4 ms·
That's sort of true. It's why I stopped thinking about my carbon emissions. Even if I kill myself and bring myself to zero, the net carbon emissions per year wi
by renewiltord 3y ago
That's sort of true. It's why I stopped thinking about my carbon emissions. Even if I kill myself and bring myself to zero, the net carbon emissions per year will only move from 37.12 billion metric tonnes to about 37.12 billion metric tonnes. And if I 10x my emissions, net carbon emissions per year will still be 37.12 billion metric tonnes.
It's been quite liberating, actually. I got rid of my motorcycle, got a Nissan Titan, and now I fly everywhere. Knowing that no matter how green I become doesn't matter and that if I 10x my emissions means that I'm free to act in whatever manner I choose!
- esarbe 3y agoWhile I don't have any intention of letting my carbon footprint balloon up, there's one point I thoroughly agree with you. This is not a problem that can be solved with individual responsibility. It just makes you feel guilty. This is a systemic, a societal problem. And until this is addressed by policy, law and international treaty, no manner of individual do-gooding will solve the issue.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoSystematic problems are solved by political action. Political consensus to change the status quo emerges from a some group of society taking individual responsibility, and then demanding/voting that society changes to their model. If no one ever takes the shitty public transit, how will politicians know that they should invest in better transit. Individuals pay the price of taking that shitty public transit and then demonstrate/campaign for better. If fast fashion is to be ended, you don't keep buying the latest outfits from The Gap every year. You individually pay high prices for the lasting products from niche stores. Then you use your demand as material to go campaign publicly to change norms and/or ask politicians to tax/regulate fast fashion items. Sure, there are some places where politicians can judge general sentiment and make laws ahead of public sentiment change, but in a lot of cases its the other way around.
- landemva 3y agoIndividuals can purchase items created locally, rather than exporting manufacturing pollution to developing nations. As Bud Light sales drop showed, consumer purchasing choices can make change.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoThis is why I think we needed legislation to curb excesses.
- renewiltord 3y agoYou mean on the Swiss? They produce 1,670,000x as much CO2 as me every year, so there's not much point in me eliminating my 20 or so CO2 tonnes. It's a drop in the ocean compared to Switzerland. I could even go 5x up and it won't matter.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoI suppose your argument has a couple of things going for it. First you don’t need to change your own behaviour. Second you get to blame someone else for the problems you have created. You will find it painful though, when you are inevitably forced to change.
- renewiltord 3y agoThat's the key thing. If some group has more emissions than me I can always just blame them first even if I'm contributing to the problem. The objective isn't solving the problem. The objective is to allow me to maximize my share of the pie by using rhetoric to claim that some arbitrary group of people are equivalent to others. So I live guilt-free so long as Switzerland emits what it does. Once Switzerland and I have emitted the total equal amount of CO2, we can consider ourselves equally liable.