3 ms·
> Funny, some invisible hand just moved my post from being the top comment Looks like a mod downweighted your comment, probably because it was a bit fulminatey
by dang 3y ago
> Funny, some invisible hand just moved my post from being the top comment
Looks like a mod downweighted your comment, probably because it was a bit fulminatey and a bit generic. Those are inauspicious markers for an HN thread, which is why the site guidelines ask people to avoid them (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html).
Your comment wasn't terrible, nor bad enough to get a moderation scolding—though it would have been better if you had shared some interesting details about actual fraud!—always a popular and curious topic—instead of generic rhetoric about it.
However, these markers are particularly bad at the top of a page, because the top subthread has a power-law influence on how the whole discussion ends up going. So when we see such a subthread at the top, we often downweight it, refresh the page, and then repeat the procedure until something more HN-salubrious is at the top.
Actually this way of moderating subthreads is probably the single biggest thing we've ever hit on for thread quality.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- moralestapia 3y agoNice and thorough explanation. The quality of HN content and discussions is indeed great, so I won't question the procedure. :) I honestly didn't thought of that initially and was becoming conspiranoic about what happened, lol. Thanks for the explanation.