3 ms·
That this will happen was obvious in March 2022, the only unknown was price. Starlink has proven itself to be unjammable, resilient, low-latency, high-bandwidth
by baq 3y ago
That this will happen was obvious in March 2022, the only unknown was price. Starlink has proven itself to be unjammable, resilient, low-latency, high-bandwidth, reliable, easy to setup and all that confirmed in a real kinetic war.
Basically everything any Pentagon official could have dreamed of, for $70M? Probably the fastest check ever written there (yes yes it's just the beginning but you get the idea.)
- Gooblebrai 3y agoDo you mind to clarify what do you mean with "real kinetic war"?
- baq 3y agoWhatever is going on in Ukraine for the past year and change. As opposed to trade wars or cyber warfare.
- micromacrofoot 3y agoUkraine, this isn't a cold war — but a "real war" with munitions (kinetics) exchanged
- pm90 3y agoIts a fancy term for a hot war in meatspace.
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y agoA war where the bullets fly.
- candiddevmike 3y ago[flagged]
- waihtis 3y agoYes, Elon has a secret laptop in his bedroom with backdoor access to the entire Starlink fleet of satellites. Or perhaps you should develop critical thinking skills and not read the "rocket man bad" takes on Elon.
- CHSbeachbum420 3y agoWait are you serious? He absolutely has access to it and even if he doesn't he employees the personnel that do. Additionally, he has already been caught twice shutting it off to prevent attacks on Russia.
- waihtis 3y agoyour commentary provides sufficient evidence either that you have absolutely no clue about things work in the real world or you're here to troll, either way I'm not going to engage
- dotnet00 3y agoThat has, as usual, turned out to be a lie that was widely reported yet the correction wasn't. What actually happened was that service in that cell had always been off and SpaceX refused to turn it on as doing so specifically for an attack would (obviously) make them party to that attack. It would also not be in line with US policy as they too had, until recently, refused to provide guided weapons with the kind of range that such an attack would've had. https://www.engadget.com/ukrainian-official-claims-elon-musk-cost-lives-by-refusing-starlink-access-during-a-drone-operation-165926481.html https://www.engadget.com/ukrainian-official-claims-elon-musk... Similarly, the reporting about the first time was misleading too, as the 1300 terminals that CNN reported on were ones supplied and paid for by the UK, which Ukraine and UK had agreed to stop paying for (because there were ~22k other terminals directly supported by SpaceX) and Ukraine had replaced them with other functional terminals before their service ended.
- 0xDEF 3y agoI don't understand why you are being downvoted. People sympathetic to the enemy has been one of the primary security threats on both sides in the Russian invasion of Ukraine. During WW2 the Danish resistance killed more Danish informants than German occupation forces.
- Dig1t 3y agoThermonuclear war has been avoided by the decision of a single person several times. https://youtu.be/ILgSesWMUEI?feature=shared https://youtu.be/ILgSesWMUEI?feature=shared Having people who are willing to think critically about escalating conflicts, especially civilians who are not fighting in a war, is what we need more of. If Russia launches a full scale invasion of the US, then Congress can declare war and it will be a completely different story.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Thermonuclear war has been avoided by the decision of a single person several times Trained people trusted by the command structure with their role. Not rando civilians. If we knew we had a stooge in Pyongyang, it would massively increase the chances of a conflict with them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shrubble 3y agoIf you really believe that Elon Musk's "Zaphod Beeblebrox" public persona is who he is, then you are buying into a deception, is my view.
- wkat4242 3y agoCorrect, he definitely has only one head.
- justapassenger 3y agoUmjammable is not guaranteed. It’s a new tech (which is/was also geofenced from parts of the front line), so we there wasn’t that much time yet for adversaries to develop jamming tech. It’s very likely harder to jam, but unjammable is a very bold statement.
- baq 3y agoI agree. A more precise statement would be - as of now, Russia does not have the tech to jam it. They must be working on it and same for the Chinese, but for now, we haven't had any evidence that jamming is operationally deployed.
- xoa 3y agoJamming ultimately works by known physics though, and Starlink seems like inherently an incredibly tough thing to jam (even ignoring anything in the future like optical). It's very high frequency, in LEO, using phase arrays and electronic steering. That makes for something that's highly directional, fairly tight beams, fairly strong signal, that are heading up into the sky (in a military context meaning anything trying to get between you and the sats is right above your SAMs/AA/fighter screens), moving very fast, with the built-in (needed anyway) ability to near instantly jump between satellites in different directions of the sky. That's a big list of fundamental physical challenges that omnidirectional low frequency radio or single HEO sats or the like just don't have. It will likely not even be reasonable for a long while to shoot down the constellation (retaliation aside). SpaceX's launch and mass manufacture costs are already cheaper than anyone and Starship will take that down another order of magnitude or more. Starlink sats will be cheaper than ASAT missiles, and orbiting low enough that atmospheric drag means Kessler Syndrome is not a concern either. Attacking the launch site(s) means attacking the continental USA. It seems to add up to a pretty dang hardened looking system? Cyberattacks, sabotage and so on could be real concerns, but to jam a tight beam phased array looking at very specific spots for signal from 10-100 miles away looks hard from a physics point of view. And of course any powerful jammer will by definition be an absolute magnet for HARMs. The US takes SEAD/DEAD very seriously and is thus pretty heavily equipped for that.
- 3y ago