3 ms·
With all due respect, I was involved in advanced Windows projects and always thought that InstallShield was s** and beyond its complexity it has an advantage be
by wslh 3y ago
With all due respect, I was involved in advanced Windows projects and always thought that InstallShield was s** and beyond its complexity it has an advantage because of business reasons more than technical ones: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/InstallShield https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/InstallShield
Microsoft promoted it strongly, and mysteriously they never come up with a decent installation support, even for basic desktop apps.
Answering the topic here: it is the business more than the product. With exceptions, as usual.
- RajT88 3y agoInstallShield was the only game in town at first. So it was amazing from that perspective. Windows installer came along and was a lot better. The InstallScript engine carried with it a lot of legacy tech-startup technical debt. Fun fact: InstallShield became a general purpose packaging tool at some point which spit out *.msi packages (and had a bunch of extensions to Windows Installer engine via custom actions). So it was pretty awesome from that perspective. In this day and age Windows Installer itself has a lot of legacy design cruft from the era it was designed for - the late 90's. So you're not wrong, but based on the era InstallShield was more or less crappy depending.
- wslh 3y agoI would like to add that was incredible that MSI were the installation standard and Visual Studio, which is the core of MS development, couldn't generate them! Yes, you can generate vanilla MSIs but are almost never what you want except for trivial installations. Sorry, but I want to add one more thing: the upgrade logic of MSIs is completely wrong, you need a lot of tricks to do an upgrade.
- RajT88 3y agoUpgrades were not that bad if you had a document in one place that explained how they worked (MSFT did not have this concentration of documentation - they are not the best at knowledge management). Patches though... Fuck. I think I could still produce a document that explains everything you need to know about patching but it is a lot more complicated than regular upgrades. At the same time, my career has moved to Cloud stuff now. Is my life better? Definitely not.
- chiph 3y agoI've written some installers using Installshield and later the WiX toolset, and the typical application developer has no appreciation on how difficult it is. "Just copy over the binaries, it's not hard." Well, when your customer is an enterprise who wants to deploy your product hands-off onto five thousand machines, and expects a clean uninstall when they want it removed later - yes, it's that hard. Writing installers really is it's own sub-speciality in software development.