3 ms·
You want to limit access to reproductive medical technology only to those who meet your arbitrary moral criteria? Are you certain you're an atheist?
by krapp 3y ago
You want to limit access to reproductive medical technology only to those who meet your arbitrary moral criteria?
Are you certain you're an atheist?
- anon291 3y agoNot the OP, but you seem to be confusing atheist with having no moral norms.
- krapp 3y agoI'm not, I'm implying that putting moral prerequisites onto reproductive rights is a de facto religious point of view.
- anon291 3y agoIt's really not. Religion is about a human connection with the divine or supernatural. Encoding morality into public rules is a legal question.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoNot the OP or GP either :-) but while I agree that literally everybody has internal morals, by definition; there is such a huge correlation in western society between religion and opposition to reproductive rights / aids, that I can understand the question even if not the snarky tone. I've seen very few (not zero but close) non-religious ethical systemic discussions against reproductive aids. As I said in another comment though,I'm eager to learn!
- bee_rider 3y agoWell, this person hasn’t said it shouldn’t be allowed, they’ve explicitly walked it back to saying that most people don’t have a “true need” for IVF, and have made other bad lifestyle choices. Which seems weird and judgmental, but it doesn’t necessarily have to come from a religious place. It is hard to speculate about people’s beliefs without putting words in their mouth. But generally people can use all sorts of things (evolutionary biology, economics, whatever) to justify themselves.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y ago> Are you certain you're an atheist? 1. There is no god nor gods. 2. Jesus Christ was not a historical person, but wholly fabricated. 3. I could not find it within myself to lie about these truths, even if it forfeited my life. I would struggle to lie about it even if it forfeited the lives of loved ones. 4. Should I somehow be wrong on any of these points, then a deity that would torture me for eternity for the intellectual mistake of disbelief is in fact a devil and is my enemy which I would have wished I was clever enough to have recognized, so that I could wage war against it. How atheist are you?