5 ms·
This is what gets me about the moon-shot deniers. If NASA was motivated to save expense and risk, doesn't the act of launching the first stages of a bunch of Sa
by stcredzero 15y ago
This is what gets me about the moon-shot deniers. If NASA was motivated to save expense and risk, doesn't the act of launching the first stages of a bunch of Saturn rockets going to mostly squash any savings flat?
Those things are huge, their launch was witnessed by many 10's of thousands, and their flight was tracked by the USSR and anyone else with the technical capability to do so. (Admittedly, the latter is probably only sporadic, but still an effective deterrent.) The second stages -- also huge, also tracked by the USSR and anyone else with the technical capability to do so. The third stages: the same. Even the command module+LEM: freaking conspicuous. And it's not as if you can send them up there, then fake the thing coming back -- you had to actually bring the freaking things back so the USSR and everyone else could track it then too.
So, after going to all that trouble, exactly how much money is going to be saved? How much risk is going to be saved? If you're faking a flight to the moon, and your fake command module misses its burn and flies off into the void, you're going to have to fake the deaths or kill off those astronauts anyways. If anything, one has greatly increased the risks by engaging in a such a huge and technically challenging conspiracy.
Kudos to Bezos for finding the engine!
- mindslight 15y agoMaybe most moon landing deniers are actually just a conspiracy of scientists hoping to goad NASA into doing it again.
- driverdan 15y agoYou give moon landing denier kooks too much credit. They don't care about the evidence.
- conradfr 15y agoYes, the problem is never asking questions, it's not accepting the answers.
- nitrogen 15y agoWouldn't the mirrors left behind by various missions be the most convincing evidence of all?
- stcredzero 15y agoThe problem is that one has to have research-grade equipment in order to make use of them. Whereas first-hand accounts eyewitnesses who saw the Saturn V rockets go up are available to those who want to do the legwork.
- relix 15y agoReflectors, actually. While normally an irrelevant detail, the distinction is quite important here: lasers reflected on mirrors reflect at a complementary angle, lasers reflected on a reflector reflect right back at the source, allowing us to actually detect it.
- mturmon 15y agoFor more: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_Laser_Ranging_experiment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_Laser_Ranging_experiment
- droithomme 15y agoThe audacity of the Apollo program and the amazing engineering successes were so incredible that I am not surprised there are still skeptics lurking about. They are incorrect in their belief, but their doubt is reasonably based. Landing on the moon and returning safely only 66 years after the first powered flight and only a few years into the age of transistors and computers was to put it simply, a completely unbelievable accomplishment and without precedent in human history.
- ComputerGuru 15y agoI honestly cannot think of anything since that has rivaled it in terms of sheer audacity and a leap of pure faith. You'd think with all our technical marvels now, we'd have something that can hold its own against the missions to the moon, but I'm honestly at a loss to suggest anything here.
- spking 15y agoI agree. If you haven't yet seen it, "Failure is not an Option" is an awesome mini-documentary about mission control from the early years through the Apollo program. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG9mFBY1oT8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG9mFBY1oT8
- stcredzero 15y agobut their doubt is reasonably based Until you start looking at evidence you can publicly verify and start analyzing what it would cost to build what people and scientists actually observed, and the downside risks of the same. Really, what would be the worst-case downside for a Saturn 1B or Saturn V first stage? (Answer: a huge, spectacular explosion in front of thousands.) If you're trying to mitigate the costs and risk of failure with a hoax, why would you send up 9 of the former and 13 of the latter? Why would you do more than 1 manned mission? It's much easier to preach to the choir.
- lutorm 15y agoLanding on the moon and returning safely only 66 years after the first powered flight and only a few years into the age of transistors and computers was to put it simply, a completely unbelievable accomplishment and without precedent in human history. Actually, I just plotted the flight distance records from Wikipedia, starting with the Wright Flyer record of .279km in 1903, to 18000km in 1946, to John Glenn's 3 orbits (~120,000km) in 1962 and Apollo 11 distance (~800,000km) in 1969. While the spacecraft points are clearly above the exponential extrapolation of the flight records between 1910 to 1946, they are much less dramatic than the improvement from 1903 to 1915, where flight distance increased by about 4 orders of magnitude. So while the distance flown obviously was without precedent, the rate of improvement was nothing like that of the first decade of flying.
- trothamel 15y ago"doesn't the act of launching the first stages of a bunch of Saturn rockets going to mostly squash any savings flat?" Well, you could save on the catering - maybe. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P6MOnehCOUw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P6MOnehCOUw