4 ms·
If you've ever tried digging tubers out of the ground, or walking around all day trying to forage enough low-calorie berries or mushrooms, you'd know that harve
by crazygringo 3y ago
If you've ever tried digging tubers out of the ground, or walking around all day trying to forage enough low-calorie berries or mushrooms, you'd know that harvesting wild plants is probably far more energy-intensive per-calorie on the whole.
While one person spending a day hunting a medium-sized or large-sized animal can feed 100 people. (And similarly trapping, using nets to fish, etc.)
Fortunately we can do both.
- EA-3167 3y agoThe thing is, the tuber never fights back. The energy expended on a fruit/mushroom/tuber/plant hunt is predictable, manageable, and can be expended by a large group. Only fit, trained hunters can reliably bring down an animal capable of feeding 100 people, and even then some of them are going to be injured or killed at some point. There's a reason that a lot of hunting and trapping involves fairly small animals, rather than megafauna; when you're netting birds for example the worst thing that happens is you miss. Fishing is great, if you live near bodies of water with lots of fish in them. Coastal communities probably did eat a LOT of fish for much of human history, but only so many fish come up to the coast. Fishing gear is also a bitch to build and maintain by hand, in cultures that still do it making new nets and repairing old ones is a full time job for at least one member of each family. Animal protein also requires prompt preservation or eating, whereas a bunch of yams, cassava and so on can be reliably kept for a very long time.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoWe had meat preservation techniques for a long time, just not with the fridge
- rtkwe 3y agoThat depends heavily on the abundance of edible in your area, which by necessity were usually the places people were, and the techniques available for you to hunt. In the pre paleolithic era hunts were often long and multi person affairs to trap and exhaust an animal. Even after the invention of stone tools you needed large parties to really even get close to ensuring you were just hunting all day for nothing.
- elzbardico 3y agoIn practice it depends a lot on the environment you live in. As a general rule, the colder/drier the climate, the harder to live from plants alone. In some places the only vegetation is mostly useless for humans, consisting almost only of cellulose, but this can sustain ruminants that can then be hunted or domesticated by humans. On the other hand, hunting in a tropical jungle is pretty difficult, but then you have an abundance of fruits and roots and so, your diet will have far less meat and a lot more plants.
- jrochkind1 3y agoAnd yet, from OP > The anthropologist Richard Lee reported that the !Kung, one of the so-called Bushman people of Southern Africa, got two-thirds of their calories from plants. Nor were they an exception. When he compared fifty-eight foraging societies from around the world, Lee found that half got the majority of their calories from plant foods; another eighteen relied mostly on fishing. Only eleven—less than a fifth—relied on hunting as their primary means of subsistence, and all but one were limited to either the highest or the lowest latitudes, far beyond our African homeland. Now, to be sure, communities found in the 1960s that subsisted mainly from foraging can _not_ be assumed to be representative of pre-historic people, they are living in the 1960s same as everyone. But they had access to hunted game as well as foraged vegetables, if hunting is so much more efficient, why did most of them get most of their calories _not_ from hunting? Because they were choosing to inefficiently spend more labor on collecting plants, when they could have been relaxing instead, because they preferred it culturally? I guess it's possible. Because the efficiency of hunting animals vs harvesting plants isn't universal in actually existing environments humans do and have lived in, but can depend on the specifics of the given ecological location? Seems likely. Maybe the ecologiccal locations most communities the anthropologists looked at in the first half of the 20th century were not representative of pre-historic humans? Certainly could be, but it's certainly not obvious. As OP notes, where hunting seems to beat plant gathering calorically is in extreme environments not representative of African savannah where we thinks humans and their forebears did most of their evolving. But in general, _most_ of the arguments given when people talk about this topic are based on imagination and what people find plausible or seems like a good just-so story to them, not on any kind of evidence at all. It's a topic where people really are drawn to ideological explanations over clear-eyed looks at evidence, I guess because it's not _really_ just about eating and labor, but about all the cultural implications and assumptions that go along with it for people, many of them that become really tied up with gender, as the OP discusses. It is in fact not at all clear that hunting is more labor efficient than collecting plants in general, and what anthropological evidence there is from the 20th century (in which in some cases anthropologists really did do caloric input/output calculations) does not neccessarily suggest it at all. Foraging people anthropologists encountered in the 20th century definitely didn't have the kind of success you suggest at hunting -- multi-person parties went hunting, and did not succesfully kill mega-fauna on every expedition, in observed cultures; what they observed was not that a single-person could reliably bring back meat to feed 100 on a daily expedition.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoWhat about legumes? I thought the tradeoff was decent for those