3 ms·
This ignores the fact that the standard for what is considered a good edit has risen dramatically over time. Most of the featured articles from the early years
by Alex3917 15y ago
This ignores the fact that the standard for what is considered a good edit has risen dramatically over time. Most of the featured articles from the early years of the site no longer even meet that standard. There are 3,500 featured articles, and almost 1,000 that have become unfeatured as standards have risen.
- jessriedel 15y agoNo, they used the same method to judge edits over the entire sample space. > To test the hypothesis ... we randomly sampled the first edits of newcomers to the English Wikipedia from the earliest days of the project to the present. With the help of some experienced Wikipedians, we hand-categorized the edits of 2,100 new users according to a four point quality scale
- Alex3917 15y agoThat only shows that the edits have been roughly the same quality of time, what I'm saying is that edits of the same quality are now judged much more harshly than they used to be. For example six or seven years ago if you wrote something that was true but unsourced, or else the citation was formatted incorrectly, the text would generally be left up and a higher level editor would get around to hunting down the proper citation eventually. But today these kind of edits would get instantly reverted, even though they create value. The issue is that because so much of Wikipedia is already properly cited, adding new text that is correct but not properly cited temporarily lowers the overall quality of the encyclopedia even though it would ultimately create value if left up and fixed, so essentially what we have now is one of those game theory failures. This really isn't that hard to figure out and all they'd have to do is slightly tweak the design to fix it, so I don't really see why they're having so much trouble on this one.