3 ms·
I'm so so so glad Clay Shirky gave me this idea of thinking of where human potential gets channeled. I think the notion was out before this article (in talks),
by jauntywundrkind 3y ago
I'm so so so glad Clay Shirky gave me this idea of thinking of where human potential gets channeled. I think the notion was out before this article (in talks), but here's one from 2008, Gin, Television, and Social Surplus, that says it well enough. "http://web.archive.org/web/20080708220257/http://www.shirky.com/herecomeseverybody/2008/04/looking-for-the-mouse.html http://web.archive.org/web/20080708220257/http://www.shirky....
There's a gradient here of interactivity. Gilligan's Island was almost purely passive; broadcast television, albeit yes it was a social phenomenon we'd talk about at the office or with friends.
On the other end, there was this kind of idolized view that the online world was a receptacle for interactivity, that we could all be actively engaged. Oh, look at the wikipedia discourse around deciding what to do about the no-longer-a-planet Pluto. A mass of people deciding how to update the article. Wikipedia was a sink for engagement, and some of that was a productive use of human surplus. It idealized the tale, because so much wikipedia usage is passive, but even then: it's self directed, enriching. An available use of human capacity that seems so vastly much better than watching Gilligans Island.
In some ways, things like Factorio are much more like Gilligan's Island than using (activley or passively) Wikipedia. Are the same kind of broadcast programming. But I still think there's a kind of mental engagement here that's different, that's better than where we were. Clicking the mouse is engagement, if not productive engagement, in a way that's different to me from receivership. The brain may be doing useless loops, but it's still an active participant. Being sharp doesn't innately count for anything, but I think that allure of places to reward the brain for being sharp count for something, that they suggest the value & reward of using one's potential. And I think that keeps many from being dull, from rusting out into lower potentials. I think it encodes the positive value system of trying.