3 ms·
MapQuest: “We’ve Come Out Of Hibernation”
- gruseom 18y agoWe see Google Maps in many ways as an endpoint of a search query [...] The people that come to MapQuest are here for the explicit purpose of finding "where is it, how do I get there and what’s nearby." This sounds like dangerous denial to me. I'm admittedly a tech user, but I use Google Maps precisely to find "where is it, how do I get there", because it works better and is cleaner than Mapquest.
- trickjarrett 18y agoThey're fully aware of the threat. That sentence is just corporate rhetoric for avoiding admitting the threat Google provides. MapQuest does a fantastic job and I hope they continue to succeed, a shining example of a niche market that they nail on delivery and suitably monetizing.
- gruseom 18y agoIf I'm ever in their situation, I hope I spend less energy on misleading rhetoric and more on improving my product.
- dmix 18y agoTheir new homepage is marginally better...they actually put the map on the front page. http://www.mapquest.com/beta http://www.mapquest.com/beta It still looks very cluttered. But doesn't everything vs Google?
- aneesh 18y agohttp://maps.live.com/ http://maps.live.com/ Just as clean a page as Google Maps. It's one of the few things (that, and image search) Live does better than Google. Live Maps does local search better, the map labels are better, and Bird's Eye view is impressive.
- unalone 18y agoLive Search also tends to have better results. (Somebody on HN told me this, I didn't believe them, and I checked for myself - it's true.) I don't like Live because I think it's overdone in a lot of ways, but it's my favorite Microsoft product.
- Devilboy 18y agoI fear they may be too late... Google Maps is already the de-facto mapping tech for 'mash-ups' everywhere.
- iigs 18y agoThe bad: It seems to default to "Click to center" instead of "click to zoom, centered here". [Essentially] Nobody wants really precise centering of the Western Hemisphere -- they want to see their house. It doesn't take advantage of my 1600x1200 LCD -- it's bannered to high hell and still fixed-width formatted to fit into a 1024x768(?) screen, and even then the map would be below the fold. If you're going to put a 400x300px banner higher than the map at least kill 75% of that huge brand banner at the top. The "Larger Map" button doesn't work. Grr. The art is still cluttery -- the fonts aren't as nice as Google's and the antialiasing is still second class. From TFA: There were two things going on prior to that time period that explain our low profile. There was considerable effort working on our new back-end technology. It is based on completely new platform technologies that was consuming a fair bit our effort. There was also a bit of miscalculation in that we didn’t do much that was visible to the user. In hindsight we should have been more visible but we knew we needed to get our house in order to do what we wanted to do. -- This is a fantastic example of Mr. Spolsky's "Things You Should Never Do, Part I" -- http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000069.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000069.html Google Street View and MS Live Maps Bird's Eye View have both raised the bar on mapping sites. Hopefully Mapquest has something up their sleeve here. The good: Because they're rendering a single layer (by default) it's amazingly fast -- drags out of pre-downloaded range are coming up with only the faintest flicker, if flickering at all. Of course, when I constrain Google Maps to the same sized canvas it's really fast too. I guess Satellite view + Streets uses overlays. Still pretty fast. I actually believe the VP's comments about their customer base being loyal and their ad clickthrough rates being higher than people think. Whereas Google has the Herculean challenge of figuring out how to monetize the proliferation of mashups and other users of their APIs, these guys target people more like my mom -- arguably less savvy but more likely to click on an ad. The takeaway: Because we are profitable... Excellent! It will be interesting to see how they compare going forward. I have a hard time believing the big three (G,M,Y) have profitable maps units.
- AndrewWarner 18y agoThey're profitable because the site is littered with ads. I have ad block on and I still have to scroll through a series of them to get to my map. Then, once I see what I searched for, MapQuest shows a "pop-up" call out box with links to more ads. ("Want pizza?" "Movie tickets?") Booo.