity schools and 'dame' schools. https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/transformingsociety/livinglearning/school/overview/before19thcentury/ https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/transforming... The majority of British children had no formal education and those that did largely had perhaps six years of basic primary school. It was essentially only the wealthy and|or children of some clergyman that received an education ... and perhaps surprisingly it was not uncommon for well off girls to have good education in numbers and languages via private tutors at home, at least, even if they did make a habit of pretending to have none. Eton, Harrow and Westminster delivered a high quality education to the (only) boys that attended but for a great many if not most attending was less about the education and a great deal more about the social connections and on ramp into the corridors of power.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> children of some clergyman that received an education The clergy, of course, were one of the major groups that spoke Latin. The others were academics, and government and the law. These occupations were exclusively reserved for men.
- watwut 3y agoThat is why the OP added "even well educated women" bit to the claim. The claim about absurdity of speaking latin to women is leading anecdote of the article. That being said, article does address some contexts in which non-elite boys got latin education.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> Despite the number of hours and years dedicated to Latin on the school curriculum, it was a complaint of educationalists from the mid-seventeenth century onward that the considerable linguistic apprenticeship in schools guaranteed only a mediocre output in terms of pupils’ abilities in written and spoken Latin, let alone Greek. As a schoolboy, I was compelled to study Latin for about 6 years, from age 9. I acquired a better understanding of grammar; but I couldn't compose say, a short essay in Latin. Nowadays I can barely compose a sentence of more than three words. I also did a term (8 weeks) of classical Greek. I learned the alphabet; that's it. I'm glad I learned Latin; but in terms of return on effort, it was a complete waste of time.
- ngcc_hk 3y agoI wonder how hard to learn these two just to appreciate some of those great epic poems … like Aeneid, not to mention Iliad and Odyssey, perhaps even Latin bible. The keyword is to appreciate. Not to write or even read like say English.