3 ms·
Has AI been able to figure out conflicting and quickly changing product requirements and implement them on top of existing technical debt? You'll be fine.
by troupo 3y ago
Has AI been able to figure out conflicting and quickly changing product requirements and implement them on top of existing technical debt?
You'll be fine.
- kossTKR 3y agoBut if this development continues AI will surely be able to just parse the entire frontend, then look at the repo, then look at the specifications, then when you ask for a specific feature it will instantly implement it gracefully. I don't see why it wouldn't understand piles of hotfixes on top of each other, or even refactor technical debt in tight coupling with existing or historical specification. Or is there a reason this is not going to happen in a few years?
- generic92034 3y agoIt depends. Did you ever work in Development Support? Understanding requests or bug reports from customers is quite challenging, for trained and experienced developers. In my eyes that would require AGI, which we do not know of, if that can be achieved with the current approach.
- kossTKR 3y agoI actually did , and yes it's extremely challenging and can be rather rage inducing; "it doesn't work" --> what doesn't work --> "the thing" --> what thing --> ∞ ... But the thing is conversations like the above ie. both external support and internal feature requests could theoretically be handled by a GPT-like system also ending up in a ai created custom specification that could both be implemented and documented by the ai system instead of humans? I know we're a few versions out, but still.
- generic92034 3y agoIf just being persistent and willing to iterate solves the issue, then yes, GPT-like systems could do that. If you have to employ creative thinking to even find out what the customer wants, then check it in the system, debug some processes and derive the desired feature or correction, then we are very far from having such a tool, IMHO.
- troupo 3y agoI very much doubt it. "Revert Norway tax code" or "add content restrictions for Turkey" cannot necessarily be deduced from the codebase. And there are thousands of product requirements like that. It might become a better code assist tool some 10 years from now, but it won't be able to implement product decisions.
- raincole 3y ago/s?
- dottjt 3y agoNot yet, but give it time. The concept of self-driving vehicles even a decade ago seemed absurd (or even AI for that matter), but now it all seems like a reality. And that's not even taking into account all the advances we'll have with AI within the next decade that we haven't even thought about. But yeah, you may be right.
- troupo 3y ago> The concept of self-driving vehicles even a decade ago seemed absurd (or even AI for that matter), but now it all seems like a reality. Nope. It's still not close to reality. It's as close to reality as it has been for the past 10 years while it was being hyped up to be close to reality. > And that's not even taking into account all the advances we'll have with AI within the next decade that we haven't even thought about. As with FSD, we may approach an 80% with the rest 20% being insurmountable. Don't get me wrong, these advances are amazing. And I'd love to see an AI capable of what we already pretend it's capable of, but it's not even close to these dreams.
- astrange 3y agoCruise and Waymo are in production in really difficult cities. I think it's definitely in the last 10 years of not being here.
- troupo 3y ago> Cruise and Waymo are in production in really difficult cities. Cruise and Waymo are in production in very tightly fine-tuned and carefully monitored situations in two cities. We've yet to see if that can be easily (or at all) adapted to driving anywhere else.
- zarzavat 3y agoPeople keep saying "ah but it can't do X!". So what? Most of us have multiple decades until we can retire. This AI is getting better every few months. It will be able to do it even faster, better and more cheaply than a human can.
- tayo42 3y agoThere's an idea with some truth to it. The first 90% is easy, finishing and getting it to 100% is hard, maybe almost impossible. So asking "can it do x" is relevant. Becasue it might not
- troupo 3y ago> It will be able to do it even faster, better and more cheaply than a human can. Take what you did in the past year. Write down every product decision taken, every interaction with other teams figuring out APIs you had, all the infra where your code is running and how it was setup and changed, all the design iterations and changes that had to be implemented (especially if you have external partners demanding it). Yes. All that you'd have to input into the AI, and hope it outputs something decent given all that. And yes, you'll have to feed all that into AI all the time because it has no knowledge or memory of "on Monday the new company bet was announced in the all hands" You will be fine.
- Michelangelo11 3y agoSo ... in this example, your job is continually feeding information to the AI from various sources. Why would the AI not be automatically hooked up to all those sources? Building a system that can do that is essentially trivial with the OpenAI API.