3 ms·
Watch the series "Alone". It's pretty clear that the contestants cannot survive by foraging for plants alone.
by WalterBright 3y ago
Watch the series "Alone". It's pretty clear that the contestants cannot survive by foraging for plants alone.
- jebarker 3y agoI think that says more about the foraging skills of modern domesticated humans (and the location choices for Alone) than it does about the nutritional viability of a foraged plant based diet.
- WalterBright 3y agoHave you watched the show? If you have, what could they have eaten that they didn't know about?
- jebarker 3y agoI've watched a few episodes. As someone else pointed out, they choose locations where there's not going to be much available food, e.g. early winter Alaska. So you can't draw any conclusions about the viability of getting nutrition from foraging in such inhospitable environments. I can't comment on what they could have eaten that they didn't know about because I'm not a skilled forager either. I'm certain though that someone who lived their whole life as a forager would fair better even if only because they could more efficiently harvest what little is available.
- WalterBright 3y agoIt's clear they had some training on what was available. I doubt the show producers hid knowledge of more substantial flora - if they did, viewers would have made a stink about it. I've been told by a survival expert that gathering food is a full time job, and many of the contestants didn't seem to get that. They'd waste calories building elaborate shelters and carving toys. BTW, if I look around the woods in the PNW, I don't see much flora that could be eaten, even though it's rather lush. Although there are berries and mushrooms, those are far from a complete diet.
- ribosometronome 3y agoI don't think Alone is particularly representative of a hunter-gatherer back in the day. For starters, they're alone rather than existing in a group of people who have had to feed themselves their entire life foraging and hunting. Even if the people are our modern experts in survival, it's hard to replace daily lived knowledge gathered from generations of people. And they're dropped in an unfamiliar (and often particularly harsh?) area. The season I saw had people stranded in the Alaskan wilderness right for the start of winter. Or the frost? One of the notable things about hunter-gatherers is that they were migratory, no? They probably would opt out of trying to survive the winter like that.
- WalterBright 3y agoI was more referring to being able to live off of gathered plants alone. Not farmed plants, and not meat. The contestants had intractable problems with this: 1. not enough calories 2. a seriously unbalanced diet and they'd slowly come unglued.