4 ms·
IF the patch was only edited for style or other minor issues, then the copyright remains with the original contributor. If the patch was completely rewritten fr
by bluGill 3y ago
IF the patch was only edited for style or other minor issues, then the copyright remains with the original contributor. If the patch was completely rewritten from scratch and is very different then not. (linux does not require copyright attribution)
If the poster wants to get a lawyer he can probably force rewriting git history to give him credit. Is it worth it - probably not.
- jacquesm 3y agoBut the OP has copyright. The LKML archive is there for everybody to see, they wrote a bit of code. That code was then modified and that modified version was entered into the repo under the maintainers name, as it usually goes. And that's because when you mail LKML you play by their rules, which have been made very explicit: https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/v4.17/process/submitting-patches.html https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/v4.17/process/submitting-pat... Note the bit about the Co-developed-by tag: "A Co-Developed-by: states that the patch was also created by another developer along with the original author. This is useful at times when multiple people work on a single patch. Note, this person also needs to have a Signed-off-by: line in the patch as well." and "Note, you did not properly sign-off on this commit, so it couldn't be applied anyway :(" From the exchange between the OP and the kernel maintainer. Which may have been the whole issue.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> From the exchange between the OP and the kernel maintainer. Which may have been the whole issue. Well, if it was, the maintainer didn't communicate that well/at all: "I prefer my version".
- bluGill 3y agoNone of that changes the fact that the original patch is copyright by the author, and it is highly likely the courts will consider the changes style issues which do not change copyright ownership. Unless the kernel maintainer can show he didn't look at the patch, only the description of the issue and then recreated the patch from scratch.
- jacquesm 3y agoOh, we're going to court now? Seriously, this is getting way out of hand: when contributing to a project that has been going for more than a few decades you need to first familiarize yourself with how things are done to set your expectations for the interaction appropriately. The Linux kernel group does a pretty good job and they have their own ways of doing things. It's custom - and polite - to get the lay of the land before yelling 'robbery' when what actually happened is exactly what is supposed to happen: the bug got fixed, you got credited for the report and the maintainer spent some of their - precious - time on getting your proposal - because that is what a patch sent to LKML is - fixed and included. And that's ignoring for the moment the fact that the interaction wasn't at all like the OP suggested it was.
- worewood 3y agoIf it were me I wouldn't think it was getting out of hand. Kernel contributions are the kind of thing that goes on your resumé and can land you a dream job. I would look into courts too.
- jacquesm 3y agoThen please never submit any patches to LKML because the last thing a maintainer needs is a court case from some entitled newbie that can't be bothered to read the documentation and on top of that is so focused on accreditation that they are willing to go nuclear over a teensy contribution. FWIW a submission to LKML does not come with any kind of guarantees for either accreditation, use, timeliness or consideration. You are making a small gift to the Linux kernel and all of its users and as such you are being thanked. Hopefully you got more value out of the Linux kernel than you contributed on account of the work that others have put in. The LKML record will suffice to prove your claims of copyright but realize that your work does not stand on its own, it is always going to be within a larger context. Try affixing a (C) Worewood to a patch you intend for inclusion and send it to LKML and see how you'll fare.