4 ms·
Heh, yea, trying to use the internal feeling of guilt as a basis is a path to complete failure in my eyes. This overlaps with the quest for AI we have and Chin
by pixl97 3y ago
Heh, yea, trying to use the internal feeling of guilt as a basis is a path to complete failure in my eyes.
This overlaps with the quest for AI we have and Chinese Room arguments. We can't even argue that people have the same sense of guilt. Is guilt in some people performative for social gains? Do other people feel guilty on things that at least to me make no sense?
- mcpackieh 3y agoI don't argue that people all have the same sense of guilt. Demonstrably they don't. Some people refused to own slaves; some people owned slaves but then released them, while other people owned slaves and never showed any sense of guilt. What I say is that everybody (excepting the possibility of true psychopaths) has empathy available to them but many people suppress it. It's a universal ability, but not universally put into practice. > a path to complete failure in my eyes. And I dispute complete failure. Humanity does not behave perfectly morally, so if that's your expectation then we've failed and always will fail. But most people do have the capacity to behave morally most of the time, and people are guided in this primarily by their internal sense of right and wrong (informed by their innate social instincts.) This system doesn't work perfectly but it's very far from a complete failure.