4 ms·
All of this is why I said hunter-gatherers do both. Because at the end of the day, it's not just about efficiency of calorie-gathering anyways. If all your pro
by crazygringo 3y ago
All of this is why I said hunter-gatherers do both.
Because at the end of the day, it's not just about efficiency of calorie-gathering anyways. If all your protein is lean, you'll die without other sources of calories anyways. Generally speaking, you needed hunting to meet your protein requirements, and then gathering to fill in the rest of your calories -- especially since women can gather at the same time while men are out hunting. So even if plant-gathering is less efficient calorically, it's still more efficient for the group, considering the gendered division of labor.
Unless you happen to be Inuit, for example, where you might subsist entirely on things like extremely fatty seal meat, since there's not much gathering to be had. Obviously it depends on great deal on your geography.
My original comment was simply pushing back on the assertion that hunting is "ridiculously" more energy-intensive. If you're good with a bow and arrow and there are lots of antelope around...
- jrochkind1 3y agoMy comment was pushing back on your assertion that hunting is obviously more energy-efficient, I don't think that is in fact backed up or true. The idea that one person can on on average day provide calories to feed 100 (for the day?) is not backed up by anthropological observation of foraging people hunting in the 20th century, and I don't see any reason to assume it would have been true for prehistoric people either. I guess that would have been the much shorter post i could have written.